Banned by HWA! News and Observations About Armstrongism and the Church of God Movement
Exposing the underbelly of Armstrongism in all of its wacky glory! Nothing you read here is made up. What you read here is the up to date face of Herbert W Armstrong's legacy. It's the gritty and dirty behind the scenes look at Armstrongism as you have never seen it before! With all the new crazy self-appointed Chief Overseers, Apostles, Prophets, Pharisees, legalists, and outright liars leading various Churches of God today, it is important to hold these agents of deception accountable.
Herbert Armstrong's Tangled Web of Corrupt Leaders
- Contact Blog Owner No2HWA:
- Contact Dennis Diehl
- Who exactly was Herbert W Armstrong?
- DAVID C PACK: We Are In A Serious Dilemma! EVERYTHING I HAVE WRITTEN IS WRONG!
- Evaluating the Rumors about Herbert Armstrong and Incest
- Apostolic Treasures: The Treasures Of Herbert W Armstrong
- Bob Thiel: The Remarkable Story of The Mysterious ThD and Subtle Deceptions of Bob Thiel
- Wacky World of Dave Pack
- David C. Pack's Wacky World 2
- Mulling Things Over With Dennis Page 1
- "Mulling Things Over With Dennis" Page 2
- Mulling Things Over With Dennis Page 3
- Van Robison
- Idiots in the Pulpit
- Herbert Armstrong's Tangled Web
- Armstrongism: Is It The Plain Truth? 8/5
- The Daughter of Babylon: A True History of the Workdwide Church of God
- The Armstrong Error Booklet
- Mr. Confusion 1971
- Book: The Truth Shall Make You Free
- UCG/COGWA Child Molester
- Rod Meredith HATES This Blog!
- PCG Suicide
- How Fred Dattalo, Cal Culpepper and Gerald Flurry Caused A PCG Suicide
- LCG Pedophiles
- Rod McNair Says Elderly Possessed By Demons
- Herbert Armstrong Confesses to Incest!
- Herbert Armstrong's Documented Prophecies By Decad...
- Worldwide Church of God vs. Philadelphia Church of God
- Pasadena Campus in 2019
- Ambassador College Pasadena Campus Demolition and ...
- Disclaimer
- Home
Friday, November 20, 2026
Noah's Ark, the Great Whore, and Bob Thiel's Prophetic Imagination
Bob Thiel has discovered yet another way to turn an ordinary subject into an end-time conspiracy. This time, the subject is Noah's Ark. According to his reasoning, should archaeologists ever conclusively establish that the Ark has been found, the discovery could become a tool of Satan, helping the Roman Catholic Church and its supposed ecumenical allies unite the world's religions under a counterfeit Christianity. Apparently, even Noah's old boat cannot escape Armstrongism's prophetic imagination. One wonders what would happen if somebody discovered Noah's lunchbox. Would that become the opening ceremony for the New World Religion?
In his article and accompanying video, Risks of Finding Noah's Ark?, Thiel presents two possible dangers. First, the discovery might eventually be exposed as false, giving biblical skeptics another reason to question Scripture. Second, if the Ark were authenticated, its discovery could supposedly become an instrument for advancing an ecumenical world religion. Because numerous cultures have flood traditions, Thiel imagines that the discovery might provide common ground for bringing people together under a counterfeit Christianity. He even introduces the visions attributed to nineteenth-century Catholic mystic Anne Catherine Emmerich, suggesting that renewed attention to her claims might give the emerging religious movement an additional boost.
Consider the logic. An archaeological discovery that might encourage people to investigate Genesis becomes, in Thiel's imagination, a potential instrument of Satan. Instead of considering that people might simply find the discovery historically interesting, or that Christians might regard it as an encouragement to explore their Scriptures, we are asked to contemplate a grand prophetic conspiracy involving Catholics, mystics, international religion, and the Beast. Apparently, the Devil has nothing better to do than wait for an archaeological research team in Turkey to finish its paperwork.
