The Real Trick: Doubt Your Own Mind
In 1982, the Holy Herbie dropped a bombshell Good News article: there’s a “hidden enemy” in your home, and it’s not Satan this time—it’s emotional immaturity… YOUR emotional immaturity. But lets be honest, the real enemy wasn’t your feelings; it was the cult’s agenda to make you doubt your God-given ability to think. In a piece that’s pure manipulation, Ol’ Herb claimed emotional immaturity—your natural feelings like anger, fear, or grief—is breaking families and causing misery. The fix? Control your emotions, obey the Ten Commandments, and let your mind guide you into God’s way of “giving.” Sounds reasonable, right? Wrong—it’s a con to get you to stop trusting your own reasoning and hand your mind over to a mere man: Herb himself, the self-proclaimed apostle who demanded blind loyalty while his cult crumbled under scandals.
The WCG didn’t just control your emotions—they controlled your thoughts, making you doubt your rational instincts and surrender to Herb’s authority. Your gut told you something was wrong—failed prophecies, triple tithes, predatory leaders—but the cult gaslit you into thinking your doubts were immature, not godly. Its been nearly 40 since the Holy Herb wilted, it’s time to reclaim your God-given mind and see this for the manipulative agenda it was.
The Setup: Your Emotions Betray Your Mind
The article starts with a dramatic hook: there’s an enemy in your home, causing suffering—emotional immaturity. Herb defines it as a lack of control over feelings like fear, anger, and grief, calling it a “departure from the normal calm state of rational thinking.” He says babies naturally “take”—grabbing toys and bottles—but humans must be taught to “give,” aligning with God’s law of love (the Ten Commandments). Most people, he claims, never learn this, remaining emotionally stunted because parents and schools fail to teach it. The real secret to Christian living, he says, is using your mind to direct your actions, not your emotions.
Here’s the sleight of hand: Herb makes you doubt your own mind by framing your emotions as a betrayal of reason. If you feel angry about the WCG’s triple tithes bankrupting your family, or skeptical of their failed 1972 Tribulation prophecy, that’s not your God-given intellect at work—it’s emotional immaturity, a spiritual failing. The cult didn’t want you to trust your rational instincts—like questioning why the Armstrongs lived in luxury while you struggled. Instead, they wanted you to surrender your thinking to Herb, the “apostle” who claimed to speak for God. Your doubts weren’t the problem; the WCG was, and they gaslit you into thinking otherwise to keep you in line.
The Shame Game: Your Thoughts Aren’t Godly
Herb doubles down with a tragic case study: a highly educated man whose emotional immaturity—never learning to control his moods—led to a broken marriage and ruined career. He was spoiled as a child, never taught self-restraint, and let his feelings warp his understanding, remaining emotionally and spiritually a child. Herb laments that most people never grow up emotionally or spiritually, failing to achieve God’s purpose: developing “right character” through mind-directed actions.
This is where the manipulation deepens. The WCG didn’t just shame you for feeling emotions—they shamed you for thinking critically. If your mind questioned the cult’s scandals, that was emotional immaturity, not reason. If you doubted the endless financial demands that left you broke while Herb flew private jets, that was your childish feelings talking, not your God-given intellect. The cult gaslit you into doubting your own cognitive faculties, insisting that true maturity meant surrendering your thoughts to Herb’s authority. Your rational mind was screaming something was wrong, but the WCG called that a sin, ensuring you’d trust Herb over your own judgment.
The Control Tactic: Surrender to Herb, Not God
Herb pivots to child-rearing, urging parents to teach emotional maturity from infancy by controlling feelings like anger and jealousy, and directing them toward “giving” (love). He shares a personal story: his first funeral, where he nearly broke down in fear but was “sobered” by his father’s stern words and God’s help, achieving emotional balance—calm dignity with tenderness. He insists emotions aren’t to be nullified, just “guided” by the mind into God’s law, but his real message is clear: your mind should follow the WCG’s rules, not your own reasoning.
This is the core of the con: the WCG didn’t want you to use your mind—they wanted you to surrender it to the Dear Leader. “Giving” meant giving to the cult—your money, time, and loyalty—while suppressing any thoughts that challenged their authority. The cult framed critical thinking as a spiritual failing, ensuring you’d hand over your God-given faculties to a mere man who claimed to speak for God, all while his empire was built on lies and exploitation.
The Religious Spin: True Faith Means No Questions
Herb takes a jab at other religions, claiming emotional immaturity is most apparent in faith. Some groups, he says, work up emotions into a frenzy, shouting “Hallelujah!” with no thought, mistaking emotion for spirituality. Others are purely mental, rejecting the Holy Spirit. True spirituality, he argues, comes from the impersonal Holy Spirit electrical-like force, given only to those who obey God’s law (Acts 5:32), and is “sound mindedness” (2 Timothy 1:7), not emotional frenzy. The emotionally mature, he says, express controlled joy and sympathy, but never let emotion—or independent thought—substitute for spiritual obedience.
Here’s the rub: the WCG redefined spirituality as blind obedience to Herb, not God. If your mind questioned their legalistic rules and rituals—you weren’t being rational; you were being unspiritual. If you thought critically about Herb’s failed prophecies or the cult’s financial scams, that was your immature emotions, not your intellect. The cult didn’t want you to think for yourself; they wanted you to doubt your own mind and trust Herb’s instead, even as his leadership caused the real suffering: families split by disfellowshipment, lives ruined by financial draining, and faith shattered by lies. The WCG gaslit you into surrendering your cognitive faculties, all while claiming it was for your spiritual good.
Trust Your God-Given Mind
The WCG’s “hidden enemy” wasn’t emotional immaturity—it was the cult’s agenda to make you doubt your own mind and surrender your thinking to a mere man. Herb wanted you to see your rational instincts—your doubts about failed prophecies, financial exploitation, and predatory leadership—as a spiritual failing, ensuring you’d trust him over your God-given faculties. But your mind was right to question, and your emotions were right to scream. Stop letting the cult guilt you for thinking. Reclaim your cognitive freedom, ditch Armstrongism’s hidden agenda, and trust the mind God gave you to see the truth.
Hidden Enemy or Hidden Agenda? © 2025 by AiCOG is licensed under CC BY-ND 4.0