Crackpot Bob has once again favored us with a linguistic demonstration that the Holy Spirit is, in fact, not a person. In the May-June 2025 Sabbath Sentinel he carefully notes that the Koine Greek word pneuma is neuter, that some English translations sneak in the masculine "he" and "who," and that therefore the whole idea of a personal Holy Spirit is a pagan Trinity trick. Grammar, we are told, has spoken: it is an "it."
This is not new theology. It is simply the latest polishing of a doctrine Herbert W. Armstrong pounded for decades. In Mystery of the Ages and assorted Plain Truth and Good News pieces, Armstrong declared with absolute certainty that originally there were only two divine Personages. The Trinity, he insisted, "is nowhere found in the Bible" and was "formulated by men under the influence of Satan." Why the vehemence? Because a closed Godhead of three would ruin the sales pitch. Armstrong's gospel required an open "God Family" into which the faithful could eventually be born as additional Gods. A third Person would slam that door shut. Hence the Holy Spirit had to be demoted to "the agency by which God the Father works... an agency, a force, a power." Armstrong was explicit: "The Holy Spirit, we repeat, is not a person."
Crackpot Bob's article is the same project with more footnotes. He cites Daniel Wallace's careful grammatical work, notes that pneuma is neuter, and treats the personal pronouns in John 14-16 as unfortunate translation bias. Wallace himself, of course, is a Trinitarian who never claimed that neuter gender proves the Spirit is impersonal; he simply observed that the grammar does not force personhood. But never mind. The useful bit is the neuter, so the useful bit is kept. The rest of the New Testament's language-where the Spirit speaks, grieves, intercedes, forbids, sends, and can be lied to-is explained away as personification or grammatical necessity. It is a force that just happens to talk, feel, and act with purpose. Convenient.
The practical problem is that Armstrongism still needs the Spirit to do personal work. Conversion, begetting, guidance, and the "gift" that comes after baptism all require it. So the groups that descended from Armstrong-including Crackpot Bob's improperly named "continuing" Church of God-continue to baptize people with a formula that sounds suspiciously Trinitarian. They say something like "into the name of the Father and the Son and through the Holy Spirit," then lay hands on the candidate and ask for the gift of that same Spirit. They will not call the Spirit a person, yet they cannot perform the rite without invoking it alongside the Father and the Son. Consistency, as the old saying goes, is optional when the alternative is looking too much like the pagans you have spent fifty years denouncing.
The entire exercise is driven by the same two-Person architecture Armstrong locked in. John 1:1 is read as revealing only the Father and the Word. Everything else must be forced to fit. The Spirit that conceived Jesus cannot be personal, or it would have been his Father. The Spirit that can be "poured out" or "stirred up" cannot be personal, because persons are not poured. And the Spirit that is grammatically neuter is therefore ontologically an "it." All of this keeps the God Family open for new members while still allowing the leadership to claim they are simply following the Bible and the original Armstrong revelation.
Crackpot Bob's grammatical scissors are sharp enough for the magazine article. They just do not cut the deeper inconsistency. Armstrongism continues to need the Holy Spirit's power, presence, and activity for its members to be considered real Christians, while simultaneously insisting that the Spirit is not a person at all-lest the Family of two stop being expandable. The neuter gender is real. The personal actions of the Spirit are also real. The baptismal formula is still spoken. And the God Family sales pitch remains the point of the whole exercise.

39 comments:
There's one big problem, one big logical flaw, in the argument the ACOGs make about the Holy Spirit. If you read the Old Testament descriptions of Wisdom, and apply to Wisdom the same standard of grammar and logic that the ACOGs apply to the Holy Spirit, it must either be a personal feminine counterpart of the Father and the Son, or it must be a power of God like the Holy Spirit, but a feminine power rather than a neuter one.
Without Banned, it’s highly probable that no one would have ever heard about Bobby boy. Quick look at his videos, which play on a number of YT sites, and the views are SMALL. Bob’s probably jealous of the hits on Banned. Really dwarves his viewing audience. Most fine posts on Banned. And Bobs nowhere to be seen…………
1. armstrong was a liar, con man, and child rapist ... even before the epstein days
2. the god family idea is biblical because jesus was the son and he had a father
3. the trinity is a castrated god from the olden days, hence the gender neutrality.
Bob should pay more attention cleaning up his recent Malawi Feast Fiasco were he really was taken like a big Sucka giving Feast money to Radson Mulowzoa without showing no more than 10 people. We hear through the grapevine Bobs putting pressure on Radson about confirming the supposed
proof of thousands 🤣. When will Bob learn. Well like we say Stupid is as Stupid does.. Those Witchdoctors need more kwachies to produce Bobs vision of 10,000 members
Why have you designed your Ai cartoon of Bob and Herbert in a baptismal tank with a small child looking under duress ?
The error Armstrongites make is when they argue that God simply uses His power as an instrument of communication - the huge problem is that this is not how the New Testament describes the Spirit.
