Church Government, Truth and Armstrongism
Lonnie Hendrix
After the upheaval of the Seventies, the Worldwide Church of God settled into its final iteration of the Herbert Armstrong era. In the September 1979 edition of The Good News magazine, the article “CHRIST NOW MOVES TO PUT GOD'S GOVERNMENT BACK ON THE TRACK” appeared, and it was attributed to none other than Herbert W. Armstrong! The article read: “Forty-six years ago, God raised up Herbert W. Armstrong, opening his mind to God's TRUTH, using him as Christ's instrument in raising up the present era of the CHURCH OF GOD. Through Mr. Armstrong, Jesus Christ RESTORED THE GOVERNMENT OF GOD -- not, of course, yet over the world, but over the Church - as the ONLY PLACE ON EARTH where the GOVERNMENT OF GOD is administered, preparing for the SOON-COMING OF CHRIST IN SUPREME POWER AND GLORY TO SET UP THE KINGDOM OF GOD OVER ALL THE EARTH!” Even within that organization, however, more than a few folks were groaning when they read those words – many of them instinctively knew that something was amiss.
For Herbert, “the truth” was the package of beliefs that Mr. Armstrong claimed that God had revealed to HIM to “restore” to his Church. Never mind, that Christ had declared that HE was “the way, and the truth, and the life,” and that no one came to the Father except through HIM. (John 14:6, ESV) Forget, that the Gospel of John stated that “the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.” (John 1:17) Just set aside all of the statements to the contrary – like Christ’s declaration to Pilate that he came to this earth “to bear witness to the truth,” and that only those who listened to what HE said would participate in that truth. (John 18:37) Indeed, to accept Herbert’s notion of truth, you must ignore that Christ said that LOVE would identify his true followers, NOT knowledge. (John 13:35) Never mind, that Paul said that “if I have prophetic powers, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have all faith, so as to remove mountains, but have not love, I am nothing.” (I Corinthians 13:2) Just ignore the fact that Paul didn’t even mention spiritual knowledge or understanding as a fruit or evidence of the Holy Spirit. (Galatians 5:22-23)
Now, what about that government that Mr. Armstrong mentioned? Throughout the New Testament, the government/kingdom of God is portrayed as being personified by Jesus Christ! He was the government of God on earth. After his ascension into heaven, those same writings inform us that Christ continued to be the head/leader of the Church. Even so, the New Testament also makes very clear that Christ designated thirteen men to be apostles within his Church, and those writings make equally clear that those men were given responsibilities and authority vis a vis the Church. Moreover, those same writings make plain that Peter, Paul, James, and John were regarded by most of the people of the Church as exercising special gifts and influence within that body of believers. Initially, Jerusalem served as the “mother” congregation of the Church. The place where everything had started, and the place that the original apostles continued to regard as their base of operations. Indeed, the great council of the Church which met at Jerusalem (see Acts 15) demonstrates the special role that that congregation played in the early Church – even influencing what happened in the far-flung Gentile congregations!
In terms of history, however, we know that the Jerusalem Church lost much of its power and place among Christians as a consequence of the Roman’s wars against the Jews (especially as pertains to the events of 70 AD). In its place, other centers of power began to spring up around the Roman Empire among Gentile cities. Rome, the capital city, of course, was one of them. After all, according to tradition, both Peter and Paul met their ends in that city. In similar fashion, over time, important cities like Alexandria, Antioch, and Constantinople emerged as places which exerted an oversized influence on the rest of the Christian community. In the West, of course, the Bishop of Rome eventually came to be regarded as the human “leader” of Christendom. (See Who Was the First Pope?) In the East, however, power remained less centralized and more resistant to a single leader. Later still, beginning with Martin Luther nailing a paper to a door in 1517, the Protestant Reformation was launched; and a large number of European Christians declared their independence from Rome and its Bishop.
