I Don’t Like Puzzles
Theodicy, Armstrongism and Performance Christianity
The Attempts to Figure Out the Puzzle of Evil
By Scout
“But who indeed are you, a human, to argue with God? Will what is molded say to the one who molds it, “Why have you made me like this?” Romans 9:20, NRSV
Some parts of Christianity I have thought a lot about. Other parts, not so much. This is mostly a matter of interest but sometimes it can be a matter of perplexity. I am bothered by theodicy. I do not believe that Christianity has made much of this important, nay critical, part of Christian doctrine. And I think Armstrongism is similar to other denominations on this topic but not worse.
Theodicy is a study of why there is a good and perfect God yet an evil world. For me, this topic has been the elephant in the room I didn’t want to talk about. Because I had no answers and I mostly found the answers of others to be inadequate. In Christian theology, theodicy has a forensic flare. Theologians seek to justify God, as if he is being sued in court, for the existence of an evil world. So they come up with various justifying arguments. Mankind holds the same perspective as Job – God needs justification. What binds all these arguments together is the perpetually troublesome concept of anthropomorphism. Armstrongism, strong in anthropomorphism, of course, is in the fray. So, I don’t have an answer for this, but I do have a viewpoint. Let me give you my line of reasoning.
A Theodicy Sampler
If God is perfectly good, why is this world a vortex of evil? A number of attempts have been made to unravel this perplexing issue. David Bentley Hart has asserted that God has nothing to do with evil. Rather, Thrones, Principalities and Powers are the source of evil in the Cosmos. (I am never sure if I actually understand what Hart writes.) My opposing view is that all sentient beings, whether good or evil, operate under the license of God. Nobody can exercise any level of free will without permission from God either implicitly or explicitly.
Another view is that God is engaged in soul-making. The world is a boot camp and we are all being put through the exercises that will produce the good character that will serve us and others throughout eternity. But often the outrageous evil of this world does not build people but crushes them into uselessness. Living on this planet is not a pleasant trip to the exercise salon to build biceps. Another problem is that not everyone is put through a prescribed regimen that is the same for all even though the ultimate purpose must be the same. Some people have an easy ride and others ride in terror. What’s that about?
Others believe that God defends the free will of people and this naturally results in the generation of evil. God wants people to have the free will to choose good. Only if good is freely chosen is it a product of good character. Coercion doesn’t count. If we are all Calvinist automatons, our actions are empty of genuine heart except once in a while as a matter of coincidence. So, if humans are accorded free will, they may produce both good and evil. You can’t let people do what they want to do and learn from it unless there is the potential for them to screw up. And we have screwed up widely.
Yet, others believe that God is a Cosmic Accountant who offsets debits against credits. He assures that if an evil is committed it is matched to some good that accrues. And because the books will be balanced in the Eschaton, all is well that ends well. The problem with this is that it connects good to evil as if evil is a necessary principle in the Creation. Evil has a necessary place at the table which denies the perfection of a loving God.
Then there are those that reject typical beliefs about God and evil. Often cited is the character Ivan in Dostoevsky’s novel The Brothers Karamazov. Ivan accepts the idea of God. He even believes that one day evil could yield some kind of a good outcome. He just does not believe that any outcome is worth the horror of a tortured and murdered child. It is a cost/benefit problem. There is no benefit that makes the cost acceptable.
I am not familiar with all conjectures concerning theodicy. But of the ones I have examined, including the Armstrongist view which I will turn to later, seem to be burdened to the point of collapse with anthropomorphism. They assume that God is a human-like being, who thinks like a human, acts like a human and who, like a human, must be defended in the court of theology for permitting evil where it should not be. I believe this viewpoint is in error.
After reviewing and seeing the flaws in a number of theodicies, maybe theologians are barking up the wrong tree. Maybe this is something that nobody is going to figure out this side of the Parousia. Like dark matter in the Cosmos.
The Reasonableness of not Knowing
We know God by analogy and anthropomorphism is just one big analogy. God is described in human terms, mostly, in scripture because that makes him understandable to humans. Some mistakenly believe that the analogy, an instructional literary device, is actually God’s essence and this leads them to believe in a limited, human-like God. For some, the limitation of God is useful in that it makes the idiosyncratic idea that humankind’s destiny to become God-as-God-is-God much more plausible.
