It is another installment in the endless Armstrongist "Hold Fast or Die" series. In this short video from the Matthew24Signs channel (tied to the ultra-tiny "God's Church Holding Fast" crowd), Mark Little and company solemnly declare that Paul's "falling away" (2 Thessalonians 2:3) was fulfilled right after Herbert W. Armstrong died in 1986, when the Worldwide Church of God started tossing out HWA's special package of "restored truths." Anyone who doesn't cling to the full HWA canon-Sabbath as the identifying sign, Holy Days, tithing, British-Israelism, the precise government structure, the place-of-safety escape, the dual resurrection details, and every other unique Armstrongian twist-is either Laodicean or already apostate. Only the pure remnant who never let a single page of HWA literature slip from their sweaty grip will keep their crown.
It's the same old story: the New Covenant is apparently too quiet, too settled, and too insufficient. The New Covenant (Jeremiah 31:31-34, Hebrews 8-10, Galatians, Romans 3-8) gives the believer a peaceful heart precisely because righteousness is by faith in Christ's finished work. The law is written on the heart by the Spirit; the old-covenant shadows and the endless external checklist are no longer the measuring stick. Peace, assurance, and rest in Christ are the actual fruit.
That is intolerable to the "Holding Fast" mindset. A peaceful heart does not generate the continuous low-grade panic required to keep the remnant pure and the tithes flowing. So the video (and the entire genre) must constantly whip the audience into a frenzy: You might lose your crown. You might be Laodicean. You might miss the place of safety. You might have already fallen away if you so much as question one of HWA's unique doctrines or notice that mainstream Christianity has the basic gospel right. The "love of the truth" is redefined as love of the entire HWA archive. Any move toward the New Covenant's freedom from law as a means of righteousness is branded the prophesied apostasy.
It's a closed loop that can never rest. The more the New Covenant offers settled assurance ("it is finished," "no condemnation," "the law of the Spirit of life has set you free"), the harder the message must work to manufacture urgency, fear of missing out on Philadelphia status, and suspicion of anyone who actually enjoys peace with God without the full Armstrongian scaffolding. The video's earnest "You need to know!" is just the latest reminder that, for these groups, a quiet conscience is the real threat. Frenzy is the product. The New Covenant keeps getting in the way.
Video here: The Falling Away
Beware: this will give you a bad case of PTSD.


This becomes just hilarious when you realize that each of these guys, as individuals, takes himself very seriously. It would not surprise me in the least if each actually laughed at the other Armstrong francisees, thinking, "I'm nothing like these other clowns, I'm the real deal!" And yet, they are all equally ridiculous!
ReplyDeleteI was trying to come up with a metaphor to drive the point home. When David Bowie came out, teenage boys "borrowing" their sisters' cosmetics? The ridiculous things that people do to imitate their idols!
The WCG defined Christianity purely as a certain set of beliefs. Everything else was subordinated to this. For the sake of control, harming members mental health and stunting their overall growth was the church culture. The only permitted exception was growth along narrow corridors such as public speaking.
ReplyDeleteThe church didn't implode for no reason.
The WCG defined Christianity purely as a certain set of beliefs. Everything else was subordinated to this. For the sake of control, harming members mental health and stunting their overall growth was the church culture. The only permitted exception was growth along narrow corridors such as public speaking.
ReplyDeleteThe church didn't implode for no reason.
Why does this blog not take against Jews and Judiasim? They too take the 7th day sabbath as a sign.
ReplyDeleteOh! Another one who thinks the only reason we take umbrage with Armstrongism is the sabbath????????????????? Oh well! That's what your dimwitted mimisters teach you.
DeleteActually, the sabbath is pretty cool. One day in 7 off? One day to decompress and cleanse the mind of all the crap that happens on the job the second five days of the week?
No, it was the child beating, the fear mongering over false prophecy, your minister becoming an intrusive Snoop Dog into your personal and private things, the constant guilt trip over not digging deeper and giving more money, authoritarianism, adults treated as children, obsessive compulsiveness over nearly everything, etc.
No way does Judaism suck that bad! It'd probably be a good change for most COG members to go to Temple and secretly believe in Jesus.
11:07 This blog is all about Armstrongism not Mormonism (Smithism) or Adventism (Whitism) or Catholicism (Papism) etc and not about other religions like Islam (Muhammadanism) or Judaism (Talmudism) either. These all have their critics but this blog is about HWA, his R/WCG and all of its Armstrongist offshoots.
Delete11.07 Most Jews do not claim that all Christians must become Sabbath-keepers
DeleteSaying 7th day sabbath is a sign is not necessarily saying 'all christians must become..'
DeleteSaying 7th day sabbath is a sign is not necessarily saying 'all christians must become..'
Delete"...Your minister becoming a snoop dog into your personal and private things..'
DeleteThese days those in authority snooping on members can cross boundaries into criminal lawbreaking.
It seems to me that all religious organizations teach a mixture of truth and error. No human organization is going to get everything right!
ReplyDeleteVERY true, 3:40. Generally, people will not believe that of their own church.
DeleteWe must draw the line somewhere. If you discover that your church is abusive and toxic, we know that those things are not fruits of the Spirit. People with the gift of discernment will leave such environments, and seek better answers and solutions.
Not a wise answer 6:39 at all. You try and manipulate readers.
Delete11:17: If any manipulation is being done itis these Armstrong systems who have developed finely honed powers of persuasion/propaganda including ways to ignore all the lies of the fake apostle. There was nothing improper about the answer at 6:39 in referring to testing the fruits of a system.
DeleteAre you for real, 11:17? The whole idea of this blog is to get people to leave the old vomit behind!!! To see it for what it is. To realize that the teachings of HWA totally ruin you, mentally, physically, spiritually, socially and emotionally! Why do you think Armstrong ministers don't want their people hanging out with us?
DeleteBB
You all shout and bawl in your comments overflowing with certainity, but the truth is you all never left.
DeleteSome of you even returned.
Welcome to the Hotel California! Armstrongism is such an insidious mind rot that it requires an entire lifetime to scrape all the $hit from the bottoms of your shoes. I agree with what you wrote, 12:36. Just not the way in which you might have intended. You, yourself are a primary example of an Armstrong victim! Just wait until you begin YOUR recovery! Only then will you realize.
DeleteYou assume much. Repent from your wicked ways and turn to Jesus and his honest way. Many talk the talk but don't walk it. Many. From all sides. Including yours.
DeleteI learn't as a child from the best worst example of Garner ted. You ones here are not so far removed from him. He lived an empty illusion and blamed his dad for everything. He talked the talk. Think on that. But you won't.
Clicked on the video - and YouTube showed me a UCG/Beyond Today ad first! Take that, Mr. Little.
ReplyDeleteHe's shepherding the "little flock".
ReplyDeleteSounds too much like other churches in the world to impress me.
ReplyDeleteJESUS said he will spew people out of his mouth. Well, you all have been spewed out! So was Herbert the child rapist. In the same company as the rest of you. Spewed out.
ReplyDelete