It does not say that God's power speaks; it says that the Spirit speaks. It does not say that God's power intercedes; it says that the Spirit intercedes. It does not say that God's power can be grieved or lied to; it says that the Spirit can be grieved and lied to. The cumulative picture is not of an impersonal force being personified on isolated occasions, but of a personal agent who thinks, speaks, wills, guides, and acts.
It’s amazing how the mind of Armstrongites immediately go to the something sexual.
But never mind. The useful bit is the neuter, so the useful bit is kept>>>
this is how these people operate - the careful selection of words while ignoring others. I've seen JW articles doing this too they are as much masters of the art of selection and bending things every which way as are Thiel and other Armstrong groups
Well, you know.....Bob is right on this one.
But you shall receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you...........Acts 1:8 NKJV
At the risk of getting political, does this show James Talarico is right?
God has no gender. So God is non-binary - identifying as a He throughout Scripture.
Beyond that, Satan (as a fallen angel) has no gender. Yet COG's call "Satan" a "He" without giving it second thought.
Nothing sexual in 12:45 comment 606.
Thank God for heretics who show how mixed up the orthodox crazies are.
To be spiritually correct, the New Testament goes grammatically incorrect.
The New Testament uses masculine pronouns in reference to the Holy Spirit, even though the Greek noun for Spirit (pneuma, πνεῦμα) is grammatically
This was done to demonstrate that the Holy Spirit is a person.
1. John 16:13 - Jesus says:
"When he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth."
The Greek text uses:
- τὸ πνεῦμα (to pneuma) — the Spirit (neuter).
- ἐκεῖνος (ekeinos) — he/that one (masculine).
- ὁδηγήσει (hodēgēsei) — he will guide.
The masculine pronoun ekeinos is used in reference to the Spirit of Truth.
2. John 15:26
Jesus says that the Helper will come:
Greek:
- ὁ παράκλητος (ho paraklētos) — the Helper/Advocate (masculine).
- ὃν (hon) — whom (masculine).
Here, the masculine pronouns agree grammatically with paraklētos, which is itself a masculine noun.
3. John 14:26
The passage reads:
"But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things..."
The Greek uses:
- τὸ πνεῦμα τὸ ἅγιον — the Holy Spirit (neuter).
- ἐκεῖνος (ekeinos) — he/that one (masculine).
Again, a masculine pronoun is used in reference to the Holy Spirit.
The use of masculine personal pronouns, together with descriptions of the Spirit teaching, guiding, speaking, grieving, and testifying, is consistent with the Holy Spirit being a distinct person.
Trooisto writes:
“The use of masculine personal pronouns, together with descriptions of the Spirit teaching, guiding, speaking, grieving, and testifying, is consistent with the Holy Spirit being a distinct person.”
“This was done to demonstrate that the Holy Spirit is a person.”
Pr 1:20 Wisdom calls aloud in the street, she raises her voice in the public squares;
Pr 8:34 Blessed is the man who listens to me, watching daily at my doors, waiting at my doorway.
Not necessarily if “the Spirit” is personified.
Ac 16:6 Paul and his companions traveled throughout the region of Phrygia and Galatia, HAVING BEEN KEPT BY THE HOLY SPIRIT from preaching the word in the province of Asia.
Ac 16:7 When they came to the border of Mysia, they tried to enter Bithynia, but THE SPIRIT OF JESUS WOULD NOT ALLOW THEM TO. (NIV - which uses older manuscripts).
The Holy Spirit and the Spirit of Jesus perform the same function, hence identifying the two - the Holy Spirit is Jesus’ spirit personified. “This is a mark of Luke’s high Christology (cf. also Rom 8:9; probably 1 Pet 1:11)” (Craig S. Keener, Acts 15:1-23:35, An Exegetical Commentary, p. 2332).
Ro 8:9a But ye are not in the flesh, but in the SPIRIT,
Rom 8:9c ... if any man have not the SPIRIT OF CHRIST, he is none of his.
Rom 8:10a And if CHRIST be in you...
Rom 8:9b if so be that the SPIRIT OF GOD dwell in you
Rom 8:10a And if CHRIST be in you
“There is a close relationship between the Spirit of Christ and the Holy Spirit... In Romans 8:9-10 the Spirit, the Spirit of God, the Spirit of Christ, and Christ all seem to be used interchangeably” (NIVSB, Kenneth Barker, Gen Editor, p.1766, note on 2 Corinthians 3:17).
The spirit of God is not God’s spirit, per se, but Christ’s spirit as Christ’s spirit is/comes from God.
Gal 4:6 And because ye are sons, GOD HATH SENT FORTH THE SPIRIT OF HIS SON INTO YOUR HEARTS, crying, Abba, Father.
Eph 3:14 For this cause I bow my knees unto the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ,
Eph 3:16 That he would grant you, according to the riches of his glory, to be strengthened with might by HIS SPIRIT in the inner man;
Eph 3:17 That Christ may dwell in your hearts by faith; that ye, being rooted and grounded in love,
“Thus Paul prays to the Father that Christ by his Spirit will be allowed to settle down in their hearts, and from his throne there both control and strengthen them...” (John R. W. Stott, The Message of Ephesians, BST, p.136).
