Crackpot Bob's Gospel of Fear: Germany Is Coming-So Keep Obeying!
A New Covenant Critique of Bob Thiel's Fixation on the End Times
By a Recovering Armstrongist follower
Bob Thiel has begun the first of a two-year project on subjecting his followers to his interpretation of the Book of Revelation.
Typical of Armstrongist prophecy, he follows a stubbornly familiar pattern. Decades pass, predictions fail, and Herbert W. Armstrong's religious empire breaks into ever more splinter groups-yet the underlying formula barely changes.
Germany is on its way. The Great Tribulation draws near, and the Beast is getting ready to rise. The Church will have to endure. Before everything collapses, its members had better be certain they obey the right man.
Enter Crackpot Bob (affectionately called Bwana Bob by his African followers) with another installment from Armstrongism's end-times entertainment industry.
Apparently, Jesus Christ's gospel needs extra drama: a German invasion, a European dictator, horrifying prophetic scenarios, and a congregation fretting over whether its obedience will spare it from the worst.
Welcome to the Continuing Church of God's prophetic-anxiety department. Bring your Bible, emergency supplies, and checkbook. The end is near. Again.
Armstrongism's most troubling feature may be the way it turns biblical prophecy into a tool for controlling believers.
The point is not merely to make Christians think about the future. Prophecy keeps catastrophe feeling close at hand, while suggesting that members' spiritual survival depends on their loyalty to the organization and its leaders.
The formula works with striking consistency: take a frightening event, tie it to a prophetic passage, and present it as proof that the organization's interpretation was right. Members are then urged to stay faithful and obedient, while being reminded that the Great Tribulation is still coming. But what happens when the prediction fails to unfold as expected? Never mind. Another prophecy is always available.
The issue is not Christians talking about Revelation. It begins when someone turns it into a threat, leaving people constantly afraid that they may not stand right with God. Paul described a very different promise in the New Covenant:
For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind." 2 Timothy 1:7, KJV
A sound mind?
That idea seems awkward for an organization whose prophetic interpretation appears to depend on keeping its members in a constant state of alarm.
The Christian life should rest on faith, hope, love, and confidence in Christ-not on constant anxiety over whether the newest political shift in Europe signals the collapse of your spiritual life. Which brings us to the Germans, Armstrongism's preferred villains of the end times.
Armstrongism has long been drawn to the idea of a revived European empire. In Herbert W. Armstrong's prophetic framework, Germany and a broader European power stood at the heart of the coming Beast system. Over time, that reading sank so deeply into the movement's thinking that several generations of members interpreted European politics as signs of an approaching catastrophe.
Germany became more than a country; it turned into a prophetic fixation.
Want to understand the European Union, military cooperation across Europe, a new political leader, a financial crisis, or a dispute between European nations? Watch Germany. Somewhere, an Armstrongist prophecy enthusiast is likely scanning the latest German headlines and muttering, "This could be it!"
That is the absurd part: the prophetic narrative can absorb almost any development.
Whatever happens, the Armstrongist prophecy industry can claim vindication. A stronger Europe fulfills the prophecy; a weaker Europe does too. Germany's leadership counts as confirmation, while its failure to lead merely means the prophecy is waiting for the right moment. The only outcome that might genuinely surprise them is Germany remaining an ordinary country while the world ignores the organization's carefully constructed prophetic timetable.
What does the New Covenant say about this fixation? Jesus did not send His followers into the world to become professional German-watchers. He sent them to make disciples, love their neighbors, proclaim the gospel, and remain faithful.
Matthew 28:18-20 records the Great Commission. It does not say:
Go therefore, and monitor the German economy, the European Parliament, and every political development that might conceivably resemble Daniel's fourth beast.
Revelation was never meant to leave Christians terrified about what lies ahead. The book's real purpose deserves a closer look.
The opening verses identify this as a revelation from Jesus Christ. Its subject is not Germany, Crackpot Bob's interpretations, or the newest prophetic reading from an Armstrongist leader. The focus is Jesus Christ.