The first supposed danger is particularly amusing. What if the Ark turns out not to be the Ark? Well, archaeological claims should be investigated, evidence should be examined, and conclusions should follow the facts. But notice how Thiel has arranged his prophetic escape hatch. If the discovery proves false, skeptics gain ammunition. If it proves genuine, Satan might use it to advance the Beast's religious system. There is apparently no possible outcome in which the discovery simply becomes an interesting historical event. What a convenient prophetic arrangement! Either way, the apocalyptic narrative gets another chapter.
Of course, there is an important distinction between finding something that resembles an ancient vessel and conclusively identifying it as Noah's Ark. The Durupınar formation in Turkey has attracted renewed investigation, including radar surveys, but the identification of the formation as the biblical Ark has not been established. Perhaps the sensible response would be to wait for the evidence. Unfortunately, patience isn't nearly as exciting as prophecy.
Thiel quotes Matthew 24:36-44, where Jesus compares the coming of the Son of Man to the days of Noah. But let's actually read what Jesus says. People were eating, drinking, marrying, conducting ordinary affairs, and carrying on with their lives. They were unaware of what was coming until the flood arrived. Jesus' point is that people should remain watchful because the timing of his coming is unknown.
Where, exactly, does Jesus mention an archaeological discovery? Where does he suggest that Noah's Ark will be discovered and subsequently used by Rome to establish an international religious alliance? Where does he connect ancient flood traditions among different cultures with the rise of the Beast? Nowhere. Jesus was teaching about readiness, not providing a prophetic briefing on the future activities of archaeological research organizations.
Thiel has taken a passage about spiritual vigilance and attached an elaborate scenario to it that the passage itself simply does not contain. This is the recurring weakness of Armstrongist biblical interpretation: Scripture becomes a collection of prophetic building blocks that can be rearranged to support almost any frightening possibility.
Thiel also invokes Revelation 13:4 and 13:8 to support his concerns about worldwide religious allegiance. Those verses describe the worship of the Beast and the allegiance of the inhabitants of the earth. They do not mention Noah's Ark, archaeological discoveries, Anne Catherine Emmerich, or a flood-related ecumenical campaign. One can certainly discuss the religious and political power described in Revelation, but moving from that text to the proposition that the discovery of an ancient vessel will help establish such a system requires several assumptions that Thiel never demonstrates.
Perhaps someone somewhere might attempt to use an archaeological discovery for religious purposes. Religious institutions have certainly used history, archaeology, and ancient traditions in their public presentations. But that possibility is not evidence of a coordinated end-time conspiracy. A hypothetical possibility does not become biblical prophecy simply because someone attaches Revelation 13 to it.
Thiel also introduces the visions attributed to Anne Catherine Emmerich, suggesting that a discovery of the Ark could cause people to regard her visions as divinely inspired. Instead of asking whether the reported visions have historical credibility, or whether they should be taken seriously in the first place, Thiel imagines how they might be exploited by a future religious conspiracy.
The reasoning is essentially this: someone might believe a Catholic mystic, someone else might become interested in Noah's Ark, and eventually the whole thing might contribute to the rise of the Beast's religious system. That's quite a theological Rube Goldberg machine! One could construct an equally elaborate theory involving almost any archaeological discovery, religious tradition, or historical personality. The problem is that speculation about what somebody might do someday is not evidence of what God has supposedly prophesied will happen.
This episode is bigger than Noah's Ark. It illustrates a fundamental characteristic of Armstrongism: the persistent need to interpret the world through a framework of impending catastrophe, religious deception, and prophetic danger. Nothing is allowed to remain ordinary. An archaeological discovery becomes a satanic instrument, a religious conversation becomes an ecumenical conspiracy, a Catholic mystic becomes a potential agent in an end-time deception, and even a story shared by different cultures becomes another piece of evidence for an approaching world religion.
And all of this is presented under the banner of biblical understanding. But where is the good news in this endless exercise of suspicion? Where is the emphasis on Christ, grace, reconciliation, mercy, and the New Covenant? The New Testament calls Christians to discernment, certainly, but it also calls them to love their neighbors, pursue peace, and keep their attention on Christ rather than become consumed by speculative fears. There is a world of difference between being watchful and becoming obsessed with inventing new things to be frightened about.