1Pe 1:11 trying to find out the time and circumstances to which the Spirit of Christ in them was pointing when he predicted the sufferings of Christ and the glories that would follow.
1Pe 1:12 It was revealed to them that they were not serving themselves but you, when they spoke of the things that have now been told you by those who have preached the gospel to you by the Holy Spirit sent from heaven. Even angels long to look into these things. (NIV).
“Clearly for the writer of 1 Peter the Holy Spirit who inspired prophecy could not be other than the Spirit of Christ... ” (David L. Bartlett, The First Letter of Peter, NIB, Vol. 12, p. 253).
“Of course one must be on guard not to read into Paul the later theology of the church. The doctrine of the Trinity, which found expression in the councils of Nicaea (A.D. 325) and Constantinople(A.D. 381) and its influential exposition in the West by Augustine in the late fourth and early fifth centuries, is an effort to understand WITH THE AID OF HELLENISTIC PHILOSOPHY the true diversity and undivided unity of Father, Son and Spirit... This way of putting the issue would have been strange to Paul as it is to most modern readers. He does, however, assert a united event of redemption in which Father, Son and Spirit play diverse roles. In a single move to liberate an enslaved people God has acted through Jesus his Son and in the Spirit of Jesus” (Charles B. Cousar, Galatians, Int, p. 97).
Shabbat Shalom
If the holy spirit is a person, Christ's long prayer in the book of John.would have mentioned him much more frequently. The holy spirit is directed by a "male" God the father and Christ, so in a sense it's male. Bob's not wrong about everything. God is made up of two God beings, not three.
Does anyone seriously prayer to the holy spirit?
Good point 5:17.
Fantastic comment highlighting key scripture. The trinity arguments go nowhere in 2026.
Your graphic is inaccurate in one aspect. Baptisms in the church are performed "in the name of Jesus Christ" - not citing Father/Son/Spirit.
Of course, that wording is controversial in Christianity as a whole.
I really don't understand all the parsing. Three elements of God are spoken of throughout the New Testament. Why do people feel as if they have to spell out things they really don't understand? I've always found it very telling that the authoritarian church government exercised in Armstrongism is a denial of the fruits of, and power of the Holy Spirit. They try to replace Him in the lives of their members. We see this in Doug Winnail's weekly rants, in Cal Culpepper's bullying, in activities of the ministry such as making members' marital choices for them, and in the deceitful manipulation they call prophecy. I used to say that the teachers of Armstrongism only understand 2/3 of God. I've since learned that they're not too keen on Jesus, either!
COG do not baptise small children, that was my point, "Anon" 6:06. If you think that question was "sexual" then that is only you thinking that.
Feastgoer is correct,
E.W. Bullinger, in his Word Studies on the HOLY SPIRIT, pp.47, 48, states: “The difficulty is that the Apostles themselves never obeyed this command (to baptize in the triune name); and in the rest of the New Testament there is no hint as to it ever having been obeyed by anyone. Baptism was always in the name of the one person of the Lord Jesus.”
Let’s examine the Scriptures to prove all things.
Acts 2:38 “Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.”
[Baptism is to be performed in His name for the remission of sins because “…he had by himself purged our sins…” (Hebrews 1:3)].
Acts 8:16 “For as yet he [it] was fallen upon none of them: only they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus.”
Acts 10:48 “And he commanded them to be baptized in the name of the Lord.”
Acts 19:5 “When they heard this, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus.”
Acts 22:16 “… arise, and be baptized, and wash away thy sins, calling on the name of the Lord.”
1Cor 6:11 “And such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God.”
Rom 6:3 “Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death?”
Gal 3:27 “For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ.”
NOTE: In Matt 28:19, the word translated “in” in the phrase “in the name of…” is the Greek word “eis” which means “into.” The above two scriptures show what we are truly to be baptized into – not the name of the Father, Son, and holy spirit – but, into Christ and His death. “This was the formula of the followers of Eunomius (Socr.5.24) – ‘for they baptise not into the trinity, but into the death of Christ’.” (Encyclopedia Biblica, article: Baptism).
John 14:26 “But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, which the Father will send in my name…”
[Note: How does one receive the holy spirit? In the name of Jesus!]
Luke 24:47 “And that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his [Jesus’s] name among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem.”
[Note: This verse ties directly with Matt 28:19 (preaching the Gospel among all nations) and Acts 2:38 (repentance and remission of sins, which comes in the name of Jesus Christ), and as we see here, both are to be done in the name of Jesus Christ – not in the name of a “triune god.”]
Scripture states clearly that baptism was never performed “in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the holy ghost,” but rather, in the name of Jesus Christ alone.
Bullinger comments, “It is difficult to suppose that there would have been this universal disregard of so clear a command, if it had ever been given; or [if] it ever really formed part of the primitive text.”
“As to the Greek MSS.(manuscripts), there are none beyond the fourth Century [Of the fourth century, there are two: the Vaticanus and the Sinaiticus – BOTH CORRUPT. All other known Greek MSS. are from 5th Century and upward], and it seems clear that the Syrian part of the Church knew nothing of these words.” (Word Studies on the HOLY SPIRIT, p.48)
Which church is that Feastgoer?