Analogy is very useful if it is understood to be analogy. It is the principal means we have of understanding God. But the clarity is lost if we believe that analogy is essence. God is absolute and we are relative. Yet, analogy works because we are made in his image (not his essence). Everything in the created, relative realm is an analogy of the Divine realm. Even wording that seems technically precise is really anthropomorphic. To say God is all-powerful is to take the limited human concept of power and escalate it far beyond human experience. Though this is an ardent sublimation, the meaning still remains rooted in humanness. It is just much larger on the relative human scale ― a scale that does not pertain to God at all because he is absolute and not relative.
The point is that we as relative beings will still be relative beings when we are resurrected. We are relative because as created beings we are contingent on the Creator who prescribes limits for us. God, on the other hand, is uncreated and unlimited. Hence, God transcends us and we will never know God in the fullness of his essence. Isiah 55 says, "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways." Our understanding of the absolute God is naturally apophatic. We can characterize the relative through analogy but our metaphors for the absolute are spare.
So, what does this apophatic view mean for developing theodicy? It means that we cannot develop a theodicy. God transcends us. He is of a different category that we are. It is presumptuous to believe that we can justify God. And this justification is the driver behind the formulation of theodicies. We cannot even understand his plans, purposes and principles beyond what he has revealed to us in our limited and contingent condition.
Carefully note that I am not asserting that there is no theodicy. I am agreeing with the idea developed by some theologians that the true theodicy is in the divine realm and it transcends our understanding. God does not act without purpose; it is just that we do not understand his purposes. We enjoy a scaled down understanding, dependent on analogy, but in theodicy we bump up against its limits. I had an Armstrongist commenter on this blog once say that if we can’t understand God, what is then the value of being a Christian. There is a difference between having and exhaustive understanding and having a working understanding. We have the latter.
The Armstrongist View – Maybe
This must be conjectural. I searched one of the online archives of Armstrongist literature and the word “theodicy” was not found by the search engine. So, I will rely on my 30 years of experience as a one-time Armstrongist. It is safe to say that Armstrongists believe that people have free will and can do either evil or good. Otherwise, the Armstrongist view aligns mostly closely with soul-making. God is producing righteous character in his followers and the potential for evil is a tool in this process. People must learn that evil is destructive and they must not follow evil.
Earlier, I mentioned some of the flaws with the idea of soul-making. Theologian Robert Fortuin expands this further. He points out that soul-making treats atrocities as if they were useful lessons, like classroom exercises. In my mind this flaw belittles the empathy of God for humanity. Another flaw he identifies is the mistaken belief that we can actually understand the logical connection between human suffering and divine purpose. Instead, this is a mystery to us with our limited capabilities. Further, it makes evil a useful constructive tool instead of a parasitic tragedy on human existence. So, the idea that evil exists so we can all develop character fails.
Conclusion
My belief that God’s intents are far beyond our ability to understand when it comes to evil in our world has a name. I have seen it termed Apophatic Non-theodicy. It sounds like a denial and it is. The denial is inescapable. And the reason why theologians cannot come up with a cogent, credible theodicy is not a problem of persuasive logic in the justification of God but a problem of the doctrine of God. We, Christians and Armstrongists, have the doctrine of God wrong. God is absolute and we cannot apply our relative categories to him. We find ourselves in a place of humility. Like it says in Job 40, “Then Job answered the Lord: “See, I am of small account; what shall I answer you? I lay my hand on my mouth.” If someone asks me why the kid in our neighborhood, who everyone agrees was a great kid, got runover and killed in the street, I will say, “I don’t know.”

27 comments:
Interesting analysis on a subject I have given much thought to over the years, and admit that I do not understand. The author of Hebrews tells us that Jesus was perfected through sufferings. So, even Jesus had to deal with theodicy, and that made him more complete some way- all for our good. I am amazed and ever grateful- looking forward to the "other side" where I just might be able to finally understand .
"I don't know" is a legitimate answer although we often believe it makes us appear weak. The truth is, in most things like this we can only speculate, which pitfalls are addressed in the book of Job.
