The Dead Stick Theology of Samuel Kitchen
When Church Loyalty Becomes a Substitute for the Gospel
Samuel Kitchen has once again demonstrated how Armstrongism can take perfectly understandable biblical teachings, twist them into organizational propaganda, and somehow arrive at the conclusion that Jesus Christ belongs exclusively to the Worldwide Church of God. Apparently, Christ being the Head of His Church wasn't quite sufficient. We now need Samuel to explain that Christ is actually the Head of one particular twentieth-century religious organization, and every other Christian fellowship is operating under unauthorized management.
His latest theological production is quite a spectacle. He begins with Galatians 5, introduces Satan and his hyenas, describes departing members as spiritual corpses, brings in unleavened bread, resurrects a dead tree, attacks Christmas trees, and finally threatens everyone with the lake of fire. All of this to establish that the Worldwide Church of God remains God's exclusive spiritual address. One almost expects a membership application at the end.
The Sinless Christ and the Supposedly Sinless Organization
Samuel begins by declaring that the Church of God must be unspotted and without blemish. There is no argument with the biblical principle that Christ calls His people to holiness. But then comes the extraordinary leap: because Christ is sinless, Christ cannot be the Head of any organization other than the Worldwide Church of God. Where exactly does Scripture establish that conclusion?
Christ's sinlessness is a statement about Christ, not a certificate of institutional perfection issued to Herbert W. Armstrong's former organization. The New Testament consistently distinguishes between Christ's perfection and the ongoing spiritual growth, failures, correction, and restoration of believers. The Corinthian congregation had serious problems involving division, immorality, jealousy, and spiritual arrogance, yet Paul continued to recognize them as the Church of God. Imagine that! A congregation with problems that still belonged to God. Apparently Paul hadn't received Samuel's memo about organizational exclusivity.
Galatians 5 Is Not a License to Condemn Everyone Who Leaves Your Organization
Samuel repeatedly invokes Galatians 5 and asks why people tolerate biting and devouring one another. The irony is that Paul's instruction is about walking in the Spirit, loving one's neighbor, and avoiding conceit, provocation, and envy. His concern is destructive behavior, not the mere existence of multiple Christian fellowships.
But Samuel has a different interpretation. Anyone leaving the Worldwide Church of God and establishing another fellowship has supposedly surrendered to the flesh, abandoned Christ, and joined Satan's demolition crew. Paul never said that leaving a particular religious organization constituted abandoning Christ, nor did he declare that establishing another congregation was an act of rebellion. Those are Samuel's additions, not Paul's teachings.
The Worldwide Church of God Gets a Special Exemption
Here comes the most revealing part of the article. Samuel acknowledges that the Worldwide Church of God had sin, but apparently that was acceptable because its members were merely overcoming and the Church was supposedly being deleavened. Yet when other congregations experience the same imperfections, those failures become evidence that their entire organizations are spiritually corrupt and destined for destruction.
Notice the double standard? The Worldwide Church of God gets an exemption; everyone else gets condemned. Every failing inside Samuel's preferred institution becomes a temporary difficulty in the overcoming process, while every failing outside it becomes evidence of Satan's influence. This is not biblical discernment. It is institutional favoritism dressed up as theology.
The history of the Worldwide Church of God after Herbert Armstrong's death hardly demonstrates uninterrupted spiritual perfection. It experienced serious doctrinal disputes, leadership conflicts, and organizational upheaval. But Samuel's explanation requires us to believe that the original organization remained God's legitimate spiritual home while everyone who departed became part of a spiritually defective counterfeit. The organization gets to be right by definition, regardless of what happens inside it. Convenient, isn't it?
The Great Dead Tree Revelation
Then Samuel introduces his botanical masterpiece. According to him, the splinter churches took the fundamentals, chopped down the original tree, attached the dead trunk to a stand, decorated it with pleasing things, and pretended they had something alive. He compares these churches to Christmas trees. One has to admire the imagination, even if the theology has wandered considerably from the biblical text.
Apparently, the Worldwide Church of God is the original living tree, while every other Armstrongist fellowship is merely a decorated dead stick. The problem is that Samuel never establishes why the original organization should be identified with the biblical Tree of Life. The Tree of Life is not a corporate trademark belonging to Herbert Armstrong. Christ Himself is the source of life.