Revelation 1:1 begins:
The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave unto him, to shew unto his servants things which must shortly come to pass."
What, then, does John say when he sees Christ glorified? He collapses at Christ's feet. Jesus answers him:
Fear not; I am the first and the last. Revelation 1:17, KJV
The contrast is striking.
Armstrongist prophecy teachers often use this book to frighten people, yet it opens with the risen Christ telling John not to fear.
Revelation's final message is not a warning that Christians must fear the Beast.
The Lamb wins. Evil will not have the last word. God's kingdom will prevail, and Christ's people are called to remain faithful to him.
That stands far apart from the endless Armstrongist refrain: "The end is near. Germany is rising. Make sure you belong to the right organization."
Christ has already accomplished what Armstrongism keeps turning into a test.
Armstrongist theology repeatedly makes organizational obedience overshadow the believer's relationship with God. Yet the New Covenant rests on Jesus Christ.
Hebrews 8:6 says:
But now hath he obtained a more excellent ministry, by how much also he is the mediator of a better covenant, which was established upon better promises.
A better covenant.
Better promises.
A better mediator.
Not another set of predictions meant to provoke fear. Not an institution that expects blind loyalty. And not a religious survival plan that keeps warning its members they may suffer because their obedience has fallen short.
The New Covenant rests on what Jesus Christ has already completed. Paul writes in Romans 8:1:
There is therefore now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus.
That statement is remarkable.
No condemnation.
Not with a condition attached-such as correctly naming the next European dictator. And not on the condition that you stay loyal enough to Bob Thiel, Sam Kitchen, Dave Pack, Gerald Flurry, or any other COG minister or leader. Believers place their confidence in Christ.
Christians are not thereby excused from responsible living. The New Covenant calls believers to holiness, love, obedience, and good works-but these grow out of a changed life; they do not buy spiritual protection from an impending prophetic disaster.
Ephesians 2:8-10 draws the line clearly.
Salvation comes through grace by faith, not through anything we accomplish. Yet believers are created in Christ Jesus for good works.
That order matters: grace comes first, and Christ comes first. Christian living grows out of that relationship.
Armstrongism reverses that order: spiritual security becomes tied to obedience to its own reading of biblical law and prophecy. No wonder its members are afraid.
Will members who have sinned face the Great Tribulation? That question exposes a troubling part of the Armstrongist prophetic system.
Armstrongist circles often suggest that members who fall short of sufficient faithfulness could face the coming Great Tribulation. The nations and the wider world will suffer, and those who have not obeyed properly may suffer with them.
The New Covenant does not promise Christians protection from every catastrophe to come merely because they belong to the right organization. Nor does it say that suffering proves a Christian has failed a spiritual test. Jesus rejected that simplistic explanation outright.
In Luke 13:1-5, Jesus challenged the idea that tragedy proves a person's spiritual failure. Rather than speculate about who deserved such suffering, He urged His listeners to repent.
In John 9:1-3, Jesus challenged the belief that the man's suffering had to come from his own sin or from his parents' sins.
The New Covenant does not authorize religious leaders to explain every tragedy as proof of someone else's spiritual failure. Nor does it permit them to frighten members with the claim that any terrible event means they could be next.
Christians have never been strangers to suffering. The apostles endured it, as did the early church, and believers across history have faced it too.
Believing in Christ does not promise a life without suffering. Romans 8:35-39 states the point plainly: no hardship can cut believers off from God's love.
Paul never says Christians will avoid tribulation. His claim is different: nothing can sever believers from God's love in Christ Jesus. That is the hope of the New Covenant.
It does not rest on belonging to the right organization or finding some prophetic way out.
Let's be honest. Fear is a powerful motivator.
People may silence their own questions, put up with harmful leaders, and stay committed despite serious doubts when they believe disaster awaits anyone who leaves a particular religious organization.
The Great Tribulation can be used as a spiritual leash.
Question the leader, and you may be told that you are abandoning God's true church. Leave the organization, and the warning may shift to the loss of spiritual protection. Challenge the latest prophetic interpretation, and your faithfulness itself may be called into question.