My speculation is, God looks at suffering and death differently than we do. He knows, we don't. For us, death is devastating, final, the end, and who knows if there is anything else. For Him, death has been conquered, it's a night's sleep, it lasts a moment, in a twinkling of an eye. Our only hope is to believe what He says about it and accept it by faith. Even if it turns out to be a farce, what have we lost?
I choose to believe that the neighborhood kid, Job's children, Ensign Pavel Chekhov (who passed yesterday) are not lost to oblivion, but will live again in a much better world under the best of conditions. Why think otherwise? It's the only thing that makes sense.
Scout,
It is referred to as "the problem of evil" for a reason. As you know, the Bible presents a number of different perspectives on this topic. We are informed that Lucifer and his angels sinned, and evil was born. Scripture also talks about us having the ability to choose between good and evil (free will). The book of Job portrays his suffering as the consequence of God allowing Satan to inflict harm on him (ostensibly for the purpose of making Job a better person - teaching him that God is beyond his ability to comprehend). In numerous places in the Hebrew Bible, suffering is portrayed as the natural consequence of sinning (e.g. Israel, Judah, Saul, David, etc.). The Bible also suggests that God sometimes uses evil to further his own ends (e.g. to strengthen or "test" faith, to provide a universal need for salvation, etc.). Finally, the Bible acknowledges that sh-t happens. Sometimes buildings collapse, burn, flood, or are blown down. Closely allied with this concept, is the subtle acknowledgement that the existence of good demands the existence of its counterpart - evil.
Nevertheless, we know that Scripture portrays a time in the future when evil will cease to be a part of reality. Moreover, the concept of a eutopia is deeply rooted in human consciousness. The Bible talks about a time when death will be abolished, and there won't be any pain, suffering or sorrow anymore. Herbert Armstrong talked about "The World Tomorrow." We all remember the picture of the lion with the lamb and a small child. Sir Thomas More wrote about it. Even so, we know that this is unattainable by us - without God. M. Night Shyalmalan's "The Village" portrayed a village that had been organized to exclude the evils of our modern culture, but evil found the people there anyway (and they had to appeal to the outside world to save one of their members). The point - that humans can't root out or isolate ourselves from evil. The Bible, however, talks about a New Heavens and a New Earth, and a New Jerusalem, and the complete extermination of evil.
Bottom line, I think that only God can know the outcome of the decisions we make - only "he" can see the end of all things. Hence, I think that you are on the right track when you suggest that this is a problem beyond our ability to comprehend and adequately address. For Christians, there must be that element of faith - faith in God's love, goodness, and justice. We must believe that God has all of this in hand and is working toward a good conclusion for all of us.
This article, while interesting, is an academic exercise, an overcomplication through intellectualization. Suffering is suffering. Pain is pain. Someone being burned to death in a car wreck, or at the stake, or in a housefire, doesn't care one iota about the concept of theodicy.
The simplest solution is usually the most correct. It doesn't matter why there is suffering and pain. It matters there is. And if god is supposedly all-loving, the perfection of good, omnipotent, and omnipresent, well, that belief collapses in light of the simplicity and visceral experience of pain and suffering.
Anonymous 10:40 wrote, “Someone being burned to death in a car wreck, or at the stake, or in a housefire, doesn't care one iota about the concept of theodicy.”
I agree. If someone is the object of atrocity, everything else becomes superficial. Survival absorbs all of our capacities. But we who can do so owe it to people who experience such things to reflect on the meaning of their ordeal. Many Elect brothers and sisters died in the arena in Rome in the mouths of lions. We owe it to them not to let their passion be trivialized. We have the opportunity for the present to consider this academically and we should. The unexamined life is not worth living.
Polarity seems to be one of the prevailing concepts of nature. So much so, that the moment we become aware of "a thing",we also become aware of the polar opposite of that thing. That may not be a theological explanation, but it is how I've come to see evil in the presence of good. It's simply the flip side
BB
"The secret things belong to God" Moses wrote in Deuteronomy. He has revealed to us what we NEED to know "for every good work." We WANT to know more, but we don't NEED to know more. So, "the just must live by faith." Rather than asking "WHY is there evil?", maybe we should ask ourselves, "What are we going to do about evil?" I'm convinced that God views death differently than we do. Paul got a peak behind the curtain and wrote to the Philippians that if had to choose life or death, he would choose death. What did he know that we don't? People a lot smarter than me haven't answered some of these questions. I'd be a fool to think that I could.