Jesus said, "I am the vine, ye are the branches" (John 15:5). Notice that He did not say Herbert Armstrong was the trunk and that all legitimate branches must remain attached to the Worldwide Church of God. Samuel has confused preserving an organization with preserving spiritual life. A church can retain its name, doctrines, publications, and institutional history while failing to demonstrate the love, mercy, humility, and grace Christ requires. Putting a religious sign on a building does not make it God's dwelling place.
The New Covenant Problem Samuel Cannot Escape
Here is where Armstrongism continually runs into trouble. The New Covenant is centered upon Jesus Christ, His sacrifice, His resurrection, and the transforming work of the Holy Spirit. Believers are reconciled to God through Christ, not through membership in an organization claiming exclusive ownership of biblical truth.
Paul describes believers as members of Christ's body (1 Corinthians 12), with different functions but one Head. He does not establish a twentieth-century denominational headquarters as the exclusive channel through which Christ can function. The New Testament also describes believers as God's temple (1 Corinthians 3:16-17) and living stones being built into a spiritual house (1 Peter 2:5). Living stones, Samuel, not dead organizational sticks propped up on a Christmas tree stand!
The fundamental problem is that Samuel has placed organizational lineage where Christ should be. Instead of directing people toward the sufficiency of Christ, he directs them back toward the preservation of an institution established under Herbert Armstrong. That is not the New Covenant. It is institutional nostalgia masquerading as biblical Christianity.
The Lake of Fire: The Final Armstrongist Threat
As if the argument weren't sufficiently exaggerated, Samuel finishes by declaring that these other churches are preparing people for the lake of fire. There it is again: the familiar Armstrongist technique of turning disagreement with the organization into a matter of eternal destruction. Rather than demonstrate from Scripture that Christ has abandoned everyone outside the Worldwide Church of God, Samuel simply announces the verdict. Apparently, he has already been appointed to the heavenly admissions committee.
But where is the New Testament authority for this extraordinary claim? Jesus warned against false teachers, hypocrisy, lovelessness, and religious self-righteousness. He called people to repentance, faith, mercy, and love. He never instructed His followers to identify one twentieth-century organization as the exclusive route to salvation. Paul even warned against boasting in human leaders and placing confidence in them (1 Corinthians 1:12-13). Perhaps Samuel should spend some time considering that passage before condemning everyone who doesn't share his organizational allegiance.
Christ Does Not Need Herbert Armstrong's Organizational Tree
The fundamental problem with Samuel's article is that he has substituted organizational loyalty for biblical Christianity. He condemns others for biting and devouring one another while declaring everyone outside his preferred organization spiritually defective. He warns against religious corruption while elevating an institution to a position of exclusivity that Scripture never gives it. He speaks of the Tree of Life while directing everyone back toward a corporate organization established by Herbert Armstrong.
The contradiction is glaring. Samuel claims to defend Christ's Church, yet his argument makes institutional identity the defining characteristic of that Church. The New Testament does nothing of the sort. Christ is the foundation, the Savior, and the Head. The Church belongs to Him, not to Herbert Armstrong, his successors, or anyone who believes that preserving an organizational lineage grants them exclusive spiritual authority.
The real test of Christianity is not whether someone remained loyal to the Worldwide Church of God, joined a splinter organization, or adopted a particular minister's interpretation of Armstrongist fundamentals. It is whether that person is following Christ, living by the Spirit, demonstrating love, and placing faith in the One who actually gave His life for them.
Perhaps Samuel should spend a little less time examining everyone else's supposed dead trees and a little more time examining the theological forest he has constructed around Herbert Armstrong. The New Covenant does not require believers to return to a twentieth-century organization to find life. It calls them to Christ, who is life.
And that is the great irony of Armstrongism: it repeatedly claims to restore Christ's authority while making loyalty to Herbert Armstrong's institutional legacy the practical test of Christian legitimacy. It preaches Christ as Head, but then insists that everyone must first recognize its particular organization as the exclusive body over which He supposedly presides.
Christ is sufficient. Herbert Armstrong was not. The Worldwide Church of God was not, and neither are its numerous successors. The Church belongs to Christ, and no self-appointed organizational guardian gets to put a padlock on the Kingdom of God and declare everyone else trespassers.

No comments:
Post a Comment