Herbert Armstrong's Tangled Web of Corrupt Leaders

▼

Monday, November 16, 2026

Celtic Throne: Oklahoma's Armstrongist Missionaries Disguised as Irish Dancers!







Thanks for reader here for the heads-up...

It is weird watching the Philadelphia Church of God dress up its religious ambitions in Irish costumes and send its dancers into public squares in Israel, where unsuspecting spectators are treated to what appears to be an innocent cultural entertainment. Smiling performers, elaborate costumes, energetic dancing, and traditional Irish music make for a wonderful spectacle. What the average passerby probably doesn't realize is that behind this production stands Gerald Flurry's Philadelphia Church of God, an American Armstrongist cult with a rather extraordinary theological agenda.

The Jerusalem Post published a review of Celtic Throne in June 2025, and its observations were particularly entertaining. Reviewer Herb Keinon discovered that this supposedly Irish troupe wasn't actually from Ireland at all. Most of its approximately 40 performers came from Oklahoma City and belonged to five American families, including the Flurry family. Jude Flurry was the principal dancer, his sister Vienna was a co-creator and choreographer, and their parents were producers. The reviewer even described the arrangement as something resembling the Von Trapp family of Irish dancing. He also found the storyline, involving an ancient Irish figure traveling from Jerusalem to Ireland, difficult to follow and rather nonsensical. Apparently, even the Jerusalem Post couldn't quite figure out what ancient Irish history had to do with all that dancing!

Of course, there is a little more to this production than Irish footwork. Celtic Throne was created by Herbert W. Armstrong College, an institution operated by Gerald Flurry's Philadelphia Church of God locarted in Edmund Oklahoma. This is the same organization that promotes Herbert Armstrong's teachings, elevates Gerald Flurry's prophetic authority, and continually finds ways to incorporate its peculiar interpretations of biblical history into practically everything it does. The production connects Irish dance to ancient Israel, King David, and the supposed migration of Israelites into the British Isles. Why simply put on an Irish dance show when you can turn it into another traveling advertisement for Armstrongist theology?

That is what makes the public presentation so interesting. Spectators see an energetic group of young American performers sharing an entertaining show, but they aren't necessarily aware of the religious cult behind the production or the theological message woven into its presentation. The dancers themselves may be genuinely enthusiastic about their craft, and their abilities deserve recognition. The issue is the larger religious enterprise using an appealing cultural production to promote its identity and message.

One can only imagine how different the advertising might look if every public performance began with an announcement identifying the troupe as a production of Gerald Flurry's Philadelphia Church of God, complete with an explanation of its beliefs about Herbert Armstrong, biblical prophecy, and the modern descendants of ancient Israel. That might make a few spectators reconsider whether they had come to watch Irish dancing or attend an unexpected Armstrongist recruitment presentation.

There is nothing wrong with Irish dancing, and there is certainly nothing wrong with Americans enjoying Irish culture. But let's not pretend Celtic Throne is simply an ordinary Irish dance company. It is an elaborate theatrical production of an American religious cult that has managed to turn Irish dancing into another vehicle for its peculiar prophetic worldview.

So enjoy the dancing, admire the costumes, and appreciate the considerable effort these young performers have invested in their craft. Just remember that behind the Oklahoma footwork is an organization whose leader apparently believes that even a little Irish dancing can help tell the story of God's supposedly exclusive end-time work.

Riverdance gives you Irish dancing. 

Celtic Throne gives you Irish dancing, ancient Israelites, King David, and a generous helping of Gerald Flurry's religious imagination.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Crackpot Bob Declares that Cannibalism is NOT Healthy! Who knew?!?!?!?!?!?!?


Crackpot Bob declares that cannibalism is not healthy.


The Soon-Coming Cannibal Buffet: When Armstrongist Prophecy Finally Eats Itself

Just hours after featuring an article talking about the doom-and-gloom self-appointed prophets and their false gospel they prattle on about day after day, God's most amazing crackpot prophet, Crackpot Bob, opened his warped mind and spewed out a long article on cannibalism. 

There are few things quite as bizarre as watching Armstrongism rummage through its dusty prophetic filing cabinets in search of something to keep their dwindling followers frightened and under their control. Just when you think the movement has exhausted its supply of end-time disasters, self-appointed prophet Crackpot Bob arrives with another cheery little announcement: Americans may soon be eating their neighbors.

According to the long-held Armstrongite tradition, the United States is headed toward a future in which the grocery stores are empty, the economy has collapsed, famine is everywhere, and your next-door neighbor might be looking suspiciously appetizing to someone who has been listening to too many Armstrongist prophecy lectures.

Welcome to another installment of Crackpot Bob's Wonderful World of Biblical Doom, where absolutely nothing good is ever just around the corner, unless, of course, it involves Bob explaining why everyone should be listening to him.

According to Crackpot Bob's latest article, cannibalism is prophesied to return to America and other English-speaking nations. He dusts off the familiar passages from Leviticus, Deuteronomy, Lamentations, and Ezekiel, adds a generous helping of Herbert Armstrong's old famine predictions, throws in some references to food inflation, international conflicts, and the price of fertilizer, and voilà! We have another prophetic masterpiece predicting that your grandchildren may eventually become somebody's dinner.

