Sunday, May 10, 2020

When Ministers Defend Failed Church of God Prophets



We have all watched over the decades as one prophet after another said one whopper after another and yet here we are, 2020 and not one single thing any of them has ever said has come true. That sadly has never stopped the current crop of liars masquerading as God's most important men here on earth today. The very fact they self-appointed themselves should have been the first clue, but the endless stream of outright lies by these men should have caused every minister in their little group to walk out the door and leave them as they called them the apostate liars they are.  But no.  It rarely happens. Instead, these weak emasculated men DEFEND the liars they are employed by.

Case in point, Ed Winkfield from the Restored Church of God. Never has the church had such an epic failure when it comes to prophesy than Dave Pack.  Well, except for Bob Thiel, Ron Weinland, and Gerald Flurry.  These are all stories for another time.  Back to Dave and Winkfield.

Winkfield wrote an article for the faithful in the RCG regarding prophecy, Putting Prophecy In Perspective.  In it, he writes:
The recent pursuit of prophetic understanding has reshaped our view of the scriptures and revealed more of God’s mind on what a Christian’s priorities should be.
Daniel was close to God and trusted that he would continue to receive understanding. Thus, he may have been shocked when he learned from the angel that there was only so much of the future he could know.
Near the end of his book, Daniel recorded multiple visions. Upon their completion, he was told to “shut up the words, and seal the book, even to the time of the end,” and at that time—not a moment sooner—“knowledge shall be increased” (12:4). Still thinking he would be an exception and allowed to know prior what others could not, Daniel inquired in verse 8, “O my Lord, what shall be the end of these things?” The angel’s answer in verse 9 told Daniel he would not fully understand the meaning of the visions.
Despite being one of the greatest servants of God to ever live, Daniel was only allowed to know so much. He would not be permitted to understand the entirety of the very things he was recording.
Yet we have been permitted to understand these things. The recent increase in the knowledge of prophecy is actually the fulfillment of prophecy—an irrefutable sign that we are at the time of the end. By revealing prophecies in Daniel, God is doing what He said He would do.
As the Author of prophecy—history written in advance—God foretells major events before they happen: “…new things do I declare: before they spring forth I tell you of them” (Isa. 42:9). He continues: “…I am God, and there is none like Me, declaring the end from the beginning, and from ancient times the things that are not yet done…” (46:9-10). As “His servants,” we among all people on Earth are uniquely qualified to learn and understand what God says “must shortly come to pass” (Rev. 1:1). 
Here we go with the Daniel excuse that current false prophets love to utter to prove their legitimacy.  These men claim that because Daniel had things withheld form till the end times, that they and they alone know what those hidden things are.

Winkfield believes that the current prophecies of Dave are unprecedented in these modern times as the world spirals out of control in front of Dave's eyes
The urgency of our times has forced the entire Church to learn—over a brief period—prophecy at a level in the past taught only to its leadership over the course of many years in Ambassador College and ministerial conferences. As a “workman” or laborer striving to rightly divide the word of truth (II Tim. 2:15), you have likely studied harder and longer than you ever have. The sheer volume and complexity of information forced you to pour over your sermon notes, puzzle over the timing of events, and ponder the prophecy tools provided. But it has all been worth it as long-standing mysteries are being revealed.
Never has the church seen such a tremendous outpouring of prophetic revelations in church histry as it has today, even the already disproved prophecies of the church ( pre-1986, of course) pales in comparison to today's revelations.