Armstrongism has spent decades teaching its followers to look at the world through a lens of impending disaster. It has developed an impressive talent for turning almost anything into another reason to be alarmed. Meanwhile, Jesus' actual instruction in Matthew 24 remains remarkably straightforward: be ready, because nobody knows the day or hour. He didn't tell his followers to spend their lives trying to identify the Devil's next archaeological publicity campaign.
Bob, if somebody actually discovers Noah's Ark, perhaps we should allow archaeologists to investigate it, historians to examine it, and Christians to consider its significance without immediately assigning Satan a starring role in the proceedings. And if the discovery turns out to be a geological formation rather than an ancient vessel, perhaps we can accept that too. Not every unusual rock formation is a divine sign, not every religious gathering is a conspiracy, and not every archaeological discovery is a prelude to the Beast's arrival. Sometimes a boat-shaped formation is simply a boat-shaped formation.
Perhaps the greatest archaeological discovery still waiting to be made in Armstrongism is the discovery of a little peace of mind. And if Bob ever finds it, I suspect he'll write an article warning that Satan intends to use it to establish the One World Religion.
African Brethren Sleeping in the Bush After Their Houses Were Torched and Others Killed; Bob Checks the Box on Helping the Oppressed
Tribal differences plus disputed election results remain a reliable recipe for bloodshed in parts of Africa. Bwana Bob's Continuing Church of God has already lost members to it: some killed, others watching their homes get demolished and burned, still others sleeping in the bush so they don't become the next targets.
As the result the opposition placed their leaders in Zambezia province to start rulling including our chiefs whom you know. Now the rulling chief were given power to rule as it was in the past but the opposition are denieng to to surrender the work which is bringing fighting in the area and brethren are in great problem. Houses of brethren have be demolished and burnt together with properties. Brethren are sleeping in the bush to avoid being killed as they are coming at night for revenge. Two brethren has died. After hearing that I went to Mozambique yesterday to see the situation and I have confirmed that brethren are really suffering. For example to get food! It is becoming a great problem. During my trip I gave them then some things for them to use. I have discuss with Deacon Jackson for the brethren to transfer from Nasiyaya to Duya so that they can use our church building and camp there. Am planning to go to Duya tomorrow to see the situation. Let us join hands to pray for the brethren so that this fighting...
We strive to help the hungry and oppressed.
Church Government, Truth and Armstrongism
Church Government, Truth and Armstrongism
Lonnie Hendrix
After the upheaval of the Seventies, the Worldwide Church of God settled into its final iteration of the Herbert Armstrong era. In the September 1979 edition of The Good News magazine, the article “CHRIST NOW MOVES TO PUT GOD'S GOVERNMENT BACK ON THE TRACK” appeared, and it was attributed to none other than Herbert W. Armstrong! The article read: “Forty-six years ago, God raised up Herbert W. Armstrong, opening his mind to God's TRUTH, using him as Christ's instrument in raising up the present era of the CHURCH OF GOD. Through Mr. Armstrong, Jesus Christ RESTORED THE GOVERNMENT OF GOD -- not, of course, yet over the world, but over the Church - as the ONLY PLACE ON EARTH where the GOVERNMENT OF GOD is administered, preparing for the SOON-COMING OF CHRIST IN SUPREME POWER AND GLORY TO SET UP THE KINGDOM OF GOD OVER ALL THE EARTH!” Even within that organization, however, more than a few folks were groaning when they read those words – many of them instinctively knew that something was amiss.
