Armstrongism has always sold itself as the last unlocked room in the house of Christianity. Everyone else had the furniture. Only Herbert W. Armstrong, we were told, had the key. "The Truth" was not merely the gospel. It was a restored package: Sabbath from Friday sunset, annual holy days, meats, tithes, God as a Family, British-Israel identity, sequential church eras, and one visible organization still obedient enough to qualify as the Church Christ actually built.
That claim was exclusive by design. If God hid the meaning of Scripture from historic Christianity and then handed the decoder ring to one twentieth-century broadcaster, then gratitude becomes a membership perk. You thank God not only for Christ, but for being among the few who can see. Satan, conveniently, has blinded everyone else-Catholics, Protestants, Evangelicals, and, after 1986, every Church of God that did not follow your particular evangelist out the door.
Living Church of God still writes in that voice. Douglas Winnail's Sabbath reflection asks members whether they are thankful for truths "hidden from the world," including a real God guiding history, a purpose for life, and Christ's return to restore all things. Fine sentences, as far as they go. Then comes the Armstrongist turn: the capacity to understand the plan of God is a gift God is "only giving to a few at this time." The rest of the planet, apparently including two millennia of Christians who somehow managed to preach Christ without Ambassador College or the Worldwide Church of God, remains under a special blackout.
It is a moving piety, until you notice that Bob Thiel, David Pack, Gerald Flurry, and Gerald Weston can all read the same paragraph and assume it describes their flock. Each man inherited the same grammar. Each insists his group is the one still proclaiming what no other group quite proclaims. The binders are identical. Only the letterhead changes.
Herbert Armstrong taught that other churches were not simply wrong on the calendar. They were a counterfeit. God had restored lost truths through him. The true church would be identifiable by Sabbath, holy days, the name "Church of God," hierarchical government, and a message about the coming Kingdom. After his death, when the old Worldwide Church of God dropped most of that package, the system did what exclusive systems always do. It shattered, and every shard claimed to be the original vase.
Pack's Restored Church of God says Christ's body is not divided into fellowships; it is one organization in full doctrinal agreement, and his is the restoration of the pre-1986 work. Flurry's Philadelphia Church of God says the apostasy was prophesied, Malachi's Message identified it, and Philadelphia continues in Edmond. Thiel's Continuing Church of God says the Philadelphia remnant can be documented by restored truths, early church history, and prophetic credentials the other groups lack. Weston's Living Church of God says it practices original first-century Christianity, restored through Armstrong and Meredith, and that members should thank God not only for being called into the truth but for being preserved in it.
The sarcasm writes itself, except the people in the pews are not a joke. They tithe, rearrange family calendars around holy days, and are taught that leaving the right corporation is spiritually dangerous. Meanwhile, the leaders treat one another as Laodicean, compromised, or simply not the Work. If "the Truth" were as self-evident as advertised, it would not need four incompatible copyright pages.
The deeper issue is not that these men believe Jesus will return. Plenty of Christians believe that. The issue is that they will not let the New Covenant be what the New Testament says it is.
Armstrong taught that the New Covenant is largely still ahead-a marriage covenant to be finalized at Christ's return-and that Christians now live between covenants, still bound to selected Mosaic requirements. Sabbath, meats, and holy days remain identity markers. The old covenant is "amplified," not administered into obsolescence. That maneuver lets a church quote Jeremiah 31 and Hebrews 8 while still policing belonging with Sinai's sign-laws.
Exodus 31 is blunt: the Sabbath is the sign of the covenant with Israel. Colossians 2 is equally blunt: festivals, new moons, and Sabbaths are a shadow; the substance belongs to Christ. Hebrews 8 is blunter still: in speaking of a new covenant, God has made the first obsolete. Armstrongism keeps the shadow in the display case and postpones the substance until the Millennium, when it will be safer to admit the new covenant has actually arrived.
So "the Truth" becomes a backward glance. Correct day. Correct diet. Correct feast. Correct era nickname from Revelation 2-3, as if Jesus mailed seven letters to first-century congregations so that a California radio ministry could later assign you a prophetic ZIP code. The future kingdom is preached with real urgency. The present church is managed like a museum of Leviticus.