The problem, according to Winkfield, is that prophecy prior to today was incomplete. It needed Dave to come along and set things straight.
The study of prophecy is an extremely rewarding pursuit yet one that can leave you feeling incomplete. Think about it. Despite all the Church has learned in recent years, and even over decades, nagging questions remain. The more we know, the more we want to know—leaving us unable to be completely satisfied. Paul knew this.
Paul also said we know and prophesy “in part.” This phrase is most crucial to recognize—and accept.
The phrase itself is not mysterious. It means a division or share of something whole. The same Greek word, rendered “piece” in Luke 24:42, was used to show Christ was given a part of a fish to eat after His resurrection. Interestingly, the root word for “part” is tied to an allotment, which is “a portion of something given.”
The apostle completes his thought by saying, “when that which is perfect [whole or complete] is come, then that which is in part shall be done away” (I Cor. 13:10).
What was Paul’s point? Prophetic knowledge comes in parts or sections. It is doled out by a loving God in allotments. This is the lesson with which Daniel had to come to grips. Paul’s use of “we” in verse 9 shows that this principle applies not just to individuals, but to the Church collectively. God gives knowledge of prophecy to His chief servants in portions, who then preach it to the Church. Come to grips with God’s process. 
According to Winkfield God dishes out "allotments" to his one true prophet that supersedes all other previous prophecies. Here a little, there a little.  that is why when Dave erases previous sermons or pulls them out of circulation it is because he has received a new allotment of understanding. this sadly leads to confusion in the RCG and members become disillusioned.  It is always the member's fault of getting caught up in church prophets lies, and never the liar himself. It's their fault they believed him in the first place.
Some in God’s Church over the years have gotten excited about prophecy, but mistakenly gone a step further and built their entire faith on the Church’s current level of prophetic understanding. When God inevitably gives another allotment of prophecy, leading to an update in our belief in how things will occur, their entire foundation is shaken. Occasionally it is shaken to the point of causing doubt and they go spiraling out of the Church. Instead of revelation being a blessing, it becomes a stumbling block. This should not be.
Notice the next things Winkfield says.  It is a new excuse when propecehs do no tocme tp pas and the prophet has to make a new revelation. God has not "perfected" his revelation. Any changes that coem later are the result of God "perfecting" the previous revelations.
Only after the prophesied event is “perfect,” meaning it occurred, will we have full knowledge of the event. Read that sentence again. Anyone expecting to have a complete and total understanding of a prophetic event prior to its fulfillment is doomed to fail! Do not allow partial knowledge of prophecy to needlessly frustrate you. Imagine if Daniel got into a bad attitude after the angel told him he could not know it all.
Apparently, everything Dave utters is incomplete and therefore members should NOT take them entirely as the final word. This gives Winkfield and others the excuse to excuse the failed lies of Dave.
Children are known for their insatiable curiosity. While they may not fully understand their world, they do not give up trying to comprehend. Understanding prophecy sparks curiosity in all of us. We are naturally eager to learn and to know details of what the future will bring. We may ponder: How long do we have until the end? What will Christ look like when He returns to His Temple? What is that army that surrounds Jerusalem? What exactly does “exousia” feel like? The questions go on.
Like children, we must continually seek to understand. However, as we slowly learned during our transition from childhood into adulthood, the accumulation of knowledge has its limits. No human being can know everything. (Except for Dave) As the famous saying goes, “The more I learn, the more I realize how much I don’t know.” As we mature, we learn that the amount of information in our world far outstrips our ability to contain it. The Bible does not even include everything Christ did (John 21:25). Paul’s child/man analogy thus is a fitting one for understanding prophecy.
While God requires us to have a suitable grasp of prophetic knowledge for salvation, He does not reveal all there is to know. The pursuit of prophetic understanding builds our faith and keeps us yearning for more—yet we should not allow the quest for this knowledge to consume our thinking to the point of being unbalanced.
Ya think?  Pass that on to Dave.  If anyone is unbalanced in the church right now, it is Dave.
This is where maturity comes in. We must pursue and understand events to come in a proper way. As we have been told, it does us no good to know everything about prophecy—specifically the Kingdom of God and how it will come—if we do not do the things that it takes to be in that Kingdom.
Since when has the Church of God ever truly "do the things" of the kingdom to come? Do they really think the way the Churches of God are run today is an example of what the kingdom of God will like?  Seriously? Heaven help us if it is.
