Herbert Armstrong's Tangled Web of Corrupt Leaders

▼

Friday, November 13, 2026

A Coal for the Mouth, Hot Air for the Message






The Live Coal on Their Lips: Armstrongism's Self-Appointed Prophets

There is something particularly revealing about the way Armstrongist leaders appropriate Isaiah 6 to support their claims of prophetic authority. The account of Isaiah's encounter with God and the live coal placed upon his lips has become convenient imagery for religious personalities who want their followers to believe they have received some extraordinary divine commissioning. Unfortunately for them, the actual passage teaches something quite different from the self-important message they would like people to accept.

When Isaiah encountered God's holiness, his first reaction was not to boast about being specially chosen or announce that he had been appointed to restore lost biblical truths. Instead, he recognized his own unworthiness, declaring, "Woe is me! for I am undone; because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of a people of unclean lips." Isaiah understood that he was a sinful man standing before a holy God, and he made no attempt to elevate himself above others.

The live coal was brought from the altar by a seraphim, who touched Isaiah's mouth and declared that his iniquity had been taken away and his sin purged. This was an act of divine cleansing, not a religious credential that Isaiah could use to establish authority over other believers. Isaiah did not purify himself, appoint himself, or manufacture an experience to convince others that he deserved their unquestioning loyalty. God was responsible for the cleansing and God was responsible for the commission that followed.

When God asked, "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Isaiah responded, "Here am I; send me." His commission was to deliver a difficult message to a spiritually hardened nation, not to establish a religious empire, collect followers, or convince people that salvation depended upon belonging to his organization. Isaiah's calling was about faithfully delivering God's message, not making himself the center of attention.

Armstrongism has repeatedly turned this biblical principle upside down. Herbert Armstrong claimed a unique end-time commission, and various splinter-group leaders have subsequently claimed special authority to restore, correct, or complete what they believe he left unfinished. Each generation seems to produce another self-appointed prophetic personality convinced that God has reserved a special position just for him. Apparently, the coal never stops being passed around in these organizations!

The New Covenant makes such claims even harder to defend. Hebrews 10:19-22 teaches that believers have access to God through Jesus Christ, while 1 Timothy 2:5 identifies Christ as the one mediator between God and humanity. First Peter 2:9 describes believers collectively as a royal priesthood, and 1 John 2:20, 27 speaks of the anointing believers have received. Nowhere does the New Testament establish a modern religious personality who alone possesses the spiritual authority to interpret God's will or demand unquestioning submission.

Jesus warned about false prophets and instructed His followers to recognize them by their fruits (Matthew 7:15-20). Titles, prophetic claims, elaborate interpretations, and declarations of divine appointment are not proof of legitimacy. Paul even warned in Galatians 1:8 that anyone preaching another gospel should be rejected, regardless of how impressive their credentials might appear. No religious leader is exempt from examination simply because he claims to speak for God.

Isaiah's experience should produce humility in anyone who reads it honestly. His encounter began with an overwhelming recognition of his own inadequacy, followed by cleansing and a commission to serve. That is quite different from modern religious personalities who seem convinced they have been selected to correct every other Christian, restore forgotten truths, expose everyone outside their organization, and announce the final prophetic timetable.

The live coal in Isaiah 6 was an act of divine cleansing connected with a specific prophetic commission. It was never intended to become a transferable religious credential for men seeking to establish their own authority. The New Covenant does not need another self-appointed Elijah, restorationist, prophetic celebrity, or religious personality demanding recognition as God's exclusive spokesman. It needs believers who remain faithful to Jesus Christ rather than surrendering their discernment to men who continually elevate themselves.

Perhaps these supposed prophets should consider Isaiah's first words before boasting about their own spiritual credentials: "Woe is me! for I am undone." If God really has placed a coal upon their lips, why does so much of what comes out of them seem devoted to establishing their own authority rather than exalting Jesus Christ?

10 comments:

  1. One thing that is a well established facts with Bob, Gerald and Samuel is that they are all grievous sinners! That coal has not purified them of sin and certainly has NOT given them the right to speak.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1. Religious folks tell us there is no hope in man.
    2. So, they say, put your faith in God.
    3. Which God?
    4. The one that MEN told you about. Refer to point 1.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When these groups tell their members to put their faith in God, "God" is just a code word for the ministers. They only mention God if it reflects on them, otherwise the emphesis is on their church leader and ministry. A simple proof is that they hide that Christ directly leads members with no middleman ministers involved. Out of power lust, they have usurped Christ's responsibilities. They are rebels.

      Delete
    2. Has God himself never touched your life 8:27?

      Delete
  3. The alternative to the bible's "prove all things" (ie, evidence plus a line of reasoning) is blindly believing authority figures. This is the argument from authority logic fallacy, since authority has a history of fallacy. Eg, Herb's 1975.
    "An argument from authority (argumentum ad verecundiam) is a reasoning form that uses an authority figure's opinion or testimony as evidence to support a claim."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To put it into street language, HWA and the people he mentored to carry his message were a bunch of spiritual pendejos masking as authority figures. The blind leading the blind.

      Delete
  4. Paul even warned in Galatians that anyone preaching another gospel should be rejected, regardless of how impressive their credentials might appear.>>

    these pompous ACOGs are so deluded they quote this same verse as if doing so it makes their own false prophetic gospels legitimate in their own eyes

    ReplyDelete
  5. We're in the time of scattering/shattering - Dan 12:7, at the end of 6000 years give or take a year or two?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Coal on their tongues was supposed to impress us? The two witnesses, who never materialized in Armstrongism, were going to breathe fire!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The two witnesses, who never materialized in Armstrongism

      Actually, there have been DOZENS of Armstrongites who at one time or another have claimed to be one or both of the two witnesses. It seems that unlike Christianity, which counsels and fosters humility, Armstrongism attracts individuals who harbor a deep desire to be superior to those around them. For most, HWA"s racialized Gnosticism fills that need sufficiently, but there remain a few -- the Bob Thiels and Sam Kitchens, etc. -- who form their entire identity around the idea that God is using them in a way that He isn't using you.

      Delete