Herbert Armstrong's Tangled Web of Corrupt Leaders

Wednesday, March 18, 2026

LCG: How Dare You Have A Critical Opinion! How Dare You!

 



First, it was matzos that those sinful LCG members fell flat on—literally. Now it's daring to question leaders. Can't you LCG brethren, ever do anything right? (Spoiler: Apparently not, according to Charlotte.)

Here we have another uplifting Sabbath message from Dr. Douglas S. Winnail, dripping with that signature blend of gentle correction and implied spiritual peril. Because nothing says "profitable Sabbath" like being reminded—yet again—that your opinions are probably from Satan, and questioning authority is basically the modern equivalent of Korah's rebellion.Christ’s Mind or Our Opinions?

How many times have you said or heard, “Here is how I see it,” or “Here is what I think,” or—gasp—“Here is how I think it should be done?” All too often, these dangerous, divisive comments are directed at people in leadership positions—even in the Church! (The horror!)

Moses was criticized by men who held different opinions (Numbers 16:1–33). Peter differed with Jesus over a matter and even rebuked Christ (Matthew 16:21–23). In both cases, the people expressing those critical opinions did not recognize the real source of their negative and divisive thoughts and actions. (Hint: It wasn't the Holy Spirit giving them discernment—it was obviously pride, rebellion, or worse.)

Before we start sharing our pesky “different” opinions, we need to remember God’s warning: “My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways My ways” (Isaiah 55:8). We also need to remember Solomon’s timeless wisdom: “A fool vents all his feelings, but a wise man holds them back” (Proverbs 29:11). (Translation: Shut up and submit—true wisdom looks a lot like silence.)

As true Christians, we need to develop a godly perspective that reflects the mind of Jesus Christ (Philippians 2:5). Which, conveniently, seems to align perfectly with whatever headquarters has decided this week.

Christ’s Mind or Our Opinions? How many times have you said or heard, “Here is how I see it,” or “Here is what I think,” or “Here is how I think it should be done?” All too often these comments are directed at people in leadership positions—even in the Church. Moses was criticized by men who held different opinions (Numbers 16:1–33). Peter differed with Jesus over a matter and even rebuked Christ (Matthew 16:21–23). In both cases, the people expressing critical opinions did not recognize the real source of their negative and divisive thoughts and actions. Before we start sharing our “different” opinions, we need to remember God’s warning, “My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways My ways” (Isaiah 55:8). We also need to remember Solomon’s warning, “A fool vents all his feelings, but a wise man holds them back” (Proverbs 29:11). As true Christians, we need to develop a godly perspective that reflects the mind of Jesus Christ (Philippians 2:5). 
Have a profitable Sabbath, 
Douglas S. Winnail

Translation for the rest of us Laodiceans still clinging to our dangerous "opinions": First headquarters polices your unleavened bread recipe (too fluffy? Too tasty? Too innovative? Straight to the sin bin). Now they're policing your very thoughts. Because nothing fosters unity like constantly reminding members that disagreeing—even politely, even privately—is proof you're not really converted.

At this rate, the next update will warn against breathing too independently, lest it reflect "our ways" instead of God's. After all, why risk members thinking for themselves when you can just quote scripture to keep everyone in line?

Keep those mouths shut, and those minds blank, brethren. Charlotte knows best. Always has. Always will. Or at least that's the official opinion we're allowed to have.



11 comments:

  1. I guess our opinions have to be in line with what the ministry thinks (even when they are wrong)? Who started the apostacy in the WCG after HWA died? Was it the "ministry" or members? This kind of wrong thinking to follow a minister has continued with most of the splinters that erupted from the demise of the WCG.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Whether it's the church or society, we have all been conditioned to "trust" authority. DOCTOR Winnail, DOCTOR Fauci, you know, the EXPERTS!

    ReplyDelete
  3. That's part of Doug's problem. He cites Moses and Christ leadership. But the problem is thinking that their "leadership" is on par with Christ or Moses who were the two mediators. It's not and never will be! Winnail has been saying the "this is my opinion" complaint for over 20 years. Well, then let the earth swallow them up Dougie.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When a true minister receives a differing opinion on something from a member he should say "great! let's discuss it". It could be a learning experience for the member, or, for the minister.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Jehovah's Witnesses use no fig leaf on this point when they warn their members of "the sin of independent thinking." All of today's denominations steal various ploys from each other.
    Btw, in one of his TV programs, Kenneth Copeland insisted that God was whispering in Adam's ear, telling him what to name the animals. So forget about the little people using their own minds.
    Genesis 2:19 ...and whatsoever Adam called every living creature, that was the name thereof.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Although my opinions, critical thinking, and the amount of rope I had allowed HWA led me to leave following the " great disappointment" of 1975, I soon recognized some deficiencies with which 19 years in R/WCG had left me. These are essential when functioning in the business world, and are actually expected. You marginalize yourself without them.

    I found that I had been left with zero negotiating skills! You simply do not negotiate with parents, ministers, or authority figures in the Armstrong culture. And, that's pretty much the essence of what Winnail is saying in his latest missive. You do as you are told, and that's it!

    The second deficiency was that I existed in fear and awe of any authority figure I encountered. Even a lowly production manager, or team leader. And, yet my job involved influencing these people and their opinions. They were the individuals who authorized payment for our services. I would freeze up, and get that deer in the headlights look on my face rather than being able to deal effectively and in the business-like manner which was expected when there were differences of opinion. Educating people out of a mindset was a necessary part of the job, and my initial lack of appropriate skills left me standing before them figuratively naked and barefoot! Weak and ineffective!

    Fortunately for me, I violated another tenet of Armstrongism! I obtained help from a professional therapist who helped me to begin to take control of areas in which I had been left weak. Also, I read a variety of self-help materials. I ended up developing tact as well, in employing my new skills. Frankly, it has been a life-long process, and I had much catch-up work to do. I learned that in the business world, your raise becomes effective the minute you do!

    Authoritarian religious cults do not strengthen people. By equating their leaders with God, they leave members in very weakened frames of mind. It becomes a life long pathology!

    BB

    ReplyDelete
  7. While I was in the most stable, least risky, and most profitable part of my profession, a council of elder ministers in LCG strongly advised me (unprompted) to pivot into the least profitable, most unstable, and riskiest part of it.

    It must have been satanic on my part to disregard his advice.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You fake ministers, get on here and post this stuff mocking real Christians while still on the payroll of the church. You will have a lot to answer for!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Jesus apparently didn't criticize the Pharisees, then.

    God's "controversy with the nations" in Jeremiah 25 must not have criticized them.

    And what do we call those comments about group keeping Passover in I Corinthians 11?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Expertise and authority are not necessarily evil or problematic when accompanied with humility. I've know ministers in the church who were very approachable, and they helped me when I really needed it. I still have great respect for them. Corrupt leaders, on the other hand, always assume the worst of someone's motives. If you dare deviate from the official narrative, they say:

    You have an "idea baby" !
    You're not trusting God.
    You are trying to take over (destroy) the church.
    You're pushing conspiracy theories!

    This is clearly an area where "by their fruits you shall know them".

    ReplyDelete
  11. Exodus 12:18 (ESV) states: "In the first month, from the fourteenth day of the month at evening, you shall eat unleavened bread until the twenty-first day of the month at evening.

    Which is it?
    1....beginning 14th to beginning of 21st
    2....beginning of 14th to end of 21st
    3....end of 14th to end of 21st
    4....end of 14th to beginning of 21st

    ReplyDelete