The Wonderful World of Armstrongist Biblical Cuisine

Crackpot Bob spends considerable time explaining that cannibalism is unhealthy. He even discusses Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and the dangers associated with consuming human brain tissue. Thank goodness for that clarification. I suppose we can all sleep a little easier knowing that Bob has taken time out of his prophetic schedule to remind us that eating human beings isn't particularly good for our health.

Apparently, this is what passes for cutting-edge biblical scholarship in the Continuing Church of God.

He then trots out Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14 to establish which animals God permits people to eat. Since human beings don't have cloven hooves, chew cud, or possess fins and scales, Bob concludes that human flesh is not on God's approved menu.

Well, there is a theological breakthrough for the ages. Somewhere, I suspect, generations of biblical scholars are slapping their foreheads because they never thought to investigate whether human beings qualified as kosher livestock.

But the real entertainment begins when Crackpot Bob moves from dietary restrictions to prophecy.

America's Future: Supermarkets Closed, Neighbors Served

Crackpot Bob insists that biblical passages describing cannibalism during ancient sieges are warnings about the future of modern America and the other English-speaking nations he believes constitute the lost tribes of Israel. Deuteronomy 28, Lamentations 2, and other passages describing the terrible consequences of ancient warfare and famine become, in his hands, a preview of what awaits modern Americans. And not just any Americans. Your neighbors. Your friends. Your relatives. Apparently, the entire country is destined for a future in which the neighborhood barbecue takes on an entirely new and disturbing meaning.

The old Worldwide Church of God was already selling this particular brand of prophetic horror back in 1969. Crackpot Bob helpfully reproduces material from a Tomorrow's World article that warned readers that one-third of Britain and America would die from famine and disease. The article practically invited readers to imagine the horror happening on their own streets.

Nearly six decades later, here we are, still recycling the same terrifying material. Apparently, Armstrongist prophecy has an exceptionally long shelf life, even when its expiration date has passed several times.

One might reasonably ask why the same old predictions keep getting repackaged for every new generation. Didn't Herbert Armstrong and his ministers spend decades telling people that the end was practically upon them? Weren't members repeatedly warned that the Great Tribulation was just around the corner? How many prophetic timetables, political developments, international crises, and supposed signs of the end have come and gone?

Apparently, the answer is simple: just keep moving the goalposts and find another frightening headline.

The Great Tribulation: Crackpot Bob's Favorite Entertainment

There is something particularly revealing about the enthusiasm with which Armstrongist leaders continually return to the subject of the Great Tribulation. For ordinary people, the thought of famine, war, disease, and widespread human suffering is something to dread and work to prevent. For Armstrongist prophecy enthusiasts, however, these disasters become almost a religious spectator sport. Every international conflict, every economic downturn, every increase in food prices, and every political disagreement can be squeezed into the prophetic machinery. The more frightening the possibilities, the more material there is for another article, video, sermon, or fundraising appeal.

Crackpot Bob's article even suggests that the coming famine could arrive within the next decade or so. How wonderfully precise! Apparently, the prophetic calendar has once again been updated, although readers might be forgiven for wondering how many previous predictions have been allowed to expire without so much as an apology.

And naturally, there is a solution to all this impending misery: listen to God, obey the commandments as interpreted by Armstrongist leadership, get your spiritual life in order, and join the improperly named Continuing Church of God.

When Ancient Judgment Passages Become Modern Threats

The biggest problem with Crackpot Bob's presentation isn't that the Bible contains passages describing cannibalism during catastrophic sieges. It certainly does. Those passages are disturbing precisely because they describe the unimaginable suffering that human beings can experience during warfare, starvation, and social collapse. The problem is the confident leap from those ancient historical and prophetic passages to the assertion that they specifically predict cannibalism in modern America. That conclusion requires considerably more than quoting a handful of frightening verses.

Deuteronomy 28 is part of the covenant warning delivered to ancient Israel. Lamentations describes the devastation surrounding Jerusalem's destruction. These passages deserve serious historical, literary, and theological consideration. They should not automatically be transformed into a personalized horror movie about modern Americans simply because someone has decided that Britain and America are the modern descendants of ancient Israel.

And that is where Armstrongism repeatedly gets itself into trouble. It begins with a predetermined prophetic interpretation and then rummages through Scripture looking for verses that can be made to support it. Rather than allowing the biblical text to speak within its own historical and theological context, everything becomes evidence for the same tired prophetic narrative.

War? Prophecy!

Food inflation? Prophecy!

Fertilizer shortages? Prophecy!

International conflict? Prophecy!

Cannibalism? Well, naturally, prophecy!

At this rate, if the local supermarket runs out of bananas, somebody in the Armstrongist universe will probably discover that Habakkuk predicted it.

Jesus Had Something Better to Offer Than a Diet of Doom

Perhaps the saddest part of this entire spectacle is what gets lost beneath the endless Armstrongist fascination with catastrophe.

The Christian message is supposed to be about reconciliation, mercy, hope, forgiveness, and the promise of God's kingdom. Yet Armstrongism has spent generations cultivating a religious atmosphere in which believers are constantly reminded that they are living in the most dangerous period in human history, that civilization is about to collapse, and that almost everyone outside their particular religious circle is headed for terrible suffering.

