Church of God Assembly has rolled out the familiar Armstrongist child-training sermon in its A Good Report magazine, and it is every bit as tone-deaf as the original. Failure to discipline "dooms a child's future." Parents must copy God's "loving correction." Proverbs 19:18 is trotted out in full King James glory: "Chasten your son while there is hope, and let not your soul spare for his crying." Proverbs 13:24 still gets top billing-spare the rod and you hate the kid. Tantrums, screaming, or hitting demand "swift punishment." Children must learn to "face the consequences." Lamentations 3:27 is pressed into service so that bearing the yoke in youth is presented as a feature, not a bug. Then, almost as an afterthought, they add the usual legal fig leaf: no face-slapping, no kicking, no hitting near vital organs, because "God hates child abuse!" Correction must be done in love, with the child's best interests in mind.
The fine print is new. The product is not.
This is the same script Herbert W. Armstrong's Worldwide Church of God pushed for decades, only now it comes with a slightly longer disclaimer after the lawsuits and the exit literature. Garner Ted Armstrong's The Plain Truth About Child Rearing treated spanking as the God-given method that actually works, not a reluctant last resort. It was to start early, be applied firmly enough to produce results, and be paired with lectures on parental authority. HWA endorsed the approach in print and from the pulpit; parents whose children misbehaved at services could expect public accountability. Imperial Schools and plenty of local congregations ran on paddles, switches, and belts. "Don't spare for his crying" was treated as practical advice, not poetry. Former members have described the ordinary, everyday version of this system: paddlings at school and home that went well past "swift correction," all justified by the same verses Church of God Assembly is recycling.
Armstrongism's results are a matter of public record. One WCG-connected household produced the "boy in the box" case after extreme confinement and beatings. That was extreme; the underlying culture that normalized pain as the primary language of authority was not. Multiple exit accounts describe children beaten under the banner of love and Proverbs, then left unprotected when the same hierarchical system shielded predators. Sexual abuse cases involving ministers, staff, or members were not rare. The institutions that taught parents to "chasten" without hesitation often proved slow or hostile when the problem was not a tantrum but predation. The repeated official line that "God hates child abuse" sat for decades next to teaching and practice that made physical punishment the default response to childish behavior.
Church of God Assembly keeps the core framework-rod, swift punishment, don't spare for crying, yoke in youth-while adding the modern disclaimer. That is the pattern across the surviving groups: the theology stays; the press release gets a little more careful. Philadelphia Church of God and others still publish material that praises the old Garner Ted booklet and describes measured swats for young children as loving training that produces "peaceable fruit." The vocabulary has shifted slightly. The underlying claim that pain is the reliable teacher of godly character has not.
Parents who treat a toddler's crying or a child's protest as an emergency requiring immediate physical correction are following the exact script the old church taught. Some stayed inside the lines the magazine now draws. Many did not. The children who grew up inside that system, and the ones who still do in the smaller groups that never abandoned it, supply the evidence the fine print never addresses
Failure to discipline dooms a child's future.A parent's discipline should be modeled after God's loving correction (Hebrews 12:5-8). Proverbs 19:18 instructs parents to:Chasten your son while there is hope, and let not your soul spare for his crying [KJV]And in Proverbs 13:24 it states:He who spares his rod hates his son, but he who loves him disci plines him promptly.The word "discipline" means "to each." Parents must make the rules for their children clear, fair, and consistent. The punishment should fit the crime. Parents should never accept unacceptable behavior-such as a child throwing a temper tantrum, screaming, or hitting.Such actions deserve swift punishment! Children need to learn to face the consequences of their actions.In the book of Lamentations 3:27 it states:It is good for a man to bear the yoke in his youth.It is work to discipline children but it will pay off in the long run. It must not go unmentioned that discipline for wrong acts or attitudes should never involve pushing, or slapping on the face, kicking or hitting near vital organs or any other physically damaging action. God hates child abuse!In administering discipline remember that correction should be done in love with the child's best interests in mind!

4 comments:
Of course, none of this advice applies to a minister's daughter whose parents must spoil her rotten with the brethren's hard-earned tithe money.
Yep. Just like any Fortune 500 company, the 'chosen ones' are exempt from pesky rules and procedures.
The truth is quite alot of ministry used the carrot and the stick with their own children, whilst teaching the members to use the rod. All done for various reasons, think about it.
The ministry knew their children in the AC system had a clear blessed pathway ahead of them. Ministry aspired for harmonous family life whilst desiring the members to have odd marriages and division amongst the members and families. It's all about control and competition.
The Armstrongs afterall was a strong family unit, even with their inner problems, so the desire was for ministry families to be strong and members families to be weak.Division causes weakness.
First sentence of your second paragraph, 2:31. Some of us PKs didn't want to bask in the sunlight of our ordained parents. Didn't want special treatment. Thought entitlement was disgusting, Just wanted to be ourselves, not an extension of, or miniaturized version of our parents. I had already picked up on the prevailing atmosphere of lust for authority and control at a young age at SEP, amongst the campers, thought it was totally bogus, and wanted no part of it. And, I never sold out. Did I pay dearly for this, as time progressed? Probably not. I was fortunate, learned from it, and found success in a completely different arena, one in which skills and opportunities paved the way rather than nepotism. It's been kind of cool doing this without any sort of title whatsoever.
In a hierarchy, even if you have authority, unless you are a really exceptional individual, people do not respect you for you. In other words, your power is artificially contrived. You are in a box. They respect the organization or entity which supposedly conferred your authority upon you, and backs you up. They can secretly think of you as a little pissant, misfit, or twerp, but are afraid to counter you because they realize that the entire system will come down on them if they do. You were not quite the natural leader you might have imagined yourself as being. If you leave, most will be thinking "good riddance". They would never follow you.
Now, back to the child-rearing. I listened to a confession I never thought I would hear. It came decades too late, but was something I had already instinctively realized. It was an admission that my parents, via all their abuse, were trying to "break my spirit". That is a horrible goal to have in raising your children! It destroys them, and certainly does not prepare them to "qualify" for leadership. It also breeds hatred, and a lifelong gulf which makes it impossible to have a normal relationship with such parents, if they remain part of the system that caused it. Thankfully, my parents did not break my spirit. Inadvertently, they provided me with something to work against, to work harder, a disadvantage to overcome. I can only hope that others were able to work through the disadvantages of Armstrongism and to find success throughout the many years of life which we thought we would never get to live!
Post a Comment