God is so much higher above humans, it’s difficult for us to comprehend him.
Furthermore, one can only understand what the Holy Spirit allows one to understand.
With Armstrongism, given their decades of documented uneasiness, unfamiliarity, and general lack of interest in the attributes of Jesus, it stands to reason that Armstrongism also has difficulty understanding the Holy Spirit.
In a comment above, the Spirit of Christ is mentioned. The Spirit of Christ is the Holy Spirit, as Jesus is God, and the Holy Spirit is God. The Holy Trinity is an attempt to contemplate the nature of God – something we cannot fully do at this time. The good news though is that we will spend eternity learning about, knowing God.
Armstrongites, like Muslims, like to point out that the word Trinity is not in the Bible. This is true, but neither is the phrase God Family, in the sense used by Armstrongites. In an attempt to relate the concept of the Trinity in Armstrongism-speak, perhaps one might attempt to compare the Trinity concept to Armstrongism’s God Family. However, the famous Shema Yisrael rescues from that mistake.
The Shema is the central declaration of Jewish faith, affirming that God is one, from Deuteronomy 6:4 "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one."
I think Armstrongites believe that Jesus is the divine Son of God … yet Jesus is not God, as the two are separate beings. I don’t know how Armstrongites square the divine nature of Jesus with Deuteronomy 6:4. I don’t think it can be done and I am not aware of Armstrongism trying to do this, or caring about it.
The Trinity explains the nature of God with three persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The three are too distinct to be one, yet too one (unified) to be three. The Holy Trinity, as one God, does jibe with the Shema.
More than ten years ago, an LCG associate of mine was gushing about how much Rod Merridith was now speaking about Jesus. My comment to him was that if one was contemplating following Jesus, one should cautiously deal with a “minister” who after several decades in the ministry was just beginning to get a bit cozier with Jesus. In recent years, this LCG associate remains unphased when I mention biblical concepts, related to Jesus, that Armstrongism fails to address, such as justification and redemption. The associate has vaguely acknowledged that LCG’s official definition of justification is lacking; however, he does not care to delve into a more biblically accurate definition.
Another comment above (Oct 30; 5:17) said that if the Holy Spirit is a person, Jesus’ long prayer in the book of John would have mentioned the Holy Spirit more frequently. That is a vivid depiction of the depth of Armstrongism reasoning and doctrine.
A commentor above (Oct 30; 2:38) cautioned not to read into the writings of Paul the later doctrines of the Church. That would be impossible to do. Romans 8 s a paramount sermon on the ministry of the Holy Spirit; it also covers justification and is part of the Church’s doctrine of the Holy Trinity. I return that comment with a request not to read St. Paul with the blinders of Armstrongism.
I acknowledge that one who has accepted Armstrongism, cannot see beyond it. However, if an Armstrongite cares to know God, he could at least read Romans 8, and put his finger on each word that appears in the text, and then when he comes to a word or phrase that is not fully addressed by Armstongism, he could write that word or phrase in his notes … and then do a fully study of what Armstrongism does not care to discuss. When he writes the word justification, hopefully he realizes this is a hugely important topic to fully understand. I hope such evaluation of one’s beliefs would be guided by the Holy Spirit.
I’ll close with one of my favorite benedictions, and sincere desire for all Armstrongites, from 2 Corinthians 13:14:
May the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all.
The New Testament speaks of the Spirit of God, the Spirit of the Father (Matt. 10:20), and the Spirit of Christ.
Yet few conclude that the Father and the Son are the same person simply because both possess or send the same Spirit. The commentary appears to move from “Spirit of Christ” to identity of person, but that is precisely the point under debate.
The fact that prayer is ordinarily directed to the Father does not, by itself, settle the question of personhood. The more relevant question is how Scripture describes the Spirit when it speaks about Him directly. Whether those descriptions are understood as genuine personal agency or as personification is precisely the point under debate.
Over the years many theologians have understood the references to baptism "in the name of Jesus" as describing the authority and significance of Christian baptism rather than providing a verbatim baptismal formula. If so, one cannot be quite as dogmatic as the above commentary appears to be.
Saturday, October 31, 2026 at 12:43:41 PM PDT
thanks for taking the time to write up and explain
October 30, 2026 at 2:38:32 AM Shabbat Shalom
In trying to understand more of the last paragraph, which quotes Charles B. Cousar, it seems he is not arguing that the Trinity is false.
Wikipedia notes that Charles B. Cousar was an ordained minister in the Presbyterian Church (USA) and a long-time professor at Columbia Theological Seminary.
He appears to have been Trinitarian. Rather than rejecting the doctrine, he appears to distinguish between Paul's writings and the later Nicene formulations, viewing the latter as a theological articulation of themes already present in Scripture.
I'm not entirely sure where that takes us, but it is an interesting topic. It may simply be that he sees a difference between Paul's language and the later theological vocabulary used to explain it.
* Trooisto writes:
“I don’t know how Armstrongites square the divine nature of Jesus with Deuteronomy 6:4. I don’t think it can be done and I am not aware of Armstrongism trying to do this, or caring about it.