Where is the good news in all this? Where is the emphasis on loving one's neighbor, feeding the hungry, caring for the vulnerable, and working toward a more compassionate world? Instead, we get another installment of prophetic disaster entertainment, complete with ancient cannibalism passages, modern political anxieties, and Crackpot Bob explaining why America might eventually turn into a biblical buffet.

The New Covenant does not require Christians to spend their lives obsessively anticipating the gruesome destruction of their neighbors. Jesus called people to love their neighbors, not speculate about whether those neighbors might eventually become dinner.

Same Old Armstrongism, Just a Different Menu

The improperly named Continuing Church of God may have a different name, a different website, and a different self-appointed prophetic personality at the helm, but the product remains remarkably familiar. Herbert Armstrong sold the fear. His successors inherited the merchandise. Crackpot Bob has simply added a few modern headlines and another round of end-time culinary speculation.

The formula never changes: frighten people with biblical catastrophes, insist that those catastrophes are just around the corner, identify the special prophetic significance of current events, and remind readers that they need to pay attention to the organization's warnings. And tomorrow? There will undoubtedly be another article explaining why something else terrible is about to happen.

Perhaps next week Crackpot Bob can investigate whether the Four Horsemen have made reservations at the local Golden Corral. Maybe he can produce a video explaining whether the Beast will introduce ration cards, whether the False Prophet will operate the neighborhood food bank, or whether the Great Tribulation will finally put an end to Taco Tuesday.

One thing is certain: the Armstrongist prophetic kitchen never closes.

After decades of failed predictions, recycled fear-mongering, and increasingly imaginative interpretations of Scripture, perhaps it is time for Crackpot Bob to consider a subject that Armstrongism has never been particularly good at serving: hope.

Because if there is one thing the world needs less of, it is another self-appointed prophet gleefully announcing that civilization is about to collapse while insisting that everyone else should be terrified.

Crackpot Bob fails to realize that the Bible is supposed to point people toward God, not turn every international crisis into an advertisement for your next prophecy video.

And if your version of Christianity has reached the point where you are spending your days warning people that their neighbors might become their next meal, perhaps it is time to step away from the prophecy charts, put down the microphone, and reread the Gospels.

Preferably before dinner.

Armstrongism's Gospel of War: When the Destruction of Humanity Becomes Good News


Armstrongism's Gospel of War: 
When the Destruction of Humanity Becomes Good News


A reader here wrote in a comment: 

They have what is called the "Gospel of War" and not the "Gospel of Peace." It's the good news of wars and rumors of wars.

For decades, Armstrongism has cultivated an unhealthy fascination with the destruction of the United States, Great Britain, and the other nations it claims are descended from the ancient Israelites. Its prophetic imagination is dominated by national catastrophe, military invasions, economic collapse, mass death, captivity, and the eventual humiliation of entire populations. Apparently, the good news of the Kingdom of God requires a rather spectacular amount of bad news for everyone else first. In Armstrongist theology, the destruction of nations is not simply something to be lamented or something humanity should desperately seek to avoid. It is practically the main attraction.

There is something deeply disturbing about a religious movement that spends so much of its time anticipating the deaths of millions of people and treating those deaths as confirmation that its leaders understood biblical prophecy all along. Armstrongist publications and sermons have repeatedly returned to the familiar scenario: two-thirds of the population perishes, survivors are taken captive, young people are transported to Europe as slaves, and the remaining population is subjected to unimaginable suffering. The United States and Britain are supposedly headed for an appointment with national annihilation, and Armstrongism has been selling tickets to the spectacle for generations.

One almost wonders whether its adherents will be disappointed if these things never happen. After all, what becomes of decades of prophetic speculation, endless warnings, and carefully cultivated anticipation if the predicted catastrophe never arrives? What happens to the endless parade of self-appointed prophetic authorities when the nations they have condemned continue to exist? Apparently, the greatest threat to Armstrongist theology is not the destruction of America, but the possibility that America might survive its predictions.

The Gospel of War Instead of the Gospel of Peace

The apostle Paul described the Christian message as the Gospel of Peace. Armstrongism, however, seems to have developed an entirely different version. We might appropriately call it the Gospel of War. Its good news consists of wars and rumors of wars, military invasions, national humiliation, mass casualties, captivity, and the destruction of societies. It is a strange sort of good news that requires millions of people to suffer before the faithful can finally celebrate that their prophetic teachers were right.

Jesus certainly spoke about wars and rumors of wars. In Matthew 24, he warned his disciples about the turmoil that would characterize the world. But notice something Armstrongist teachers conveniently overlook: Jesus specifically instructed his followers not to be alarmed by these events. He also warned against being deceived by those who claimed special prophetic knowledge. The passage was not an invitation to develop an elaborate obsession with international catastrophes or to turn every military conflict into another opportunity to announce that the end was finally approaching.

