Armstrongism's Gospel of War:
When the Destruction of Humanity Becomes Good News
A reader here wrote in a comment:
They have what is called the "Gospel of War" and not the "Gospel of Peace." It's the good news of wars and rumors of wars.
For decades, Armstrongism has cultivated an unhealthy fascination with the destruction of the United States, Great Britain, and the other nations it claims are descended from the ancient Israelites. Its prophetic imagination is dominated by national catastrophe, military invasions, economic collapse, mass death, captivity, and the eventual humiliation of entire populations. Apparently, the good news of the Kingdom of God requires a rather spectacular amount of bad news for everyone else first. In Armstrongist theology, the destruction of nations is not simply something to be lamented or something humanity should desperately seek to avoid. It is practically the main attraction.
There is something deeply disturbing about a religious movement that spends so much of its time anticipating the deaths of millions of people and treating those deaths as confirmation that its leaders understood biblical prophecy all along. Armstrongist publications and sermons have repeatedly returned to the familiar scenario: two-thirds of the population perishes, survivors are taken captive, young people are transported to Europe as slaves, and the remaining population is subjected to unimaginable suffering. The United States and Britain are supposedly headed for an appointment with national annihilation, and Armstrongism has been selling tickets to the spectacle for generations.
One almost wonders whether its adherents will be disappointed if these things never happen. After all, what becomes of decades of prophetic speculation, endless warnings, and carefully cultivated anticipation if the predicted catastrophe never arrives? What happens to the endless parade of self-appointed prophetic authorities when the nations they have condemned continue to exist? Apparently, the greatest threat to Armstrongist theology is not the destruction of America, but the possibility that America might survive its predictions.
The Gospel of War Instead of the Gospel of Peace
The apostle Paul described the Christian message as the Gospel of Peace. Armstrongism, however, seems to have developed an entirely different version. We might appropriately call it the Gospel of War. Its good news consists of wars and rumors of wars, military invasions, national humiliation, mass casualties, captivity, and the destruction of societies. It is a strange sort of good news that requires millions of people to suffer before the faithful can finally celebrate that their prophetic teachers were right.
Jesus certainly spoke about wars and rumors of wars. In Matthew 24, he warned his disciples about the turmoil that would characterize the world. But notice something Armstrongist teachers conveniently overlook: Jesus specifically instructed his followers not to be alarmed by these events. He also warned against being deceived by those who claimed special prophetic knowledge. The passage was not an invitation to develop an elaborate obsession with international catastrophes or to turn every military conflict into another opportunity to announce that the end was finally approaching.
In fact, Jesus' message was remarkably different from the nationalistic doom-and-gloom theology Armstrongism has promoted. When Jesus spoke about the Kingdom of God, he spoke about reconciliation, mercy, forgiveness, love of neighbor, and the transformation of human relationships. He instructed his followers to love their enemies, pray for those who persecuted them, and become peacemakers. Apparently, these teachings are considerably less exciting to people who would rather spend their evenings studying prophetic charts about the coming destruction of the United States.
The New Covenant Has a Very Different Message
The New Covenant fundamentally changes the way Christians understand God's relationship with humanity. The old nationalistic framework, with its emphasis on physical Israel, national blessings, national curses, and military conquest, is not the defining framework of the Christian faith. Through Christ, God's promises are extended beyond national boundaries. The Kingdom of God is not an Anglo-American inheritance, and the Gospel is not a warning that the descendants of particular European populations are about to receive their punishment.
Paul makes this abundantly clear in Galatians 3:28-29, where he explains that distinctions between Jew and Greek no longer determine one's standing in Christ. Those who belong to Christ are Abraham's offspring and heirs according to the promise. That is a rather inconvenient passage for a movement that has spent generations dividing humanity into prophetic national categories and insisting that the Anglo-Saxon peoples occupy a uniquely privileged place in biblical prophecy.
The New Covenant does not invite Christians to sit around hoping that their neighbors, fellow citizens, or entire populations will experience the fulfillment of terrible national calamities. It calls them to something considerably more demanding: love, compassion, service, forgiveness, and reconciliation. Romans 12:18 instructs Christians, as far as it depends on them, to live peaceably with everyone. Romans 12:21 tells them not to be overcome by evil but to overcome evil with good.
There is no footnote explaining that these instructions can be temporarily suspended because someone has discovered another prophetic timetable predicting the collapse of America.
Jesus Was Not Selling a National Catastrophe
Consider the contrast between Jesus' teachings and the recurring Armstrongist fascination with national destruction. When Jesus encountered suffering, he responded with compassion. He healed the sick, fed the hungry, welcomed the marginalized, forgave sinners, and challenged religious authorities who burdened people with oppressive demands. He did not establish a ministry devoted to predicting the eventual enslavement of entire populations while assuring his followers that these tragedies would demonstrate the accuracy of his prophetic interpretations.