“The Holy Trinity, as one God, does jibe with the Shema,”
It can be squared; and I care about it, as I do all Scripture.
Heb 1:1 God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spake in time past unto the fathers by the prophets,
Heb 1:2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, by whom also he made the worlds;
The OT is written from the “principal” perspective [see below]. This is reflected in Hebrews 1:1-2.
1Ti 2:5 For there is ONE [HEIS] GOD [THEOS], and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus;
Eph 4:6 ONE [HEIS] GOD [THEOS] AND FATHER of all, who is above all, and through all, and in you all.
Gal 4:6 God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father.
So the Shema applies to God - for there is indeed only one God, the Father — only one God from the “principal” perspective. This does not mean that there are no other God-beings:
Dt 6:4 Hear, O Israel: The LORD [YHWH] our God ['Elohim] is one LORD [YHWH] :
Deut 6:4 Hear, O Israel, The Lord [Kyrios] our God (Theos) is one [heis] Lord (Kyrios). (Brenton, LXX)
1Co 8:6 But to us there is but ONE [HEIS] GOD [THEOS], THE FATHER... AND one [heis] Lord [Kyrios] Jesus Christ...
"[Paul] has kept the "one" intact, but has divided the Shema into two parts, with theos (God) now referring to the Father, and kurios (Lord) referring to Jesus Christ... [Paul] is reasserting for the Corinthians that ... there is indeed only one God... but at the same time, he insists that the identity of the one God also includes the one Lord..." (Gordon D. Fee, Pauline Christology, pp.90-91).
Poor Holy Spirit once again left out, as it can’t be fit into the NT shema.
Jdg 13:22 “We are doomed to die!” he said to his wife. “We have seen God!”
Jn 1:18 No one has ever seen God, but God the One and Only, who is at the Father’s side, has made him known.
God is God of both the Old and New Testament. But how did that God interact with the fathers? Hebrews provides one answer. But there is more.
With the coming of Jesus, not only did he reveal God, he also revealed himself.
But before continuing two others aspect needs to be introduced.
Jn 14:9 Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father.
Jn 14:24 These words you hear are not my own; they belong to the Father who sent me.
"What a man does through agents he may be said to do himself" (Leon Morris, Luke, TNTC, p.157).
2Co 5:19 To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself,
Leon Morris comment encapsulates “the principle of agency” which permeates the Bible. God, as principal, was with his people through Yahweh Jesus, his agent.
Part 2
Ex 25:8 And let them make me a sanctuary; that I may dwell among them.
Ex 40:34 Then a cloud covered the tent [skéné , LXX).] of the congregation, and the glory [doxa, LXX] of the LORD filled the tabernacle [skéné].
Heb 1:3 The Son radiates God’s own glory [doxa] and expresses the very character of God, (NLT).
“For the Hebrew people the glory of God was a visible and outward expression of the majestic presence of God. When the law was given at Sinai ‘the glory of the Lord' settled on the mountain. Likewise, the glory of God became manifest at ‘the tent of meeting'... Now, says the author of this letter, in these last days his same glory has been seen in the person of Christ who reflects or is ‘the radiance of God's glory' (NIV)...” (Raymond Brown, The Message of Hebrews, BST, p. 30).
God dwelt in the Tabernacle through whom we now know as the Son. That is Jesus’ dwelt with his people in OT times.
Jn 1:14 And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld his glory [doxa], the glory [doxa] as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of grace and truth.
“The typological parallel drawn between tabernacle and Temple in the descent of the cloud of glory upon the sanctuary is repeated in John 1:14: “The Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have seen his glory ... full of grace and truth” (NIV). In Jesus there was a new manifestation of divine presence” (Leslie C. Allen, The First and Second Books of Chronicles, NIB, Vol. 3, p. 502).
“In John 1:14 we read that the Word became flesh and “lived” among the people — better, he “pitched his tent” or “tabernacled” among them and all beheld his “glory.” (The noun form [skēnē] of the Greek verb skēnoō here is used throughout the Greek Old Testament, the Septuagint, to refer to the tabernacle.) Likewise, in John 2:19-21 Jesus claims to be the temple. This is typically understood to mean that God “came down” from heaven and is embodied in Jesus...” (Peter Enns, The Evolution of Adam, pp. 108-09).
John 1:14 in essence identifies Jesus as the God-being who dwelt with his OT people. So Jesus dwelt with his people on OT, while in heaven (1 Kgs 8:11-13, 30), and the physical manifestation of his dwelling presence in his earthly habitation was his glory filling the house.
2 Cor 6:16 for ye are the temple of the living God; as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people.
1Co 6:19 Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, who is in you, whom you have received from God? You are not your own;
The Shekinah is the “nearest Jewish equivalent to the Holy Spirit... The glory of God (kabod in the Heb. Bible, doxa in LXX and NT) is another name for the Shekinah...” (R. A. Stewart. "Shekinah," NBD, 2nd ed. p.1101-02).
Gal 4:6 And because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, Abba, Father.
Mt 28:20 ... and, lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world. Amen.