The Word of God is compared to a mirror (Jms. 1:23). While peering into it for prophetic understanding, we, like Paul, can recognize certain elements. But, because the knowledge is partial, we cannot see every detail. Does it mean the details are not there? You get the point.
Paul said he would eventually “know even as also I am known,” meaning he would someday comprehend with such crystal clarity that it would be like seeing himself face to face the way others perceive him—exactly as he is, with the utmost detail. His understanding will be full, just as ours will ultimately be. In the meantime, we must settle with the fact that our knowledge is limited.
Understanding of prophecy comes from God. Though great servants of the past—even in the 20th-century Philadelphian era—could not grasp the fullness and detail of all we are learning, (till Dave, of course) this is not an insult to them. They were no less God’s servants than Daniel, who, along with Noah and Job, was one of the greatest servants who ever lived (Ezek. 14:20). Our prophetic understanding is not a function of our greatness or superiority. Instead, it is an end-time signal and revelation of things set to occur in our lifetimes.
The ability of Dave to make prophecies with each of his new revelations
First, the amazing ability to speak all languages, whether of men or angels, is reduced to noise if one does not display the love of God (vs. 1).
Then notice this, “And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge…” (vs. 2).
Stop. Recognize that this ability would change everything. This power would allow us to fully understand all that we have studied in recent years. With it, we could effortlessly page through Scripture and fully interpret all prophecy ever written. We would know, in crystal-clear detail, everything to come. That would be amazing!
Yet Paul concludes this enviable scenario by stating that even if he understood all prophecy in perfect detail “and have not charity, I am nothing” (vs. 2). Prophetic understanding at its highest level—with an ability to understand all mysteries and possess all knowledge—yet without the love of God—leaves us void.
God unequivocally gave us His perspective on prophecy. The spiritual gifts and abilities discussed in detail in the previous chapter, even in their greatest manifestations, are inferior to displaying the love of God.
Because Dave is filled with so much love, it i ok if hsi proepches fail, becasue ofthat love.
Paul expounds on charity in I Corinthians 13:4-8 by laying out its 16 traits, which then brings us back to the beginning: “Charity never fails: but whether there be prophecies, they shall fail; whether there be tongues, they shall cease; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away. For we know in part, and we prophesy in part” (vs. 8-9).
God is a Being whose thoughts and ways are vastly above our own (Isa. 55:8-9). He, for His own reasons, has decided to reveal prophetic truth at the speed and method of His choosing. It is almost certainly because the events are to soon occur. Also, the effort required to keep up over the last several years has changed you—probably more than you know. This process has sharpened your study skills and helped you build the stamina necessary to do more. Our responsibility as mature Christians is to supplement this prophetic diet with other aspects of Christian living.
Our pastor general, Mr. David Pack, who has written and preached more about the subjects of prophecy and Christian living than anyone, tied both together: “Ultimately…every sermon on Christian living has a prophecy element in it, because your goal is to be part of the Kingdom of God—and that’s all about and the centerpiece of prophecy.” He also stated, “So every time you work on yourself, every time you’re seeking to grow and become more like Jesus Christ…being ready to be a judge to help people all over the world…that’s the ultimate essence of prophecy.”
RCG member's salvation is tied up entirely by its use of the RCG web site. Their eternal life is at stake if they fail to sue the materials provided.
Supplementing our prophetic diet is easier than ever with all the tools available on our website and in our library of materials. Is it more work? Yes, it is. But what could be more rewarding? Eternal life is at stake.
We have long understood that prophecies “fail” (I Cor. 13:8), meaning these events will eventually come to pass and will never happen again. Prophecy has a shelf life. Love, however, never fails. Because God is love (I John 4:8), charity is therefore eternal. It, along with faith and hope, will always be relevant. 
Love.  The Restored Church of God is based upon it!   Tell that to the marriages and families split apart by Dave.
It is a privilege to understand prophesied events. To avoid being on the wrong side of them, however, we must not focus solely on the accumulation of this precious knowledge.
Remain patient and balanced in your approach to prophecy; grow in faith, hope and love. And—most importantly—“live the Book.” 
It is too bad RCG members are so preoccupied with prophecy when every single sermon given by Dave is supposedly filled with new prophetic truth. Just how many times now has Jesus been prophecied to return to Wardsworth and he is still no there. Unless he is shopping at the Giant Eagle and we just done know it yet.