Then, in the Twentieth Century, along came a man by the name of Herbert Armstrong. Herbert began studying the Bible in a small local library in Oregon and quickly decided that traditional Christianity had abandoned its roots. Indeed, according to Armstrong, the Christian Church and its leadership had lost many of the “truths” of the Bible and had adopted a false gospel about Jesus Christ. He claimed that the “good news” wasn’t about salvation through Jesus of Nazareth – that it was a message about the future restoration of the Kingdom of God on earth. Indeed, Mr. Armstrong was so convinced that the majority of Christianity had gotten things backwards, that he began to believe that God was using HIM to set things to right – to restore what he claimed had been lost. Having decided that the Saturday Sabbath was the only correct day on which to worship God, Armstrong joined the Church of God Seventh Day and began preaching his “restored truths” to anyone who would listen. Unfortunately, however, the leadership of that organization did not see many of Armstrong’s “truths” as being consistent with Scripture and made clear that he was teaching things that were not accepted by the Church as a whole.
Incensed and disgruntled, Mr. Armstrong decided to form his own Church of God. Moreover, over time, he declared that God had transferred the mantle of Divine authority to him and his organization, and that he alone possessed “THE TRUTH.” Eventually, as we have already seen, Armstrong and many of his followers came to view him as God’s apostle for the “End Times.” Thus, Herbert became the sole authority on what constituted God’s truth. Indeed, after initially rejecting the claims of Peter’s supremacy and Papal authority, Herbert Armstrong embraced the notion and proclaimed himself to be Christ’s representative on earth! What had taken the traditional Christian community hundreds of years to achieve was achieved by Mr. Armstrong in the space of a single human lifespan. He claimed the authority to set doctrine within the Church and to excommunicate (disfellowship) anyone who disagreed with him and/or his teachings. Eventually, Herbert got to the place where he wouldn’t tolerate interference by anyone and encouraged his followers to forsake any sources of information that did not originate in HIM!
This, of course, was directly contrary to the teachings of Jesus Christ on the subject of authority among his disciples – within HIS Church. Christ told his apostles: “You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. It shall not be so among you. But whoever would be great among you must be your servant, and whoever would be first among you must be your slave, even as the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” (Matthew 20:25-28) In other words, the authoritarian or top-down model was excluded by Jesus Christ from HIS Church!
Indeed, the Apostle Paul also wrote to the saints at Corinth that no cults of personality should exist within God’s Church. (I Corinthians 1:10-17) In other words, the saints should not be following a man or men – Jesus is the author and finisher of our faith! Paul also warned the Galatians not to accept a counterfeit Gospel – one that didn’t have Christ as its centerpiece! (Galatians 1:6-9) He wrote: “For I would have you know, brothers, that the gospel that was preached by me is not man's gospel. For I did not receive it from any man, nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Jesus Christ. For you have heard of my former life in Judaism, how I persecuted the church of God violently and tried to destroy it. And I was advancing in Judaism beyond many of my own age among my people, so extremely zealous was I for the traditions of my fathers. But when he who had set me apart before I was born, and who called me by his grace, was pleased to reveal his Son to me, in order that I might preach him among the Gentiles, I did not immediately consult with anyone; nor did I go up to Jerusalem to those who were apostles before me, but I went away into Arabia, and returned again to Damascus.” (Galatians 1:11-17)
Clearly, Jesus Christ introduced the concept of servant leadership to his disciples, and he explicitly condemned the authoritarian model practiced by the rulers of this world. Moreover, the writings of the New Testament make very plain that Jesus of Nazareth is THE TRUTH, and that HE is at the center of the message known as the Gospel or “good news!” Thus, Herbert Armstrong is exposed as a false teacher, a false apostle, and someone who did NOT serve God, Jesus, the Holy Spirit, or THEIR people. Instead, he is shown to be an apostate from the faith delivered to the real apostles by Jesus Christ, and someone who exercised an authority which was certainly NOT granted to him from on high! Hence, we MUST conclude that any man or organization which claims to have inherited his mantle or to advance his teachings is as false as the foundation upon which he/it exists!