Just as God sent the glory of Yahweh Jesus into the tabernacle and temple and God dwelt, through Jesus, among his OT people, so God has sent the spirit of his Son into body/temple of individual believers and the temple of corporate believers and God dwells, through Jesus, among his NT people.
Part 3
Mt 28:19 Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit,
From the Bible one knows that God and Jesus are God-beings (Jn 1:1-2; 20:17, 28). But does the paring of the Holy Spirit with Them imply that the HS is also God? Is that a valid assumption? Not necessarily.
Rev 1:4 ... Grace and peace to you from him who is, and who was, and who is to come, AND from the seven spirits before his throne,
Rev 1:5 AND from Jesus Christ, who is the faithful witness, the firstborn from the dead, and the ruler of the kings of the earth.
“Not only does grace and peace proceed from the eternal God and the seven spirits before the throne, but from Jesus Christ as well” (Robert H. Mounce, The Book of Revelation, Rev., NICNT p.48).
“The innovation of grace and peace also comes from the “seven spirits before [God’s] throne.” From the perspective of a fully developed trinitarian theology it is tempting to interpret the seven spirits as the one Holy Spirit represented under the symbolism of a sevenfold or complete manifestation of his being... The primary argument is that it would be improper to bracket anyone less than deity with the Father (v. 4a) and the Son (v. 5), especially since in the context ALL THREE ARE GIVEN AS THE SOURCE OF GRACE AND PEACE. The argument loses force, however, in view of such passages as Luke 9:26, which speaks of the Son “when he comes in his glory and in the glory of the Father and of the holy angels,” and 1 Tim 5:21, in which Paul charges obedience “in the presence of God and Christ Jesus and the elect angels” ” (Robert H. Mounce, The Book of Revelation, Rev., NICNT pp. 46-47).
2Co 1:2 Grace and peace to you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.
The Holy Spirit is not included in the salutation/greeting at the beginning of this epistle just as he gets left out in all the salutations/greetings at the beginning of all of Paul’s letters.
2Co 13:14 May the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the FELLOWSHIP [KOINŌNIA] of the Holy Spirit be with you all.
Eph 4:3 Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace.
1Jn 1:3 and truly our FELLOWSHIP [KOINŌNIA] is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.
2Jn 1:3 Grace be with you, mercy, and peace, from God the Father, and from the Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of the Father, in truth and love.
“... the grace benediction in 13:14 is the only one in Paul’s letters that is Trinitarian in structure” (Scott J. Haffemann, NIVAC, p. 498).
As noted above God and Jesus are God-beings so can one assume that because the Spirit is paired with Them he is also a God-being? This is not an assumption that I can make.
Rev 22:1 And he showed me a pure river of water of life, clear as crystal, proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb.
Rev 22:3 And there shall be no more curse: but the throne of God and of the Lamb shall be in it; and his servants shall serve him:
Jn 17:3 And this is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.
While there are some verses that could be construed as supporting the Trinity, I would suggest that as the Holy Spirit is missing in so many places that one would expect him to be, I cannot accept that the Holy Spirt is a God being. Also it doesn’t fit the dwelling typology of the OT, as I understand it.
Part 4
Eze 43:5b ... the glory of the LORD filled the house.
Eze 43:6a And I heard him speaking unto me out of the house;
Eze 43:7a And he said unto me, Son of man, the place of my throne, and the place of the soles of my feet, where I will dwell in the midst of the children of Israel for ever, (AV).
In the Messianic Age God is also going to dwell on earth through His agent Yahweh Jesus; Jesus will have a dwelling presence in the Millennial Temple just he did in the Mosaic Tabernacle and Solomonic temple, while in heaven, in the sense used by the author of Hebrews, as high priest and in the heavenlies as King.
Seeing that Armstronites gets bad press for not focussing on Jesus Christ; here is part of what I believe that I put together with AI:
The “good news” that shall be proclaimed in all the world before the end may be summarized as “the redemptive reign of Jesus Christ”.
Acts 4:12b for there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved. (AV).
Key aspects this summary encompasses:
Good News (Gospel): The inherent meaning of the word “gospel” itself, suggests a message of hope and salvation.
Redemptive: Jesus’ actions (life, crucifixion, and resurrection) offer salvation and reconciliation between humanity and God.
Reign: Refers to the present and future reign of Jesus as Savior and Lord.
Ac 1:6 ... they asked of him, saying, Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?
2Ti 4:18 And the Lord shall deliver me from every evil work, and will preserve me unto his heavenly kingdom:...
It includes the establishment of the Kingdom of God on Earth; and the establishment of the Kingdom of God in heaven - replacement of Satan’s kingdom...
One Gospel
Mk 1:14 ... Jesus came into Galilee, preaching the GOSPEL OF THE KINGDOM/REIGN OF GOD,
Ro 1:16 ... the GOSPEL OF CHRIST: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek.
“These Scriptures highlight a common theological distinction, where the two Scriptures represent complementary facets of a single overarching message rather than different gospels.