In fact, Jesus' message was remarkably different from the nationalistic doom-and-gloom theology Armstrongism has promoted. When Jesus spoke about the Kingdom of God, he spoke about reconciliation, mercy, forgiveness, love of neighbor, and the transformation of human relationships. He instructed his followers to love their enemies, pray for those who persecuted them, and become peacemakers. Apparently, these teachings are considerably less exciting to people who would rather spend their evenings studying prophetic charts about the coming destruction of the United States.

The New Covenant Has a Very Different Message

The New Covenant fundamentally changes the way Christians understand God's relationship with humanity. The old nationalistic framework, with its emphasis on physical Israel, national blessings, national curses, and military conquest, is not the defining framework of the Christian faith. Through Christ, God's promises are extended beyond national boundaries. The Kingdom of God is not an Anglo-American inheritance, and the Gospel is not a warning that the descendants of particular European populations are about to receive their punishment.

Paul makes this abundantly clear in Galatians 3:28-29, where he explains that distinctions between Jew and Greek no longer determine one's standing in Christ. Those who belong to Christ are Abraham's offspring and heirs according to the promise. That is a rather inconvenient passage for a movement that has spent generations dividing humanity into prophetic national categories and insisting that the Anglo-Saxon peoples occupy a uniquely privileged place in biblical prophecy.

The New Covenant does not invite Christians to sit around hoping that their neighbors, fellow citizens, or entire populations will experience the fulfillment of terrible national calamities. It calls them to something considerably more demanding: love, compassion, service, forgiveness, and reconciliation. Romans 12:18 instructs Christians, as far as it depends on them, to live peaceably with everyone. Romans 12:21 tells them not to be overcome by evil but to overcome evil with good.

There is no footnote explaining that these instructions can be temporarily suspended because someone has discovered another prophetic timetable predicting the collapse of America.

Jesus Was Not Selling a National Catastrophe

Consider the contrast between Jesus' teachings and the recurring Armstrongist fascination with national destruction. When Jesus encountered suffering, he responded with compassion. He healed the sick, fed the hungry, welcomed the marginalized, forgave sinners, and challenged religious authorities who burdened people with oppressive demands. He did not establish a ministry devoted to predicting the eventual enslavement of entire populations while assuring his followers that these tragedies would demonstrate the accuracy of his prophetic interpretations.

In Luke 19:41-44, Jesus wept over Jerusalem. He lamented the suffering and destruction that would come upon the city. He did not celebrate the catastrophe as a wonderful opportunity to demonstrate that he had correctly identified the geopolitical future. He grieved over people who would suffer.

That is a rather important distinction. Jesus could speak prophetically about judgment while simultaneously expressing profound sorrow over human suffering. Armstrongist prophetic culture, by contrast, has too often transformed judgment into a source of excitement, superiority, and theological self-congratulation.

The difference between those attitudes ought to be obvious to anyone who has actually read the Gospels.

A Religion That Needs Everyone Else to Suffer

One of the most troubling characteristics of Armstrongism is the psychological atmosphere created by its constant emphasis on impending catastrophe. Generations of members have been taught to view world events through a framework of impending national punishment. Economic difficulties, political disagreements, military conflicts, and international tensions become evidence that the prophetic machinery is finally beginning to turn. Every crisis is another opportunity to announce that the end is near.

Rather than encouraging Christians to work toward a better world, this theology encourages people to anticipate the collapse of the existing one. Rather than cultivating concern for the suffering of humanity, it risks turning that suffering into a prophetic scoreboard. The worse things become, the more convinced some followers become that their religious system must be correct.

What kind of spiritual outlook is that? Imagine telling someone whose family is suffering from war, economic hardship, or political oppression that their misery is actually wonderful news because it confirms your favorite religious interpretation. Yet this is the logical destination of a theology that repeatedly treats human catastrophe as evidence of prophetic success.

There is also a profound contradiction here. Armstrongist leaders frequently insist that their followers should demonstrate love, kindness, and obedience to God. Yet the larger prophetic narrative they promote often revolves around the anticipated destruction of people who do not belong to their religious system. The world outside their movement is apparently destined for disaster, while the faithful are encouraged to congratulate themselves for having discovered the correct escape route.

That is not the Gospel of Christ. It is religious tribalism dressed up in prophetic language.

The Gospel of Peace Is Actually Good News

The New Testament offers something much better than an endless parade of national disasters. Ephesians 2:14 declares that Christ himself is our peace, breaking down the dividing wall of hostility. This is the heart of the New Covenant message: reconciliation between humanity and God, and reconciliation between people who were previously separated by hostility and division.

Second Corinthians 5:18-19 describes the ministry of reconciliation entrusted to believers. Christians are called to participate in that ministry, not to spend their lives eagerly anticipating the destruction of nations and the enslavement of their populations.

James 3:17 describes wisdom from above as pure, peaceable, gentle, willing to yield, full of mercy and good fruits. James 3:18 adds that the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace. These are not incidental decorations attached to the Christian message. They are central characteristics of the life shaped by Christ.

And what about the Beatitudes? Jesus specifically declared, "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God" (Matthew 5:9). He did not say blessed are those who correctly predict the destruction of America, blessed are those who identify the coming European slave camps, or blessed are those who can produce the most frightening interpretation of the latest international crisis.

He said peacemakers.