For Herbert, “the truth” was the package of beliefs that Mr. Armstrong claimed that God had revealed to HIM to “restore” to his Church. Never mind, that Christ had declared that HE was “the way, and the truth, and the life,” and that no one came to the Father except through HIM. (John 14:6, ESV) Forget, that the Gospel of John stated that “the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.” (John 1:17) Just set aside all of the statements to the contrary – like Christ’s declaration to Pilate that he came to this earth “to bear witness to the truth,” and that only those who listened to what HE said would participate in that truth. (John 18:37) Indeed, to accept Herbert’s notion of truth, you must ignore that Christ said that LOVE would identify his true followers, NOT knowledge. (John 13:35) Never mind, that Paul said that “if I have prophetic powers, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but have not love, I am nothing.” (I Corinthians 13:2) Just ignore the fact that Paul didn’t even mention spiritual knowledge or understanding as a fruit or evidence of the Holy Spirit. (Galatians 5:22-23)
Now, what about that government that Mr. Armstrong mentioned? Throughout the New Testament, the government/kingdom of God is portrayed as being personified by Jesus Christ! He was the government of God on earth. After his ascension into heaven, those same writings inform us that Christ continued to be the head/leader of the Church. Even so, the New Testament also makes very clear that Christ designated thirteen men to be apostles within his Church, and those writings make equally clear that those men were given responsibilities and authority vis a vis the Church. Moreover, those same writings make plain that Peter, Paul, James, and John were regarded by most of the people of the Church as exercising special gifts and influence within that body of believers. Initially, Jerusalem served as the “mother” congregation of the Church. The place where everything had started, and the place that the original apostles continued to regard as their base of operations. Indeed, the great council of the Church which met at Jerusalem (see Acts 15) demonstrates the special role that that congregation played in the early Church – even influencing what happened in the far-flung Gentile congregations!
In terms of history, however, we know that the Jerusalem Church lost much of its power and place among Christians as a consequence of the Roman’s wars against the Jews (especially as pertains to the events of 70 AD). In its place, other centers of power began to spring up around the Roman Empire among Gentile cities. Rome, the capital city, of course, was one of them. After all, according to tradition, both Peter and Paul met their ends in that city. In similar fashion, over time, important cities like Alexandria, Antioch, and Constantinople emerged as places which exerted an oversized influence on the rest of the Christian community. In the West, of course, the Bishop of Rome eventually came to be regarded as the human “leader” of Christendom. (See Who Was the First Pope?) In the East, however, power remained less centralized and more resistant to a single leader. Later still, beginning with Martin Luther nailing a paper to a door in 1517, the Protestant Reformation was launched; and a large number of European Christians declared their independence from Rome and its Bishop.
Then, in the Twentieth Century, along came a man by the name of Herbert Armstrong. Herbert began studying the Bible in a small local library in Oregon and quickly decided that traditional Christianity had abandoned its roots. Indeed, according to Armstrong, the Christian Church and its leadership had lost many of the “truths” of the Bible and had adopted a false gospel about Jesus Christ. He claimed that the “good news” wasn’t about salvation through Jesus of Nazareth – that it was a message about the future restoration of the Kingdom of God on earth. Indeed, Mr. Armstrong was so convinced that the majority of Christianity had gotten things backwards, that he began to believe that God was using HIM to set things to right – to restore what he claimed had been lost. Having decided that the Saturday Sabbath was the only correct day on which to worship God, Armstrong joined the Church of God Seventh Day and began preaching his “restored truths” to anyone who would listen. Unfortunately, however, the leadership of that organization did not see many of Armstrong’s “truths” as being consistent with Scripture and made clear that he was teaching things that were not accepted by the Church as a whole.
Incensed and disgruntled, Mr. Armstrong decided to form his own Church of God. Moreover, over time, he declared that God had transferred the mantle of Divine authority to him and his organization, and that he alone possessed “THE TRUTH.” Eventually, as we have already seen, Armstrong and many of his followers came to view him as God’s apostle for the “End Times.” Thus, Herbert became the sole authority on what constituted God’s truth. Indeed, after initially rejecting the claims of Peter’s supremacy and Papal authority, Herbert Armstrong embraced the notion and proclaimed himself to be Christ’s representative on earth! What had taken the traditional Christian community hundreds of years to achieve was achieved by Mr. Armstrong in the space of a single human lifespan. He claimed the authority to set doctrine within the Church and to excommunicate (disfellowship) anyone who disagreed with him and/or his teachings. Eventually, Herbert got to the place where he wouldn’t tolerate interference by anyone and encouraged his followers to forsake any sources of information that did not originate in HIM!
This, of course, was directly contrary to the teachings of Jesus Christ on the subject of authority among his disciples – within HIS Church. Christ told his apostles: “You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. It shall not be so among you. But whoever would be great among you must be your servant, and whoever would be first among you must be your slave, even as the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” (Matthew 20:25-28) In other words, the authoritarian or top-down model was excluded by Jesus Christ from HIS Church!