I am inclined towards Augustine’s view of evil. He believed that evil had no real substance. Evil was instead an absence of good. The term that modern theologians use is “privative.” Evil is the deprivation of good, hence, it is privative. It is called the Privation Theory of Evil. It was difficult for me to understand this without the following scripture:
"And God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good. And the evening and the morning were the sixth day." (Genesis 1:31)
If God created only good and he is the only Creator, then evil was not created as good was and does not have the same existential status that good has. Evil is, rather, a disruption of good. It is parasitic on good.
Another question is why do we experience evil at all? God knew that evil would inevitably happen in this world. Christ was slain from the foundation of the Cosmos. And we all experience evil, know evil and must struggle against evil. Yet, we believe a world is coming in which there will be no evil. So, why the boot camp? What are we preparing for? I believe that while evil will not exist eternally, the need to reject evil will. We will come out of this world with the horror of evil so profoundly imprinted on us that it will always be rejected. The nature of evil will always be on the bookshelves of our minds as a reference work. The reason why we will all be righteous in the afterlife is that with the blessing of God we will exert our wills to be.
I believe evil is mysterious. We cannot always sort out cause and effect. I think HWA tried to systematize evil. He tried to systematize many things about life. The seven laws of this and that. But evil resists being systematized. The home of a Christian Ukrainian family in Kiev is hit with an artillery shell and they are all killed including a baby who has no accountability. Who can tell why? Many try to reduce the cognitive dissonance by making up reasons for why evil befalls someone. A futile and judgmental gesture.
Evil cannot be systematized. HWA made evil the product of transgressing the laws of God. Certainly that is an evil but it is not all evil. Rather it leads to judgementalism. If someone suffers, then you know they have broken God’s law, you may think. And then performance becomes the imperative. You then instead of the Articles of Faith you have the Articles of Performance. The more you systematize, the less important faith becomes and the more important works become. Scripture states, “"But if ye be without chastisement, whereof all are partakers, then are ye bastards, and not sons."
I am not expressing any kind of coherent doctrine of evil. Just some things I have considered. My two cents…
If we are trying to simplify the concept and define it, I believe that evil can best be described as the absence of LOVE. God is the epitome of love, and Christ identified love as the basis for God's universal law. This absence can be by design or happenstance - active or passive. If God is present, both are excluded as possibilities. God is NOT the source of evil, but he can allow it to exist outside of his active presence. In this respect, omnipresence is a Divine prerogative that can be exercised or withheld at will. (e.g. before Christ, we existed in a state of alienation from God)
Miller Jones 10:34
I believe you put a fine point on it. In theodicy two kinds of evil are defined: moral evil and natural evil. Natural evil encompasses hurricanes and fires and those sorts of events. In my view, moral evil is exactly what you have written: It is the absence of love.
Ronald Dart in his ministry taught and warned alot about the differences and dangers of human evil versus Satanic evil.
He used to warn church members they well may encounter human evil whilst being a church member much more than Satanic evil.
How right he was.
Much human evil can take root in religious offices especially from within unchecked and unaccountable church ministry. Men are fallible and in church environments many men without proper guidance have zero accountability in their lives, and are therefore very vunerable to doing human evil to others and jepodising their standing with God.
To add to the complexity of the issue of theodicy is theologian Rudolf Bultman’s view. Google AI states his view like this:
“Rudolf Bultmann asserted that the language of "powers" used by New Testament writers like Paul actually described the impersonal, pre-programmed, or determinative structures of the cosmos. In his view, these "powers" represent the existential conditions, natural laws, and social systems that modern science understands as the regular operations of history and nature—forces that human beings mistakenly allow to rule over them rather than living in true existential freedom under God.”
I interpret Bultman’s views as follows. There are impersonal algorithms inherent in the fallen Cosmos that are conducive to life going wrong – somewhat like our recent jeopardous foray into artificial intelligence. And these powers were overthrown by Christ at the Cross but we are yet in the age of Already But Not Yet. So, these forces are still in some way operative. Jesus said, “If the world (Cosmos) hate you, ye know that it hated me before it hated you.”