“Redemptive / “Gospel of Christ”: This aspect emphasizes Jesus's atoning work—his sacrificial death, burial, and resurrection—which provides the means for forgiveness of sins and reconciliation with God. It focuses on personal salvation by grace through faith in the finished work of the Savior and the justification of the individual sinner.
“Reign / “Gospel of the Kingdom of God”: This aspect emphasizes God's active rule and sovereignty over all creation, which has broken into human history in the person and mission of Jesus. It concerns the transformation of lives and communities to align with God's will and divine principles (love, justice, peace) and the ultimate, future consummation of God's perfect reign in the Messianic Age.
“In essence, the “gospel of Christ” can be seen as the door to salvation (the means of entry), while the “gospel of the Kingdom” describes the sphere and lifestyle one enters through that door, living under God's active reign and experiencing its transformative power now, while awaiting its full realization in the future. The core message is one, encompassing both the personal redemptive work of Jesus and the cosmic scope of God's reigning authority” (AI collaboration).
Jn 3:36 Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God’s wrath remains on him.”
“... a response is expected when the king comes to reign; that is, one should turn away from their old way of life (repentance) to embrace the reign and rule of the king... TO MAKE JESUS THE CENTRE, OR THE HUB OF YOUR LIFE” (David M. Shaw, The Already and Not-Yet Kingdom au.thegospelcoalition.org).
The coming of God's reign either demands repentance or brings judgment (Cp. D. A. Carson, Matthew, EBC, Vol. 8, p.103).
This article is strong on identification but weak on distinction. That is to say, it ought not be regarded as a completed treatment of the subject.
Considerable effort is expended explaining how closely Christ and the Spirit are related, but far less effort is devoted to passages where Father, Son, and Spirit appear to interact as distinguishable agents. Examples include John 14:26 and John 15:26, where the Spirit is sent, bears witness concerning Christ, speaks, appoints, intercedes, and acts in relation to both the Father and the Son.
Strangely, in pursuing this thesis the author appears to assume that passages emphasizing identification should control the interpretation of passages emphasizing distinction. We are reminded that the Spirit is called the Spirit of Christ, that God dwells in believers through the Spirit of His Son, and that the Spirit functions as the divine presence among God's people.
Yet another set of passages also requires explanation. In these texts the Spirit is not merely identified with Christ but acts in relation to both the Father and the Son. The Father sends the Spirit. The Son sends the Spirit. The Spirit bears witness concerning Christ. Such passages present not only close association, but also genuine interaction and distinction.
The real question therefore is not whether the Spirit is closely related to Christ. Most would readily agree that He is. The question is whether the passages that distinguish the Father, Son, and Spirit can be explained equally well within the proposed framework. One can readily assemble texts emphasizing identification. The challenge is to account for both identification and distinction while giving proper weight to each.
After considering the comments above, I feel
I've considered the thoughts above and see a distortion of the Shema ... stated as there is one God, as in God the Father but there's also another God-being known as Jesus. I cans see how some may feel that we are needlessly parsing words when our beliefs are really very similar, however, my ultimate conclusion is that Armstrongism is a polytheistic religion, currently with two separate God-beings and soon, surely in the next five to seven years, the number of god-beings will balloon up to thousands. In the Kingdom of Armstrongism, the Shema can no longer be said and the nature of God will be forever changed.
2:23 writes:
This article is strong on identification but weak on distinction. That is to say, it ought not be regarded as a completed treatment of the subject.
Jn 20:22 ... He breathed on them, and He says to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit.
I was only touching on identification, so here is one more:
Jn 6:38 For I have come down from heaven not to do my will but to do the will of him who sent me.
“Throughout this Gospel Jesus has been described as the One who was sent by God (e.g., 4:34; 5:23; 6:38)... Thus as Jesus was God’s special representative (or agent) in the world, so too his disciples become Jesus’ agents...” (Gary M. Burge, John, NIVAC, p. 558).
Jn 1:32 Then John gave this testimony: “I saw the Spirit come down from heaven as a dove and remain on him.
Jn 1:33b ‘The man on whom you see the Spirit come down and remain is he who will baptize with the Holy Spirit.’
“... in this Gospel one feature of Jesus’ commission is his empowering. God not only sent his Son but also empowered him with the Spirit.
Jn 20:21 Then said Jesus to them again, Peace be unto you: as my Father hath sent me, even so send I you.
“... to be commissioned (20:21), to advance the work of God as God’s agent, means being empowered as Jesus was empowered — obtaining the Spirit, just as Jesus was anointed and as Jesus promised.
Jn 20:22 ... He breathed on them, and He says to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit.
“Thus John 20:22 becomes the climax to the entire Gospel. The Spirit ... is now given to the disciples in a provocative and personal way. Jesus breathes (on them) and says, “Receive [the] Holy Spirit.”
Jn 7:37 On the last and greatest day of the Feast, Jesus stood and said in a loud voice, “IF ANYONE IS THIRSTY, LET HIM COME TO ME AND DRINK.
Jn 7:38 Whoever believes in me, as the Scripture has said, streams of living water will flow from within him.”
Jn 7:39 BY THIS HE MEANT THE SPIRIT, whom those who believed in him were later to receive. Up to that time the Spirit had not been given, since Jesus had not yet been glorified.