They will say they do not teach salvation by works. Armstrong said eternal life is a gift. The successor groups repeat it. Functionally, though, assurance, identity, and often fellowship are tied to the package and the organization that claims to guard it. Grace gets you in the brochure. The calendar keeps you in the directory.
In Scripture, truth is not a secret curriculum restored in 1933.
Truth is a person. "I am the way, and the truth, and the life." Knowing the truth is knowing Christ, not passing an exam on whether America is Manasseh.
The New Covenant is not waiting in a file cabinet until the Second Coming. Jesus said the cup is the new covenant in his blood. Paul called himself a minister of a new covenant, of the Spirit rather than the letter. Hebrews says Christ is already mediator of a better covenant, and that the first is aging and ready to vanish. One may debate how Israel's national promises reach their public fullness. One may not, with a straight face, use that debate to keep the church under Sinai's worship schedule.
The law is not thrown in the street. It is written on hearts. That is not "a few insiders finally decoded the holy days." It is the Spirit forming people into the likeness of Christ. The moral will of God remains. The Mosaic covenant as the terms of belonging does not.
The church is not one corporation with a successor evangelist. There is one body, and it is made of those united to Christ by the Spirit-not those who survived the correct 1990s split. Paul wrote 1 Corinthians 1 to rebuke "I am of Paul, I am of Apollos." Armstrongism cites the same chapter to congratulate a remnant for having information the rest of the household of faith missed.
And the gospel is public. When Paul said the god of this age blinds minds, he was talking about the gospel of the glory of Christ, not about people who celebrate the resurrection on Sunday or eat shrimp. The apostles preached in streets and synagogues. They did not require a proprietary restoration before anyone was allowed to understand.
Under the New Covenant, gratitude sounds different. You thank God that the veil is taken away in Christ. You do not thank him that your group finally obtained the decoder ring and that Satan has, for some reason, issued a communications blackout to every other pulpit on earth-including the three Armstrongist pulpits across town.
The tragedy of COGland is not that it takes the Bible seriously. It is that it takes Armstrong's restoration so seriously that Christ becomes the mascot of a remnant brand.
A faith that must keep insisting "no one else has ever understood this" is already nervous. A faith that then splits into hundreds of groups, each repeating the sentence, has confessed the problem out loud. If the truth were the person and work of Jesus, it would be large enough for the catholic church of all who belong to him. If the truth is a restored code plus the right human government, it will keep shrinking until it fits inside one man's office.
Winnail asked whether readers were thankful for the opportunity to understand truths hidden from the world. A better question: thankful to whom, and for what? If the gift is Christ, the Spirit, and sins remembered no more, then the thanksgiving is Christian. If the gift is exclusive sight, withheld from the rest of the body and located in one lineage of evangelists who cannot agree which lineage is real, then the thanksgiving is just the old boast in a Sabbath suit.
The New Covenant does not need a replica Armstrong. It already has a Head. He does not require four competing press secretaries to protect him from the rest of Christianity. The substance belongs to Christ. The shadows were never the prize. And a truth that can only survive by declaring everyone else blind is not the truth that sets people free. It is a flashlight fight in broad daylight.
Are You Thankful for the Truth?
The Sabbath is a good time to thank God for giving us an understanding of His truth—that there is a real God who is guiding the course of history (Job 12:23; Daniel 2:21; 4:17), that there is a real purpose for life (1 John 3:1–3), and that Jesus Christ is going to return to bring peace and justice to the world and restore all things (Isaiah 9:6–7; Acts 3:19–21). We are told that the saints will reign with Christ and fill the earth with a knowledge of God’s ways (Daniel 7:27; Isaiah 11:9). The capacity to understand the truth about the plan of God is a gift that God is only giving to a few at this time (1 Corinthians 1:26). The Bible reveals that Satan has blinded the rest of the world to these important and wonderful truths (2 Corinthians 4:3–4). Are you thankful for the opportunity to understand these truths that have been hidden from the world? —Douglas S. Winnail
No comments:
Post a Comment