Scout @ 7:59,
I believe that evil can occur because of natural forces acting without personal supervision or restraint. Hurricanes, tornadoes, and fires operate without love or malice.
I don't think that evil is simply an absence of good. There are those who deliberately create evil, almost as it is a clean sheet blueprint. As an example, who would classify ethnic "cleansing", i.e. mass extermination, as the absence of good. Rape, and murder, too. You could describe stealing as disrespecting others' property, unless it were organized crime or a ponzi scheme.
Absence of good might include failure to assist an accident victim, or hearing about someone planning to commit a crime and failing to report it. Or, possibly failing to use the Holy Spirit's correct pronouns.
Anonymous 8:27
I am no expert in Augustinian belief but I think he was not referring to evil as the operational effects but as its abstract nature. He did not believe that evil was created by God like a substance of some sort. Rather than having its own existential category, evil is the malfunction of objects and systems that were otherwise good. “Absence” as a term may sound static or passive. But he saw evil as getting its activity and energy from processes that have gone wrong. My guess is that he saw evil as a kind of label. It is what we label the phenomenon where good things malfunction. But evil does not exist as a created category. My speculation.
You have a good cow. And you have a good garden. And you have a good dog. The dog barks, scares the cow, the cow bolts and breaks down the fence and tramples the garden. Evil happened but had no separate substantive existence. Good things just went wrong. For a moment, good was absent. Augustine refers to that absence as evil. HWA might say it happened because the famer transgressed laws. Rudolf Bultman might say it happened because the Cosmos are programmed to produce these kinds of events.
Someone might ask, what about Adolf Hitler. Is he just a malfunction or was he a willful evil. I think, in fact, he was both. I believe God created us to be seekers of good. But sometimes, for many reasons, we do not know what good is. Adolf Hitler was actually engaged in seeking good when he decided to exterminate the Jews. He thought the world would be a better place for everyone if the Jews no longer existed. He was seeking good but he did not know what good was. Somewhere there was a malfunction of good thing that caused his viewpoint.
Most people don’t think this way. It probably only has a place in philosophy and theodicy.
As Lonnie noted, the Bible presents many tiers of evil, wickedness, sin and iniquity (see Companion Bible Appendixes 44, 128), which represent a broad scope of causation, such as Satan's rebellion and influence, the workings of this world system, and the outworking of man's fallen nature, all being departures from the true and living God. All of these factors have contributed to one of the more disturbing things we are witnessing today which is the complete abandonment of what Scripture calls "natural affection" (Romans 1:31), the instinctive love that should exist in family relationships and between friends. God put this into our human nature (Romans 1:14-15) for the reason of maintaining the race and a viable society, yet in this day and age its absence is beginning to run amok. Parents are killing their children, children their parents, no love for the unborn or the elderly, husbands and wives abusing one another, friends killing friends, and the list goes on.
There are many psychological factors and explanations that have been advanced, but the loss of natural affection is both a symptom and a cause of the moral decay that is encouraged and being normalized in the narratives of this corrupt world system. The apostle Paul specifically lists this as a very real and visable sign of what he calls "the last days" (2 Timothy 3:1-3).
People who desire to be good are naturally motivated towards goodness, those who dwell in mischief and lies naturally turn towards evil doings.
Many evil people never change and grow worse over time, it's the tragedy of the human condition. Many evil men have always been in power, from the bad Kings of Israel to modern day political leaders.
Theodicy is a difficult topic to consider. I am not accustomed to considering its nature and I believe that is so for most people. Many of the comments here have drifted away from theodicy into an analysis of evil. These two questions illustrate the distinction:
Question 1: What is evil? (A question of Ethics)
Question 2: If there is a good God, why is there evil in the world? (A question of Theodicy)
Question 1 is certainly relevant to Question 2 but not the same issue. To say that evil is the lack of love or a lack of natural affection is to give us an answer to Question 1. Question 2 asks the question: If there is a good God, how can there be a world where there is no love? If he is God why doesn't he prevent the lack of love? If he cannot prevent the lack of love, is he really God?