“John 20:22 fulfills the word given at the Feast of Tabernacles, where Jesus’ offer of living water referred to the Holy Spirit, which could not be distributed until Jesus was glorified (7:39). Now the hour of glorification has reached its climax. Jesus is departing, and he places the Spirit that is within him in their lives” (Gary M. Burge, John, NIVAC, p. 559).
“This passage is one of the most controversial in the Gospel” (Gary M. Burge, John, NIVAC, p. 559).
“... the notion of the Spirit as an empowerment, as that which can be “breathed” on the disciples from Jesus’ mouth seems inconsistent with that of the Spirit as Advocate (or another Advocate”) a divine Person who will teach the disciples after Jesus’ departure, leading them into all truth (see 14:16-17, 26; 15:26; 16:7, 13)” (J. Ramsey Michaels, The Gospel of John, NICNT, p.1011).
It is suggested there is no inconsistency if the Holy Spirit, = Spirit of Jesus, is at times personalized.
“The masculine “Advocate,” implying personality, is repeated linked to the neuter “Spirit,” either “the Holy Spirit” (14:26) or “the Spirit of Truth” (14:16; 15:26; 16:13). Here, as in the first half of the Gospel (1:32-33; 3:5, 6, 8, 35; 4:23-24; 6:63; 7:29), the neuter “Spirit” is used (without even the definite article!) LEAVING LITTLE ROOM FOR THE SPIRIT’S PERSONALITY... In the Gospel itself, a variety of expressions have been used for the Advocate’s coming: “I will ask the father, and he will give you ...” (14:16); “the Father will send in my name” (14:26); whom I will send to you from the Father” (15:26); “if I go, I will send him to you” (16:7) None of these quote match the present scene in which “Holy Spirit” comes on the disciples as breath from Jesus’ mouth.
Part 2
“The description here is better attuned to the promise John received that Jesus would baptize “in Holy Spirit” — as here without the definite article (1:33) — or to the experience of being “born of water and Spirit” as qualification for entering the kingdom of God (see 3:5-6). In short, the accent is on “life,” even as Jesus is alive (14:19), not on a new personal Companion to be with them forever and lead them into all the truth. And yet, this is the only “Spirit” that comes on the disciples within the pages of this Gospel...” (J. Ramsey Michaels, The Gospel of John, NICNT, p.1011).
Jn 20:22 ... He breathed [emphusaó] on them, and He says to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit.
Ge 2:7 and breathed [emphusaó] upon his face the breath [pnoé] of life, and the man became a living soul. (Brenton, LXX).
Ac 2:2 And suddenly a sound like a violent rushing of wind [pnoé] came out of heaven, and it filled the whole house where they were sitting.
As variations are a stylistic feature of John’s writings then it should be no surprising that John switches from a non-personalized use of the Spirit before chapters 14-16, a personalized Spirit in ch 14-16, and an impersonal one in 20:22.The impersonal descriptions of the Spirit outnumber the personalized ones.
Jn 14:23 Jesus answered and said unto him, If a man love me, he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him.
John followed by Acts is the NT parallel to the OT precedent of God coming to dwell with his people through Jesus:
Non-Public Dwelling: Jn 20:22 ... He breathed on them, and He says to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit.
Public Dwelling: Ac 2:4 All of them were filled with the Holy Spirit
Non-Public Dwelling: Ex 40:34 And the cloud covered the Tent of Meeting, and the glory of YHWH filled the tabernacle.
Official Public Dwelling: Lev 9:23 And Moses and Aaron went into the Tent of Meeting, and they came out, and they blessed the people, and the glory of YHWH appeared to all the people. (More a confirmation of the dwelling, after the ordination of Aaron and his sons).
Non-Public Dwelling: 2 Ch 5:14 and the priests could not continue ministering because of the cloud, for the glory of YHWH had filled the house of God.
Official Public Dwelling: 2 Ch 7:3a-bα And all the sons of Israel looked upon the descending of the fire and the glory of YHWH upon the temple, and they bowed their faces to the ground on the pavement, and they worshiped.
1 Jn 4:13 In this we know that we remain in Him and He in us: because from out of His Spirit He has given to us. (BLB).
1 Jn 4:13 This is how we know that we live in him and he in us: He has given us of his Spirit. (NIV).
“Jesus desires to enter his disciples lives, to indwell them completely, to provide them with his Spirit (symbolized through his breath)... In 1 John the author tries to explain that which gives Christians an identity and a power that sets them apart from the world. He writes, “We know that we live in him and he in us, because he has given us of HIS SPIRIT” (1 John 4:13, italics added). THE HOLY SPIRIT IS JESUS’ SPIRIT; it is the powerful presence of Christ with his friends” (Gary M. Burge, John, NIVAC, p. 567).
So in the mystery of the Trinity, there is another mystery, in that a co-equal, co-eternal Person of the Godhead can be literally exhaled from the mouth of Jesus as a component of his breath. :)
I would suggest that Occam’s razor would favor the binitarian/bitheistic model over the trinitarian one.
Post a Comment