Time to Abandon the Prophetic Bloodsport

Armstrongism needs to take a serious look at the Gospel it claims to proclaim. A movement that spends generation after generation anticipating the deaths of millions, the destruction of nations, and the enslavement of innocent populations has wandered a considerable distance from the central message of Jesus Christ.

The Christian faith is not about waiting for the world to burn so that religious leaders can declare victory. It is not about finding satisfaction in the suffering of people who disagree with one's theology. It is not about nationalistic fantasies, prophetic scorekeeping, or the endless recycling of failed predictions about the imminent destruction of the Anglo-American nations.

The Gospel is good news because God has acted in Christ to reconcile humanity to himself. It is good news because forgiveness is offered, enemies can become neighbors, the excluded can be welcomed, and people can be transformed by love. It is good news because Christ calls his followers to become agents of reconciliation in a world desperately in need of peace.

Armstrongism's Gospel of War turns the suffering of humanity into a theological spectator sport. The New Covenant calls Christians to relieve suffering, feed the hungry, care for the vulnerable, love their enemies, and make peace.

Perhaps it is time for Armstrongist prophets to put away their national destruction charts, stop polishing their predictions of mass death, and actually spend some time reading the teachings of Jesus.

After all, the last time I checked, the Christian message was supposed to be the Gospel of Peace, not the Gospel of War, Rumors of War, National Slavery, and the Spectacular Demise of the United States.

Jesus came preaching good news. Armstrongism seems to be waiting for the bad news to get here.

Tithes, Offerings, and Free Labor: The Three Pillars of Armstrongism



Armstrongism: Where Tithing Is Mandatory, but So Is the Free Labor!

For decades, the Worldwide Church of God perfected a rather remarkable arrangement with its membership. Members were expected to tithe, give offerings, support the church's building projects, finance its television broadcasts, and contribute to an endless parade of special fundraising campaigns. But apparently, handing over a substantial portion of one's income wasn't quite enough. The church also expected its members to provide something money couldn't buy quite so cheaply: their labor.

Why hire someone when you have thousands of faithful members who can be persuaded that mowing the minister's lawn is somehow an act of Christian service?

Throughout the old Worldwide Church of God, members were routinely called upon to perform all sorts of unpaid work. Some mowed ministers' lawns, maintained their properties, deleavened ministers and evangelists homes before the Days of Unleavened Bread, cleaned church buildings, maintained church facilities, provided "Sabbath" security, set up rented halls, dismantled Feast of Tabernacles facilities, washed dishes, scrubbed toilets, and performed countless other chores. When the Feast rolled around, members became an unpaid workforce responsible for making everything look wonderful for the visiting ministry and church hierarchy.

Naturally, this was all presented as serving God, supporting the Work, loving the brethren, or demonstrating a willing and obedient attitude. Nobody wanted to be the person who questioned why the church couldn't hire employees to perform work that ordinary organizations would simply pay people to do. After all, questioning the arrangement might reveal an insufficiently submissive attitude.

And heaven forbid anyone should suggest that a minister, who was already receiving a salary and numerous benefits, might mow his own lawn!

The arrangement was particularly amusing when it came to the ministry's comfortable lifestyle. Members could be struggling financially, working ordinary jobs, raising families, and trying to make ends meet, yet somehow they were expected to find additional time to maintain church properties and assist the ministry. Their own household responsibilities could wait. The Work came first, and apparently so did the minister's landscaping.

Fast-forward to the modern Armstrongist splinter organizations, and it appears that some traditions are simply too precious to abandon.

A Philadelphia Church of God social media post from last year recently appeared in my X feed showing PCG women washing clothing for the young people attending its Summer Educational Program (SEP). Apparently, the ladies were busy providing laundry services for the campers. It brought back memories of the original SEP program in Minnesota in 1971,  where we were expected to wash our own clothes. Not by machines, but in tubs with laundry scrubbing ridges, by hand.



Imagine that! Young people learning to take responsibility for their own laundry. What a revolutionary concept!
Of course, one has to wonder whether the children of the PCG's privileged leadership families would be quite as enthusiastic about this arrangement if they were expected to wash their own clothing. Perhaps there is a special exemption for children whose parents occupy the upper floors of the Armstrongist aristocracy. One can almost imagine the horror of discovering that a washing machine actually requires someone to put clothes inside it, add detergent, and press a button.

Why should the campers learn independence when there are perfectly good church women available to operate the laundry department?

Perhaps the PCG should consider expanding the service. They could establish a permanent laundry ministry, complete with a hierarchy of washing supervisors, folding coordinators, and approved detergent policies. A special offering could be collected to purchase additional washing machines, while the women provide the labor free of charge. Which, incidentally, they already do as part of the free traveling slave labor that accompanies the Celtic dance road shows. Groups of women travel with the production washing, ironing and taking care of the dancers clothing.

And this is the larger problem with Armstrongism. The old Worldwide Church of God established a culture in which members were expected to surrender not only their financial resources but also their personal time, energy, and independence. The splinter organizations inherited much of that institutional mentality. Whether it is the Philadelphia Church of God, the Continuing Church of God, or one of the other Armstrongist descendants, the old expectation that members should continually sacrifice themselves for the organization remains an uncomfortable part of the tradition.