My belief has come to be that we are unable as limited human beings to evaluate these questions. We can create a definition of evil that may seem mostly satisfactory. But why are we even trying to create a definition of evil? Why is evil not an unknown concept for us? If we knew the answer to this last question, we could easily justify God and theodicy would not be such a problem in Christianity.
And, of course, defining evil is not as easy as you might think. For example, a hypothetical case. Thirteen generations ago, a man saves a boy from drowning in a remote area of England. We would think of that as a good act. Thirteen generations later, one of the boy’s direct descendants in Seattle becomes a serial killer and cruelly kills a bunch of people. Saving the drowning boy was one of many direct causes of the deaths of many people. Was saving the boy from drowning a good or evil act? How does one sort this out? That is a significant question but it is not the central issue of theodicy. Theodicy is concerned not with how evil happens but if there is a good God, why is there evil in the first place?
Armstrongists have the simplistic notion that evil comes out of the human heart. They never consider that humans were created by God and in his image (they erroneously believe that the image refers to the human shape). And if God created us with an unavoidable inclination to evil, does he not become responsible himself for human perfidy? These questions will eat your lunch. These questions are the hard and gritty work of theology. For now, I have concluded that humans just are not up to the challenge. It transcends us.
It depends on your definition of love. You have not defined what you qualify love as.
One persons definition of love can be scriptually correct, another's view of love can be tainted by the culture of the world outside of God.
Scout 739
You are right, we are limited human beings and there are no simple answers to be had here, for we are dealing with the main tenants of all human philosophy. The meaning of life, the problem of evil, and the mystery of death are all interrelated. Together they form the basis of all our beliefs and basic premises about everything. The first paragraph of the summation on "evil" in the International Standard Bible Encyclopedia reads: "Evil remains a mystery. Any attempt to explain evil must be a oversimplification and a falsification. Still, it is necessary to take this mystery seriously if anything like an adequate account of life is to be given". (ISBE, vol.2, article " Evil", pg.210).
Both Wikipedia and the Bible Hub thoroughly discuss the subject, and the explanations by Byker Bob (polarity) and Lonnie (alienation from God) are both worthy of further discussion.
My oversimplified explanation on this is a take off of the alienation theory, that man was created good, but was enticed and fell from grace. Being now alienated from God, he was banished from paradise, sent forth to do his own thing, given to all things "self", all to eventually learn a valuable lesson (see Proverbs 1:7, 24-33, Galatians 6:7-8). The lesson of both the Garden and that of the old covenant experiment is one and the same!
Christ, " without me, you can do nothing", John 15:5.
Ronald Dart in early 2000's did an three part Bible study entitled 'Understanding Evil' it is available on youtube.
BP8 7:17
I think we have a big clue about the significance of evil in the fact that Jesus did not return immediately after 70 AD. I would guess that his followers would conclude, correctly, that the fall of Jerusalem was the Tribulation and the Parousia must soon happen. But it did not play out that way. So, now we live in an extended period of already-but-not-yet where generation after generation of the Christian Elect are exposed to an environment of evil as evil becomes more and more multi-faceted.
It must have something to do with Christians training for the Priesthood. I could speculate on this but I have no real answers.
To believe the book of Revelation is of no significance and that the great tribulation has already happened is a form of evil in itself. An foolish evil that harms self and anyone foolish enough to go along with it.
I am reminded of the foolish priests and prophets telling Isaiah that he was wrong and the was only good times ahead.
I think you need to consider if your pre-occupation with prophecy is not making it impossible for you to understand anything else.
I am not pre-occupied with prophecy, that is a dog that won't hunt. I am a realist and the Great Tribulation is to come. When, i do not know.
Jesus Christ himself instructed his followers to Watch.
Here's some realism. If you are an Armstrongist then you are preoccupied with the prophecy about the Tribulation. I assume you are watching all the time as you have written.
The Tribulation already happened. Have a look at:
https://armstrongismlibrary.blogspot.com/2022/04/why-i-do-not-believe-in-end-time.html
That is your freedom of choice not to believe. No-one can change your opinion but equally you carry no sway on people who believe differently to you.
But many many sunday going Christians perceive that there is something askew with the world, leaders are not who they should be i.e. Trump, and that times they are achanging.
Post a Comment