Already worried about your salvation? There is another prophecy waiting to trouble you. That creates a system where religious anxiety keeps feeding itself.
The member fears what lies ahead, while the organization supplies an explanation. Reassurance then comes from the same source that keeps interpreting the future, making the member increasingly dependent on it.
What a convenient arrangement. Only a subscription service is missing.
Perhaps Bwana Bob could call it:
The Great Tribulation Survival Package: Monthly Prophecy Updates, Spiritual Anxiety, and Premium German Watching.
Yes, it's satire. The issue underneath it isn't.
The New Covenant calls believers to freedom in Christ.
Galatians 5:1 says:
Stand fast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage.
That freedom does not release anyone from love, responsibility, or holiness. Christ has broken the condemnation and bondage that once held people captive; believers are also free from religious systems that try to bind them again through fear.
The Gospel is not an end-time emergency broadcast!
One tragic result of Armstrongist fixation on prophecy is that it can bury the gospel itself. Jesus announced the kingdom of God, calling people to repent and receive forgiveness while showing mercy and restoring humanity's relationship with God. He healed the sick and welcomed sinners. His followers were told to love one another-even their enemies-and He gave His life to save the world.
Yet in the Armstrongist prophetic universe, the message can end up sounding like this:
"Look at Germany!"
"Look at Europe!"
"Look at the Beast!"
"Look at the coming tribulation!"
"Look at the latest prophetic development!"
Eventually, the question becomes unavoidable: where is Jesus in all of this? Not Jesus reduced to a prophetic symbol or placed somewhere on a future timeline, but Jesus as the living Savior, mediator of the New Covenant, and the source of believers' hope.
The apostle Paul wrote:
For I determined not to know any thing among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified. 1 Corinthians 2:2, KJV
That verse creates an awkward problem for a religious movement with an apparently endless interest in prophetic speculation. Paul kept his message centered on Christ crucified.
His sacrifice established the New Covenant, while His resurrection gives believers their hope. Christian life rests on faith in Him.
Germany is not where the gospel centers. Nor is Bob Thiel. The Continuing Church of God does not stand at its heart. Jesus Christ does.
The Final Irony: Revelation Ends with Hope, Not Bob Thiel
The book of Revelation ends with God's victory over evil and the promise that creation will be made new.
Revelation 21:4 declares:
And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain.
That is the Christian hope in its fullest sense.
It is not endless terror or a life spent fearing what comes next. Nor does it require constant doubt over whether someone has correctly identified the next prophetic development.
Through Jesus Christ, God will restore all things. Revelation 22:17 extends the invitation:
The Spirit and the bride say, 'Come.' Let anyone who hears them repeat the invitation. If you are thirsty, come; whoever wishes may take the water of life freely.
Freely.
That is the language of grace.
The water of life is not a prize for reading European politics correctly, nor for surviving a religious organization's endless prophetic trials.
It is given freely. That alone sets the New Covenant apart from the Armstrongist fear machine.
The world's problems are real. So is war. So is suffering. And human sin is real.
Christians should take Jesus' teachings seriously. Still, biblical prophecy should not be used to frighten people or control an organization, as though it held the answer to the world's problems.
The answer is found in the gospel of Jesus Christ. Through the New Covenant, believers receive forgiveness and reconciliation, along with the freedom and hope to live differently. They are called to love God and their neighbors, remaining faithful in the present instead of getting lost in speculation about the future. Their confidence rests on Christ-not on predictions made by religious leaders.
Crackpot Bob, watch Germany if you insist. Study European politics. Make your prophetic videos. Just stop presenting your reading of the future as though it were the gospel of Jesus Christ.
The New Covenant does not offer a plan for surviving a German invasion. Nor does it ask believers to live on a subscription of religious fear or keep proving that they deserve God's protection.
The gospel is good news: Jesus Christ has done for sinful humanity what it could never do on its own.
Revelation's final message is not the Beast's victory.
The Lamb wins.
The Germans are not the gospel; neither are the Great Tribulation or Bob Thiel's words.
Jesus Christ is.
No comments:
Post a Comment