In Luke 19:41-44, Jesus wept over Jerusalem. He lamented the suffering and destruction that would come upon the city. He did not celebrate the catastrophe as a wonderful opportunity to demonstrate that he had correctly identified the geopolitical future. He grieved over people who would suffer.
That is a rather important distinction. Jesus could speak prophetically about judgment while simultaneously expressing profound sorrow over human suffering. Armstrongist prophetic culture, by contrast, has too often transformed judgment into a source of excitement, superiority, and theological self-congratulation.
The difference between those attitudes ought to be obvious to anyone who has actually read the Gospels.
A Religion That Needs Everyone Else to Suffer
One of the most troubling characteristics of Armstrongism is the psychological atmosphere created by its constant emphasis on impending catastrophe. Generations of members have been taught to view world events through a framework of impending national punishment. Economic difficulties, political disagreements, military conflicts, and international tensions become evidence that the prophetic machinery is finally beginning to turn. Every crisis is another opportunity to announce that the end is near.
Rather than encouraging Christians to work toward a better world, this theology encourages people to anticipate the collapse of the existing one. Rather than cultivating concern for the suffering of humanity, it risks turning that suffering into a prophetic scoreboard. The worse things become, the more convinced some followers become that their religious system must be correct.
What kind of spiritual outlook is that? Imagine telling someone whose family is suffering from war, economic hardship, or political oppression that their misery is actually wonderful news because it confirms your favorite religious interpretation. Yet this is the logical destination of a theology that repeatedly treats human catastrophe as evidence of prophetic success.
There is also a profound contradiction here. Armstrongist leaders frequently insist that their followers should demonstrate love, kindness, and obedience to God. Yet the larger prophetic narrative they promote often revolves around the anticipated destruction of people who do not belong to their religious system. The world outside their movement is apparently destined for disaster, while the faithful are encouraged to congratulate themselves for having discovered the correct escape route.
That is not the Gospel of Christ. It is religious tribalism dressed up in prophetic language.
The Gospel of Peace Is Actually Good News
The New Testament offers something much better than an endless parade of national disasters. Ephesians 2:14 declares that Christ himself is our peace, breaking down the dividing wall of hostility. This is the heart of the New Covenant message: reconciliation between humanity and God, and reconciliation between people who were previously separated by hostility and division.
Second Corinthians 5:18-19 describes the ministry of reconciliation entrusted to believers. Christians are called to participate in that ministry, not to spend their lives eagerly anticipating the destruction of nations and the enslavement of their populations.
James 3:17 describes wisdom from above as pure, peaceable, gentle, willing to yield, full of mercy and good fruits. James 3:18 adds that the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace. These are not incidental decorations attached to the Christian message. They are central characteristics of the life shaped by Christ.
And what about the Beatitudes? Jesus specifically declared, "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God" (Matthew 5:9). He did not say blessed are those who correctly predict the destruction of America, blessed are those who identify the coming European slave camps, or blessed are those who can produce the most frightening interpretation of the latest international crisis.
He said peacemakers.
Time to Abandon the Prophetic Bloodsport
Armstrongism needs to take a serious look at the Gospel it claims to proclaim. A movement that spends generation after generation anticipating the deaths of millions, the destruction of nations, and the enslavement of innocent populations has wandered a considerable distance from the central message of Jesus Christ.
The Christian faith is not about waiting for the world to burn so that religious leaders can declare victory. It is not about finding satisfaction in the suffering of people who disagree with one's theology. It is not about nationalistic fantasies, prophetic scorekeeping, or the endless recycling of failed predictions about the imminent destruction of the Anglo-American nations.
The Gospel is good news because God has acted in Christ to reconcile humanity to himself. It is good news because forgiveness is offered, enemies can become neighbors, the excluded can be welcomed, and people can be transformed by love. It is good news because Christ calls his followers to become agents of reconciliation in a world desperately in need of peace.
Armstrongism's Gospel of War turns the suffering of humanity into a theological spectator sport. The New Covenant calls Christians to relieve suffering, feed the hungry, care for the vulnerable, love their enemies, and make peace.
Perhaps it is time for Armstrongist prophets to put away their national destruction charts, stop polishing their predictions of mass death, and actually spend some time reading the teachings of Jesus.
After all, the last time I checked, the Christian message was supposed to be the Gospel of Peace, not the Gospel of War, Rumors of War, National Slavery, and the Spectacular Demise of the United States.
Jesus came preaching good news. Armstrongism seems to be waiting for the bad news to get here.

No comments:
Post a Comment