Indeed, the Apostle Paul also wrote to the saints at Corinth that no cults of personality should exist within God’s Church. (I Corinthians 1:10-17) In other words, the saints should not be following a man or men – Jesus is the author and finisher of our faith! Paul also warned the Galatians not to accept a counterfeit Gospel – one that didn’t have Christ as its centerpiece! (Galatians 1:6-9) He wrote: “For I would have you know, brothers, that the gospel that was preached by me is not man's gospel. For I did not receive it from any man, nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Jesus Christ. For you have heard of my former life in Judaism, how I persecuted the church of God violently and tried to destroy it. And I was advancing in Judaism beyond many of my own age among my people, so extremely zealous was I for the traditions of my fathers. But when he who had set me apart before I was born, and who called me by his grace, was pleased to reveal his Son to me, in order that I might preach him among the Gentiles, I did not immediately consult with anyone; nor did I go up to Jerusalem to those who were apostles before me, but I went away into Arabia, and returned again to Damascus.” (Galatians 1:11-17)
Clearly, Jesus Christ introduced the concept of servant leadership to his disciples, and he explicitly condemned the authoritarian model practiced by the rulers of this world. Moreover, the writings of the New Testament make very plain that Jesus of Nazareth is THE TRUTH, and that HE is at the center of the message known as the Gospel or “good news!” Thus, Herbert Armstrong is exposed as a false teacher, a false apostle, and someone who did NOT serve God, Jesus, the Holy Spirit, or THEIR people. Instead, he is shown to be an apostate from the faith delivered to the real apostles by Jesus Christ, and someone who exercised an authority which was certainly NOT granted to him from on high! Hence, we MUST conclude that any man or organization which claims to have inherited his mantle or to advance his teachings is as false as the foundation upon which he/it exists!
Thursday, November 19, 2026
The Only True Zerubbabel Says Repent, Leave Your “Splinter,” Or Be A Vomit-Worthy Laodicean!
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Mark Little (God's Church Holding Fast) Says You Make Christ Sick to His Stomach!
It is another installment in the endless Armstrongist "Hold Fast or Die" series. In this short video from the Matthew24Signs channel (tied to the ultra-tiny "God's Church Holding Fast" crowd), Mark Little and company solemnly declare that Paul's "falling away" (2 Thessalonians 2:3) was fulfilled right after Herbert W. Armstrong died in 1986, when the Worldwide Church of God started tossing out HWA's special package of "restored truths." Anyone who doesn't cling to the full HWA canon-Sabbath as the identifying sign, Holy Days, tithing, British-Israelism, the precise government structure, the place-of-safety escape, the dual resurrection details, and every other unique Armstrongian twist-is either Laodicean or already apostate. Only the pure remnant who never let a single page of HWA literature slip from their sweaty grip will keep their crown.
It's the same old story: the New Covenant is apparently too quiet, too settled, and too insufficient. The New Covenant (Jeremiah 31:31-34, Hebrews 8-10, Galatians, Romans 3-8) gives the believer a peaceful heart precisely because righteousness is by faith in Christ's finished work. The law is written on the heart by the Spirit; the old-covenant shadows and the endless external checklist are no longer the measuring stick. Peace, assurance, and rest in Christ are the actual fruit.
That is intolerable to the "Holding Fast" mindset. A peaceful heart does not generate the continuous low-grade panic required to keep the remnant pure and the tithes flowing. So the video (and the entire genre) must constantly whip the audience into a frenzy: You might lose your crown. You might be Laodicean. You might miss the place of safety. You might have already fallen away if you so much as question one of HWA's unique doctrines or notice that mainstream Christianity has the basic gospel right. The "love of the truth" is redefined as love of the entire HWA archive. Any move toward the New Covenant's freedom from law as a means of righteousness is branded the prophesied apostasy.
It's a closed loop that can never rest. The more the New Covenant offers settled assurance ("it is finished," "no condemnation," "the law of the Spirit of life has set you free"), the harder the message must work to manufacture urgency, fear of missing out on Philadelphia status, and suspicion of anyone who actually enjoys peace with God without the full Armstrongian scaffolding. The video's earnest "You need to know!" is just the latest reminder that, for these groups, a quiet conscience is the real threat. Frenzy is the product. The New Covenant keeps getting in the way.