20 comments:

Byker Bob said...

Well, the Mount of Olives has not yet been split, but if Jesus chooses to return in black skin as a test of their Christianity, I guarantee that all of these cretins will miss Him!

BB

Tonto said...

I will say it again... big claims require big proof.

Big proof , (or even small proof) is totally absent from Davey and the other false prophets.

Anonymous said...

You've had to "pour over your sermon notes" he says.

I recommend doing that with gasoline and a match.

Anonymous said...

Dave is another Joseph Goebbels.
Ed is Joseph Goebbels Jr.

Hoss said...

Well, except for Bob Thiel, Ron Weinland, and Gerald Flurry.

Actually I see Bob as the odd one out in this group. While Ron and Gerry have made false forecasts, Bob couches his predictions is such a way that he can't be caught out. I feel his real dilemma is his apparent need to be acknowledged as a prophet.

Recently I heard Noam Chomsky comment on the plethora of pronouncements from the current occupant of the White House - when you say so much, it is always possible that something will be correct. This reminded me of Bob's blunderbuss of predictions, it is always possible that something will hit the target and be correct - or at least "align" with correctness.

Anonymous said...


THE FALSE PROPHETS

The Really Bad People that Jesus warned would come and deceive many.

Satan's Favorites

Gerald R. Flurry: He started off as a drunken plagiarist to produce his Malachi's Mess. mess, which after a number of revisions he now claims was delivered by a mighty angel and is the “little scroll” mentioned in Revelation 10:1-11. Gerald Flurry immediately put an end to Jesus' “Great Commission” to preach the gospel (meaning GOOD NEWS) of the kingdom of God to the whole world for a witness to all nations and REPLACED IT with the BAD NEWS of a “new commission” from Satan to act like complete jerks towards all other former WCG people, thereby becoming the ultimate gospel perverter. Remember that there is a double curse associated with this sort of bad behavior. When no WCG minsters went with him, he set up some arrogant and malicious perverts as PCG ministers. For members he filled the PCG with too many old sex maniacs, sex perverts, and predators. He bought the copyrights to some of HWA's old writings, but then edited and changed them. Gerald Flurry soon claimed that he (instead of Jesus) was That Prophet of Deuteronomy 18:18-19 that everyone had to listen to or else God would be mad at them, thereby becoming the ultimate identity thief. A major purpose of the PCG is to try to destroy all normal family relationships and to promote sexual immorality. The diabolical trick of the PCG is to do all of Satan's evil in God's name.

David C. Pack: His August 31, 2013 prophetic guess totally failed even though he claimed to have 56 proofs for it, and it continued to fail whenever it was rescheduled for Springtime or the next Autumn. Now his prophetic yellings and spittings are getting really, really, REALLY crazy. All the regularly required tithes, offerings, and fundraisers were not enough for him, so David Pack “restored” his “COMMON” theft doctrine that everyone must send him virtually everything they own (cash, savings, retirement plans, possessions, houses, etc.) -- “or no salvation if you don't.” David Pack promoted himself to Apostle, Joshua the High Priest, Elijah the Prophet (in place of HWA, whom he posthumously promoted out of his way to the Office of Moses), That Prophet of Deuteronomy 18:18-19 (in place of Jesus), and now plans to become Messiah (in place of Jesus Christ). Truly, you cannot make this stuff up. But, sadly, Dave can and does make this stuff up. Being demon-possessed will do that to a person.

Dishonorable Mentions

Ronald E. Weinland: He claimed to be one of the Two Witnesses of Revelation 11:3-12 and that his wife is the second witness who will witness (that is, watch) him witnessing. He came up with short-term prophetic guesses that quickly failed. He seemed to just make up ridiculous things rather than waste his time watching the news on television to even try to guess right. He did 3.5 years in jail for the usual things that religious leaders do, because he was too stingy to share the ill-gotten gain with accountants and lawyers who routinely make such behaviour technically legal for all sorts of other false religious leaders.

Robert J. Thiel: A mentally challenged guy. He got someone to anoint him for an illness, and then claimed that the anointing had ordained him to be a prophet. Apparently, he got a “double portion” of some evil spirit. He thought that studying pagan prophecies of Mayans, Kenyans, and Catholics, looking to the Demons that inspired them, and watching FAKE NEWS on television, could help him to guess the future so he could pass himself off as a true prophet of God. Of course, it simply did not work. Things never did work that way.

Continued below...

Anonymous said...


...continued from above.

The Old Fool

Alton B. (Don) Billingsley: He tried to find some sort of duality between the history of ancient Israel and modern America. He said in a sermon that God had revealed to him that Hillary Clinton would win the 2016 presidential election. So, of course, Donald Trump won. Prediction Addiction can be a lifelong affliction. There is no fool like an old fool. One would think that if someone really had the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Truth, that they would eventually be able to overcome the bad habit of making up wrong prophetic guesses in God's name.

The Wannabe

James D. Malm: All the false prophets listed above deceitfully pretended to be HWA's loyal and faithful followers and successors. James Malm, on the other hand, openly rebelled against HWA and left the WCG in 1985 while HWA was still alive to try to “think for himself.” James Malm's wife got into sacred names nonsense and divorced him. He got into calendar confusion. James Malm thought that he could come up with a safe prophetic guess by predicting a regional war in the Middle East sometime in the coming years. Not very original.


Anonymous said...

Why should anyone show you the proof?