To be fair, there is nothing inherently wrong with church members volunteering. Congregations everywhere depend upon volunteers. People willingly clean their churches, prepare meals, help at camps, and organize religious gatherings. There is something genuinely admirable about people working together to help one another. People do this because they have felt blessed by what they get from their churches instead of being TOLD they will be cleaning.

There is a considerable difference between voluntary Christian service and an institutional culture in which members are expected to provide endless unpaid labor because the organization has convinced them that doing so demonstrates their loyalty, obedience, or spiritual commitment. When saying no becomes an indication of a bad attitude, volunteering begins to look considerably less voluntary.

And that is where Armstrongism deserves some serious scrutiny.

The church can collect its tithes, second tithes, third tithes, tithe of the tithe, special offerings, building fund contributions, and member/co-worker appeal letters. It can maintain its expensive headquarters, purchase property, operate elaborate church facilities, and provide comfortable accommodations for its leadership. Yet somehow, there is always another job that needs doing by someone who isn't getting paid.

The members provide the money. The members provide the labor. The members provide the transportation, cooking, cleaning, maintenance, organizing, and laundry services. Meanwhile, the leadership gets to enjoy the benefits of a remarkably well-organized volunteer workforce.

Perhaps the next Armstrongist doctrinal restoration should be the recovery of an ancient and previously overlooked truth: Thou shalt not hire a janitor when thou hast a congregation of unpaid members.

One can almost hear Herbert Armstrong approving from the grave. After all, why stop at demanding a tenth of someone's income when you can also have their weekends, holidays, vacation time, and household labor?

Armstrongism has always been extraordinarily good at telling its members what God supposedly expects them to sacrifice. What it has been considerably less enthusiastic about explaining is why so much of that sacrifice seems to benefit the organization and its leadership.

Apparently, salvation is a full-time job, the ministry is management, and the membership is the maintenance department.

And remember, brethren, your tithes are due on payday. The laundry is due by Thursday.

The Churches of God: Where Satan Gets Top Billing and Jesus Is Just the Angry Supporting Actor



For a movement that claims to represent the one true Church of God and restored 1st-century Christianity, its ministers seem to spend an astonishing amount of time talking about someone other than Jesus. You would think that a religion supposedly centered on Jesus Christ would devote most of its energy to discussing his teachings, his sacrifice, his mercy, his love, and the New Covenant. But apparently, those subjects are too mainstream Christian for the Armstrongist prophetic entertainment industry. Instead, its ministers have developed an almost obsessive fascination with Satan, demons, conspiracies, mysterious spiritual forces, and the endless machinations of the devil. If something goes wrong, Satan did it. If someone disagrees with the ministry, Satan is involved. If a member leaves the church, Satan has deceived them. If a website criticizes the organization, the devil must be behind it. If the world experiences political turmoil, religious confusion, or social problems, you can be certain that another satanic conspiracy is waiting to be exposed.

One has to wonder whether Satan ever gets a vacation. Listening to Bob Thiel, Gerald Flurry, Gerald Weston, Samuel Kitchen, Alton Billingsley, and Dave Pack, you might conclude that the devil is the busiest, most successful, and most powerful spiritual being in the entire universe. God seems to spend most of his time reacting to Satan's latest scheme, while Jesus is apparently waiting backstage for his eventual entrance into an apocalyptic production involving enormous destruction and a very unhappy humanity. Welcome to Armstrongism, where Satan gets the starring role, Jesus gets the angry cameo, and the ministry gets to explain everything else.

Satan: The Real Star of Armstrongist Theology

Although these ministers have their own peculiar theological obsessions, they share a remarkable tendency to portray the world as one enormous battlefield of satanic interference. Everything is connected, everything is a conspiracy, and virtually every unpleasant development is interpreted as evidence that Satan is working behind the scenes to frustrate God's purposes. Bob Thiel deserves particular recognition for his seemingly endless interest in identifying the devil's activities. His broadcasts and writings repeatedly return to Satan, demonic influence, deception, persecution, and supposed spiritual attacks against his ministry. One almost expects him to announce that the local grocery store has changed its opening hours because Satan is attempting to undermine the restoration of the true Church of God.

Gerald Flurry has his own elaborate collection of prophetic enemies, conspiracies, and end-time threats, with a theological universe populated by sinister forces and an endless succession of people and institutions that must be exposed. Gerald Weston and the Living Church of God likewise devote considerable attention to Satan's influence, worldly deception, and spiritual dangers lurking around practically every corner. Then there is Dave Pack, whose prophetic pronouncements have turned anticipation of Christ's return into a seemingly perpetual exercise in apocalyptic expectation. With prophetic timelines repeatedly requiring explanation and adjustment, one wonders whether Satan has been given responsibility for maintaining the church calendar.

The common thread is that Satan receives an extraordinary amount of attention. Rather than encouraging members to concentrate on Christ and the freedom found in the New Covenant, these ministries repeatedly direct their attention toward the devil's supposed influence over virtually every aspect of human existence. Apparently, keeping the membership frightened, suspicious, and constantly alert to satanic interference is considerably more exciting than teaching people how to live like Jesus.