Video here: The Falling Away
Beware: this will give you a bad case of PTSD.
The Holy Relic Goes Down: PCG Weeps as the Ship That Once Carried Herbert W. Armstrong Becomes Fish Habitat
In the annals of prophetic COG nonsense, the Philadelphia Church of God has once again distinguished itself. On November 17, 2026, the online Trumpet published "The Sad Symbolism in the Sinking of the SS United States," treating the deliberate, carefully engineered scuttling of a 74-year-old, long-mothballed ocean liner as a grim harbinger of America's collapse.
The horror? The SS United States-the fastest ocean liner ever built, larger than the Titanic, record-holder for the Atlantic crossing-was towed from Mobile, Alabama, to a site about 22 nautical miles off Destin, Florida, and flooded through prepared openings so it could settle on the bottom in roughly 180 feet of water as the world's largest artificial reef. No torpedo. No iceberg. Just valves opened, toxins and fuel already stripped, and a planned second life as habitat and dive tourism. Okaloosa County bought the rusting hulk for a million dollars after decades of failed preservation schemes left it rotting at a Philadelphia pier. The ship even resisted for hours longer than expected because it was built like a brick-exactly as its designers intended.
To the rest of the world, this is an old vessel that outlived its commercial usefulness (withdrawn from service in 1969 as jets killed the liner trade), spent most of its remaining decades as a floating eyesore, and is now being recycled into something useful. To the PCG, it is nearly sacramental. Why? Because the holy and perfect Herbert W. Armstrong once sailed on it.
Armstrong wrote in his autobiography that he and Loma boarded the "new, fastest ship in the world" on August 5, 1954. Rod Meredith later recounted a 1960 crossing that included the U.S. Treasurer and other dignitaries while he traveled with the Armstrongs. In 1961 Armstrong met a steward whose family had been reading the Plain Truth. Armstrong was even offered the chance to conduct a church service aboard "America's biggest, fastest and proudest ship" and turned it down over "religious differences." That, apparently, is enough to turn a practical reefing project into end-time symbolism.
The Trumpet piece cannot resist the parallels. The ship was deliberately sunk on Veterans Day. Gerald Flurry had just published an editorial declaring the midterm elections a "disaster in the nation's history" that would "hasten America's downfall." Therefore, the valves opening on the SS United States to sink it must mean the same thing for the country. They even drag out Armstrong's old 19-year time-cycle arithmetic and Flurry's 1998 "A Titanic Lesson" article, in which Britain and America were warned they were not "unsinkable." The SS United States, larger and faster than the Titanic, is now "the largest passenger vessel on the ocean floor," going down not to screams but to cheering spectators. Metaphors everywhere, for those with eyes to see-or at least for those who still treat HWA's travel itinerary as a prophetic timeline.
One almost has to admire the commitment. An aging, expensive-to-maintain ship that no one could afford to turn into a museum or hotel is cleaned of environmental hazards, scuttled under Army Corps and EPA standards, and turned into a reef that will attract marine life and divers. In PCG cosmology, this becomes proof that the United States "refuses to die" yet is "destined to die" for lack of willpower-because the same steel that once carried Herbert Armstrong is now home to grouper and amberjack.
The practical details do not interest them. The ship sat neglected for decades. Preservationists lost the battle. The county is spending tourist-tax money to create habitat and a dive site next to the already-reefed USS Oriskany. Divers will be able to visit it. The upper decks will sit shallow enough for less-experienced divers. None of that registers when the only relevant fact is that the holy Apostle of the Radio Church of God once crossed the Atlantic on it and declined to preach on board.
Armstrongism has always specialized in this kind of relic-hunting. Ships, buildings, dates, and personal anecdotes become charged with cosmic meaning the moment a leader was involved. The SS United States is simply the latest object to be pressed into service. It will now host snapper and moray eels instead of co-worker letters and church services that were never held. For everyone except the Philadelphia Church of God, that is not a tragedy. It is a ship that finally found a useful purpose after decades of doing nothing at all.
LCG: How One Little Sentence Lets Us Know It Is Running a Geriatric Farm with a Daycare Attached.