Anonymous said...

The one's Anon picked say more about Anon than Anon thinks.

Anonymous said...

What they all fail to acknowledge is that none of the things that these church leaders go on about are required for salvation according to the NT. There were only 4 things listed, nothing else. So if it's not required, why concern oneself with it? I find no need to worry about prophecy as I can't do anything about it and don't have the power to change it anyway. All the other nonsense, don't have the inclination to pay attention to any of it either. These members like remaining under the babysitter, they will never grow up and mature.

WHAT ABOUT THE TRUTH said...

Exactly the retreat I expected. Editor of publications Mr. Edward Winkfield kissing the hairy dirty ass of his boss could have been any minister with burning ears disease that resides in "god's kingdom" on earth.

The last few weeks and for that matter the last how many years surety of overtaking and claiming the promised land with the king in their hip pocket has once again failed and thus proving that God is fully capable of squashing men who create impossible to lose or guaranteed to happen scenarios.

In the biblical example of the exodus from sin and pursuit and establishment of the kingdom, the Israelite army of God was routed numerous times. God revealed each time that sin within was the reason.

Mr. Winkfield and his boss have subjectively casted the "pursuit of prophecy" into a Godly bait and switch scheme that in their opinion each portion and allotment (although a failure) builds one upon another.

The light of any problems according to Mr. Winfield isn't with his boss or God, it is with "puzzled" members unsatisfied with timing or the results, and "feeling incomplete" from a heightened "expectation of fulfillment". These members are "doomed to fail" according to Mr. Winkfield which means officially the leadership of the RCG believes their membership are failures. These failed members have been given an outpouring of prophetic understanding and Christian living messages that has given the membership "faith" from Mr. Pack so that there should be no excuse.

The pursuit of the promised land and kingdom that the RCG desires can't be accomplished with the golden calf front and center within the congregation. This hidden idol of the membership has the eyes of God upon them and not for good.

The routed membership and stuck in the wilderness of Wadsworth should be telling and none of which will be escaped with such sin in their presence.



Anonymous said...

When Dave Pack separated from GCG, one of his big talking points was that the GCG ministry (including Rod Meredith, but also Harold Smith, Raymond McNair, Norbert Link, etc.) wasn't teaching prophecy with sufficient precision. Had Pack applied his present standard to the leadership while he was in GCG, he would never have departed.

Unless of course prophecy has nothing to do with it, and it's all about who's in charge, and that once you're in charge you believe you can do anything you want and the peons must obey.

Anonymous said...


“Despite all the Church has learned in recent years, and even over decades, nagging questions remain.”


Yes, nagging questions such as, “Why are you guys ALWAYS wrong ALL the time?”

Anonymous said...


“The study of prophecy is an extremely rewarding pursuit yet one that can leave you feeling incomplete.”


Extremely rewarding indeed for the false prophets who come up with all the never-ending lies, but extremely costly for their followers who are left feeling incomplete and destitute after they have handed over all their money and the end still has not come.

Anonymous said...

prophecy with sufficient precision

Sounds similar to the reason Bob Thiel gave for leaving LCG.

RSK said...

Have yet to see him cite LCG.

Byker Bob said...

If a leader is insistent regarding his interpretation of prophecy, particularly when he has been proven numerous times to be dead wrong, then he is going to be giving very foolish counsel to those choosing to follow him. The worst thing a member could do under the circumstances would be to continue to suffer the cumulative damages resulting from the foolish counsel while waiting for and expecting him to eventually be right. That's like trusting a player with a negative batting average (I know! statistically impossible, but go with me on this!) to hit a grand slam game saving home run final inning of the World Series.

BB

Anonymous said...

A lot of cults are the result of CIA experiments, according to author Daniel Estulin who wrote about the Tavistock Institute. Some others were started by the Masons. Where do COGs fit in? Part of the dumbing-down process I gather.

As Winston Churchill said, some powerful forces want to reconstitute the world on the basis of arrested development. That's why we have the "no child left behind" nonsense as well as the overblown lock-down nonsense. The whole goals is to "collapse the system" as the lefties always say, so they can say "capitalism" failed and we need a hard-left soviet style system of "equality". Massive debt is a policy they have used for centuries to overthrown governments.


Anonymous said...

Why do you assume it's a male?

the Ocelot said...

Remember Sacred Namers :
Jesus Christ is Lord The Son of God Worship him and hear his Gospel message at your Christian Church today