The Most Powerful Being in the Universe Is Apparently Satan

Here is where Armstrongist theology becomes particularly amusing. Ministers routinely describe Satan as the god of this world, the great deceiver of humanity, and the master manipulator of governments, religions, education, science, politics, and practically every institution that fails to agree with their interpretation of Scripture. Satan has supposedly infiltrated everything, and the world is portrayed as one enormous demonstration of his influence. Yet these same ministers insist that God is sovereign, all-powerful, and ultimately in control.

There is a rather obvious contradiction in the way this is presented. If Satan is so extraordinarily successful at deceiving humanity, manipulating world affairs, corrupting religion, and frustrating God's purposes, one might reasonably wonder what exactly God is doing while all this is happening. Does God have a plan, or is he simply waiting for Satan to finish his latest project? Has the devil established a competing universe with a larger staff, better public relations, and a more effective communications department? Armstrongist ministers would undoubtedly object to such questions and explain that God permits Satan to influence the world for a specific purpose. Fine, but that still doesn't explain why their preaching seems to give Satan more attention than the very God they claim to represent.

The New Testament repeatedly directs believers toward Christ, yet Armstrongism seems determined to keep everyone's attention fixed on the devil. Instead of celebrating Christ's victory over sin and death, members are continually reminded of the devil's supposed victories over practically everything else. If one listened exclusively to these ministers, it would be easy to conclude that Satan is winning the battle and God is still trying to figure out how to get things back under control.

Bob Thiel and His Never-Ending Satanic Detective Agency

Bob Thiel deserves special recognition in this department. His ministry seems to have developed an almost encyclopedic interest in identifying Satan's influence in the modern world. One can easily imagine his followers waking up each morning wondering what fresh satanic conspiracy has been discovered overnight. Perhaps another church has been deceived, another government agency is being manipulated, another religious organization has failed to recognize Bob's prophetic importance, or another website has published something critical of his ministry. Naturally, that last possibility must be particularly important.

It is difficult not to notice how much attention is devoted to the devil compared with the actual teachings of Jesus. Where are the extended discussions about loving one's enemies, forgiving others, caring for the poor, showing mercy, and refusing to judge people hypocritically? Where is the enthusiasm for the Sermon on the Mount? Where are the discussions about the grace of God and the sufficiency of Christ? Apparently, those subjects cannot compete with another thrilling installment of Satan's Secret Operations Against Bob Thiel.

One almost wonders whether the devil has established a special department devoted exclusively to monitoring the Continuing Church of God. With the amount of attention devoted to supposed attacks against the organization, Satan must have an entire office building somewhere, complete with a dedicated communications team and a department responsible for keeping track of Bob's latest broadcasts. Perhaps the ministry should publish a weekly intelligence report detailing the latest satanic operations, complete with charts, maps, prophetic interpretations, and an announcement that another person has disagreed with Bob. It would certainly give his followers something to look forward to.

Jesus: Apparently Not Much to Talk About Until He Starts Destroying Everyone

And then there is the rather unfortunate place Jesus occupies in Armstrongist theology. You would think the central figure of Christianity would receive considerable attention, considering that his teachings are supposed to establish the foundation of Christian living. His death and resurrection are central to the New Covenant, and his example is what believers are supposed to follow. Yet in much Armstrongist prophetic preaching, Jesus often seems to be waiting backstage until the exciting destruction begins.

When ministers finally get around to discussing his return, the atmosphere changes dramatically. Suddenly, Jesus is presented primarily as an angry returning conqueror preparing to unleash devastating judgment upon a rebellious world. There is no shortage of enthusiasm for the catastrophic passages in biblical prophecy, and the more frightening the prediction, the more animated some presentations seem to become. The charts come out, the prophetic timelines are dusted off, and the ministers begin explaining who will suffer, who will be punished, who will be destroyed, and how much of humanity will be left standing.

Some Armstrongist interpretations emphasize the biblical language concerning two-thirds of humanity being struck down in end-time judgment. Rather than treating such passages with solemnity and humility, certain prophetic presentations seem almost exhilarated by the prospect. One would think they were announcing the opening of a new amusement park rather than discussing the suffering of billions of human beings. Apparently, the greatest Christian excitement is not the prospect of humanity being reconciled to God but the opportunity to explain how thoroughly God is going to punish everyone who failed to listen to the ministry. Naturally, the ministers themselves will have been among the select few who understood everything correctly. What a remarkable coincidence!

Whatever Happened to the Jesus Who Actually Taught People to Love?

Consider the Jesus presented in the Gospels. He taught his followers to love their enemies, pray for those who persecuted them, forgive others, care for the poor, show mercy, and treat their neighbors with compassion. He criticized religious leaders who burdened people with demands while neglecting the weightier matters of the law: justice, mercy, and faithfulness. He repeatedly challenged religious arrogance and self-righteousness, demonstrating that genuine spiritual leadership was about serving others rather than exercising authority over them.

In Luke 15, Jesus tells stories about the lost being found and the joy of restoration. In John 10, he describes himself as the good shepherd who cares for his sheep, and in Matthew 11, he invites the weary and burdened to come to him for rest. This is the Jesus Christians are supposed to follow. But where does that Jesus fit into the Armstrongist prophetic circus? Apparently, he is the fellow who occasionally gets mentioned between lengthy discussions about Satan, the Beast, the Great Tribulation, world government, religious deception, and the latest conspiracy supposedly proving that the ministry was right all along.