4 comments:
A very good history of things and highlighting the sheer fakery and lies of an alleged apostle Armstrong. Amazing though people can't see through it even after all this time that has gone by since the noisy one passed on and all of the resources now available to test.
Miller Jones wrote, “Just ignore the fact that Paul didn’t even mention spiritual knowledge or understanding as a fruit or evidence of the Holy Spirit.”
You and I have discussed epistemology before. I think we are of only slightly different viewpoints. The counterpoint of the statement you make above is defined by several scriptures including Ephesians 1:17, John 16:13, 1 Corinthians 2: 10-13 and the verse I think of first which states, ”But the Advocate, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you everything and remind you of all that I have said to you.” (John 14:26, NRSV). Salvific knowledge is not only an evidence of the Holy Spirit but Is a product of the Holy Spirit’s activity.
I think that the process of conversion is not only the work of the Holy Spirit but is also epistemological. It is both action and revelation. I admit I don’t know how this works at the initiation. When an elect person is called is the response totally of the heart or is there knowledge involved? Certainly it is of the heart. The role of knowledge at the start is less clear. I do think it is a mistake to make growth in knowledge a requirement for salvation which seems to be the Armstrongist view – as if it were a qualifying work – you have to know the Correspondence Course inside out. I believe that knowledge is an outcome or product of salvation. And it will not be perfect knowledge because we see through a glass darkly – hence, the differences in theology among the various Christian denominations.
Some will quickly respond there are 300 major Christian traditions so correct knowledge cannot be that important. Somewhere there has to be a line in the sand. Paul condemned the Circumcision Party and said they had cut themselves off from Christ and had fallen from grace. Even though they apparently believed in Christ (Acts 15:5). There was a boundary of knowledge they had crossed that made them outside the pale of Christianity. Likewise, HWA was outside the pale of Christianity because of the sufficiently errant knowledge that he preached.
I don’t know where that line in the sand is precisely located for each person. That is a matter of judgement and I am not a judge. I know I want to be as far away from the wrong knowledge as is possible for me through the mercy of God in Christ.
Scout,
We have discussed this before, and I think we are very close in our thinking. As you know, Herbert Armstrong underscored understanding as the thing which identified "true" Christians from "so-called" Christians. For him, this was the evidence or fruit of having God's Spirit. I reject that notion entirely.
Christ said that love would identify his followers from those of the world. We know that the fruit/evidence of the Holy Spirit is found in Godly character traits, NOT in doctrinal knowledge or correctness. We have all witnessed the Spirit/Mind of Christ in action in people with little expertise or understanding of theological matters.
Having said all of that, it is also clear that the Holy Spirit can lead us into truth - into a relationship with Christ and his Father. Some Christians even acquire deep and profound understandings of the theology behind our faith based on their yielding to the guidance of the Holy Spirit - this is NOT widespread, and it is NOT required. The line in the sand is an acceptance of our own insufficiency, and the absolute necessity of Christ's intervention on our behalf. We must understand this and have faith in the efficacy of what Christ has done for us.
I agree with Christ, Paul, James, and John that the Holy Spirit can reveal, guide, lead us into a deeper understanding of our faith. I know that this also depends on our own willingness to yield, follow, and accept. Moreover, I believe the human part of this equation accounts for the wide variety of Christian traditions. Like you, I am always suspicious of those who stray too far from the teachings that have always been equated with orthodoxy. Even so, as you say, it is not our place to judge those folks. Thankfully, it's above our pay grade.
......a king (Hebrew Melek. "Melek" can apply to a non-existent leader of locusts - Prov 30:27, could be simply a leader, not necessarily of a country or nation) with a vehement countenance and dark sentences shall stand up. And his power shall be mighty, but not by his own power, and he shall corrupt to an extraordinary degree, and shall prosper, and do his thing, and shall corrupt numerous people of the saints. And through his policy also he shall cause deceit to prosper in his hand, and shall magnify himself in his heart (calling himself the apostle?) and during a time of peace shall corrupt many.........Daniel 8:23-25
Herbert W Armstrong ??
Post a Comment