LCG had its recent Council of Elders meeting and Gerald Weston is here to assure the faithful that everything is fine. The 18 elders spent three days in "camaraderie, support, and wisdom," which is council-speak for "we sat around, compared notes on the same old problems, and decided the numbers still look okay if you squint hard enough." Then he dropped the line that tells you everything you need to know about the Living Church of God in 2026:
Congregations are "stable overall," attendance "has not changed dramatically" because older members keep dying, and there are "significant pockets of children" in some places. Oh, and 27.6 percent of people who bothered to fill out a Festival survey started attending in the last ten years. Behold, proof that the work is still alive!
Let's translate the carefully chosen language. "Stable" and "has not changed dramatically" means the headcount is roughly flat. The elderly are exiting the way elderly people do. The children who are born into LCG families (or whose parents brought them in years ago and kept them) are roughly replacing those who die. That is not growth. That is replacement-level fertility inside a closed system while the surrounding Armstrongist world continues its long, slow demographic collapse.
Weston treats this as good news. In the rest of the Armstrongist universe, the math has been unkind for decades: aging congregations, thin youth ranks, and net attrition once you factor in deaths, walk-aways, and the occasional split. LCG's "pockets of children" are real enough in certain places, but they are the product of members having kids, not of a dynamic, expanding work pulling large numbers of new adults. When your attendance only holds steady because the birth rate roughly offsets the death rate, you are not building an empire. You are running a geriatric farm with a daycare attached.
The 27.6 percent figure is the shiny object. It "flies in the face of those who claim the work was finished decades ago." Sure. Some people still trickle in. Festival surveys are also voluntary, self-selecting, and filled out by people who are already engaged enough to attend and answer questions. It is not the same as showing that net adult conversion is driving meaningful growth. If it were, the overall attendance would not be "not changed dramatically." The deaths of older members would be more than offset by new adults, not merely balanced by the children of existing ones.
Weston goes on to say there are some disturbances in the force in some church area, causing Weston to note that "there always have been and always will be problems in this age." This is the theological get-out-of-jail-free card. It allows leadership to acknowledge that things are messy without ever admitting that the messes might have anything to do with doctrine, governance, personality cults, failed predictions, or the usual Armstrongist baggage. The problems are just "this age." The elders are dedicated. The congregations are stable. Move along.
Anyone who has followed LCG (or any of the other Churches of God) knows the problems are not abstract. They are the ordinary frictions of a high-control, hierarchical system that still expects members to treat the leadership's interpretations as binding while the leadership itself continues to tweak, explain away, and reinterpret earlier certainties. When the headcount only stays even because births replace deaths, those frictions do not go away. They just get distributed across a membership that is not expanding fast enough to dilute them.
The implicit claim is that LCG is the "living" church precisely because it has not yet entered the death spiral visible elsewhere in Armstrongism. That is a low bar. Holding steady while the rest of the movement shrinks is better than shrinking yourself, but it is not the same as being a vibrant, expanding work. It is demographic stasis with a press release. The children in those "significant pockets" will grow up inside the same system. Some will stay. Some will leave when they are old enough to notice the gap between the rhetoric and the reality. The 27.6 percent who arrived in the last decade will either stay long enough to become the next generation of aging members, or they will discover, as many before them have, that the work looks more finished the longer you stay.
Weston's update is not a report of robust growth. It is a report that the bleeding has slowed to a trickle and that the birth rate is currently high enough to keep the total from falling. In Armstrongist terms, that counts as victory. In any other terms, it is an admission that the Living Church of God is living, for the moment, mostly by not dying as fast as the alternatives.
As I am writing, this is the last of three days of meetings for the 18 members of the Council of Elders, and I appreciate the camaraderie, support, and wisdom among this group of dedicated men. They report that the congregations are stable overall, though there always have been and always will be problems in this age.
One surprise that came to light is that 27.6 percent of people who turned in a Festival survey this year began attending in the last ten years, which flies in the face of those who claim the work was finished decades ago. Our overall attendance has not changed dramatically, due to deaths of older members, but we are seeing significant pockets of children in some congregations. Due to the busy schedule of meetings, there will be no video update this week. —Gerald E. Weston