The contrast is extraordinary. The Jesus of the Gospels spent considerable time demonstrating compassion toward people, while the Jesus presented in some Armstrongist prophetic preaching seems to spend considerably more time being discussed in connection with how many people will be destroyed when he returns. One wonders whether these ministers have ever considered that the purpose of the Gospel is not to cultivate an audience that delights in imagining the destruction of everyone outside its religious organization.

Herbert Armstrong's Theological Inheritance

Of course, this obsession did not appear out of thin air. Herbert W. Armstrong established a theological framework in which Satan's influence over humanity was central to understanding practically everything. The world was supposedly deceived, traditional Christianity was supposedly corrupted, mainstream religion was supposedly part of a counterfeit system, and governments were influenced by satanic forces. Education, science, politics, and culture were all viewed through the lens of a cosmic struggle between God's government and Satan's government. Armstrong's followers inherited a worldview in which the entire planet was essentially under the control of the devil, while their own organization represented God's restored truth.

That is a remarkably convenient arrangement for anyone who wants to insulate a religious organization from criticism. If outsiders disagree, they are deceived. If members question leadership, they are rebelling. If critics expose embarrassing problems, they are being used by Satan. If the organization fails to achieve its predictions, the devil is still working against it. There is always a supernatural explanation available, and the ministry never has to seriously consider that perhaps its own teachings are mistaken, its leaders are fallible, or its prophetic interpretations are simply wrong. Why examine human mistakes when you can blame a supernatural conspiracy?

This worldview also creates an environment in which members are encouraged to distrust practically everyone outside their particular church organization. Mainstream Christianity is deceived, secular society is under Satan's influence, other religious organizations are counterfeit, and critics are spiritually compromised. The result is a self-contained theological bubble in which the ministry becomes the only supposedly reliable source of truth. It is difficult to imagine a more effective way of keeping members dependent upon religious leadership.

The Great Christian Irony

Here is the irony Armstrongist ministers seem to miss: Christianity is supposed to be about Christ. The name itself gives away the central figure. Yet Armstrongism has managed to construct a religious culture in which Satan receives an extraordinary amount of attention, the world is portrayed as one enormous satanic conspiracy, and Jesus is frequently discussed in connection with the destruction awaiting everyone who refuses to follow the ministry's instructions.

Where is the emphasis on the grace of God? Where is the celebration of Christ's victory over sin and death? Where is the assurance that believers are held in God's hands rather than living in perpetual terror of demonic interference? Paul wrote in Colossians 1:13 that believers have been delivered from the power of darkness and transferred into the kingdom of God's beloved Son. That is a rather different emphasis from spending one's religious life obsessively cataloging everything Satan supposedly controls.

In Colossians 2:15, Paul describes Christ's triumph over spiritual powers and authorities. Christ is the victor, not Satan. The Christian message is not that Satan is so powerful that believers must spend every waking moment worrying about his latest conspiracy. It is that Christ has accomplished what humanity could never accomplish for itself. Yet apparently, that message doesn't generate enough excitement for the Armstrongist prophetic entertainment industry.

Perhaps It's Time to Put Satan Back in His Place

At some point, one has to ask why these ministers seem so preoccupied with Satan. Is it because fear is an extraordinarily effective tool for keeping people dependent upon religious leadership? Does constantly warning members about deception make them less likely to trust outside information? Does portraying the world as hopelessly corrupted make the organization appear indispensable? Whatever the explanation, the results are remarkably consistent. Members are taught to distrust outsiders, fear spiritual contamination, question mainstream Christianity, avoid supposedly dangerous influences, and remain dependent upon the ministry for explanations of practically everything happening in the world.

Meanwhile, the simple teachings of Jesus about love, mercy, forgiveness, humility, and compassion frequently receive considerably less attention than the latest prophetic warning. Perhaps that is the greatest tragedy of Armstrongism. It has taken a religion centered upon Jesus Christ and turned it into a never-ending investigation of Satan's activities, complete with prophetic detectives, conspiracy theories, end-time countdowns, and ministers who seem positively delighted whenever another catastrophe can be squeezed into their interpretation of biblical prophecy.

If Satan really is as powerful as these ministers make him sound, perhaps they should stop advertising his accomplishments so enthusiastically. After all, why give the devil free publicity? And perhaps someone should remind Bob Thiel, Gerald Flurry, Gerald Weston, Samuel Kitchen, Alton Billingsley and Dave Pack that Christianity actually has a central figure. His name is Jesus Christ, and he isn't a supporting character in Satan's biography. He is the one Christians are supposed to follow.

Maybe the next great Armstrongist restoration shouldn't involve discovering another satanic conspiracy, identifying another prophetic enemy, or announcing another impending catastrophe. Maybe it should involve rediscovering Jesus Christ and actually paying attention to what he taught. That would mean spending less time obsessing over the devil and considerably more time demonstrating the love, mercy, and grace that Jesus commanded his followers to practice.

One can only imagine the ministry-wide emergency meeting that would follow.