Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Wade Cox’s “Unitarian Bible” and “Council of the Elohim” Claims




Wade Cox's "Unitarian Bible" and "Council of the Elohim" Claims
By a Concerned Believer

Wade Cox (Christian Churches of God) and his Armstrongist fellow travelers. particularly Bob Thiel, love to announce that "most reputable theologians" have quietly admitted the Bible is Unitarian and subordinationist, that Calvin, Harnack, and Brunner all said so, and that Trinitarians have spent centuries doctoring translations to hide a vast "Council of the Elohim" of which Christ is merely one member. The claim is both overconfident and false. It selectively quotes, ignores context, and treats specialized scholarly observations about the divine council as if they vindicate Cox's particular Unitarian/subordinationist system. Most serious biblical scholars-critical or confessional-do not agree with Cox, Bob Thiel, or the rest of the Armstrongist crowd on this.

Calvin, Harnack, and Brunner Did Not "Admit" What Cox Claims

John Calvin was a thoroughgoing Trinitarian. He wrote extensively on the three persons in one essence, condemned Arius for stripping the Son of eternal divinity, and insisted that Father, Son, and Spirit are each fully God. He used traditional language of relations while defending the Son's aseity with respect to the divine essence. Claims that Calvin "admitted" the Bible is Unitarian require ignoring large sections of the Institutes and his confessional statements. Subordination language appears in the economic Trinity (the Son's functional submission in the incarnation and redemptive work), but that is not Unitarianism.

Adolf von Harnack was a liberal Protestant church historian. He argued that classical Trinitarian and Christological dogma was a later Hellenization of a simpler ethical gospel centered on the fatherhood of God and the kingdom. That is a reconstruction of an "original" Jesus, not a demonstration that the New Testament texts themselves teach Unitarianism. Harnack did not claim the biblical writers were Unitarians in Cox's sense; he claimed later church dogma departed from what he thought the historical Jesus taught. Critical scholarship continues to debate the development of Christology, but early high Christology (John 1, Philippians 2, Colossians 1, Hebrews 1) is widely recognized as present in the first century, not a fourth-century invention.

Emil Brunner was a neo-orthodox theologian who affirmed the deity of Christ and treated the Trinity as important Christian teaching, even while critiquing certain classical formulations and emphasizing personal encounter. He was not a Unitarian. Cox's appeal to these three men is selective citation or misrepresentation.

The Divine Council Exists-and It Does Not Support Cox's System

Scholars have long noted a "divine council" or heavenly assembly in the Old Testament (Psalm 82, Psalm 89, Job 1-2, Deuteronomy 32, etc.). Leopold Sabourin and many others discuss it. Modern work by figures such as Michael Heiser has popularized the concept for a broader audience: elohim can function as a category term for spiritual beings who inhabit the unseen realm, with Yahweh as the unique, incomparable, uncreated Creator who alone is worthy of worship. The "sons of God" or members of the council are subordinate beings under Yahweh's authority.

This does not mean the Bible is Unitarian, nor that Christ is simply one more elohim on the same plane as the rest of the host. The council consists of created beings. Yahweh remains uniquely other. Evangelical scholars who accept the divine council (including Heiser) still affirm high Christology-the Son as uncreated, the unique monogenes, the one through whom all things were made, and the one to whom the angels are commanded to worship (Hebrews 1). Critical scholars who see more developmental or polytheistic background material still do not endorse Cox's reconstruction of a singular Eloah who "extends" into an elohim host of which Christ is a subordinate member. Armstrongist Ditheism (two co-eternal beings) and Cox's Unitarian alternative are both minority systems outside mainstream scholarship.

Textual and Translation Claims

Deuteronomy 32:8 is a well-known textual variant. The Masoretic Text reads "sons of Israel"; the Dead Sea Scrolls and Septuagint support "sons of God" / "sons of El" (or "angels of God" in the Greek). Most textual critics regard the "sons of God" reading as earlier. The change in the Masoretic tradition is widely viewed as a monotheizing or clarifying edit, not a conspiracy to hide Cox's theology. The verse depicts the Most High allocating nations under subordinate divine beings, with Israel as Yahweh's own portion. It does not demote Yahweh or support Unitarianism. Similar observations apply to other passages Cox cites; the existence of a heavenly assembly is not news, and it does not do the doctrinal work Cox wants.

Psalm 8:5 uses elohim. The Septuagint translated it as "angels," and Hebrews 2 quotes that rendering. This is ancient and contextually defensible (the verse is about humanity's status relative to the heavenly host). It is not a Trinitarian plot to hide an "extended order of beings." English translations that follow the Septuagint/Hebrews or render "heavenly beings" are reflecting the textual and interpretive tradition, not covering up Unitarianism. Bullinger's notes in the Companion Bible are interesting but not decisive against the broader scholarly and translational consensus.

Claims of widespread Sopherim "forgeries" in Job and elsewhere to conceal a Unitarian council are exaggerated. Textual criticism acknowledges variants and scribal activity; it does not support a coordinated effort to disguise the theology Cox prefers.

The Real Issue

Cox's system treats the One True God as singular Eloah, with elohim referring to an extended host (including a subordinate Christ) that humans can join. This is a particular Armstrongist reconstruction. It is not the consensus of "reputable theologians." Mainstream biblical scholarship-whether conservative (affirming early high Christology and the uniqueness of the Son) or critical (tracing development and ancient Near Eastern parallels)-rejects the idea that Trinitarians have systematically altered the Bible to hide a Unitarian council, and it does not endorse Cox's or Thiel's particular solutions to the nature of God.

The New Testament repeatedly presents Jesus as the unique Son, the one through whom all things were made, the one who shares the divine name and receives worship, and the one who is greater than the angels (Hebrews 1). Attempts to fold him into a larger council of created elohim require special pleading that most scholars do not accept. Cox's confident appeals to Calvin, Harnack, Brunner, Sabourin, and alleged translation conspiracies do not hold up under scrutiny. They are Armstrongist special pleading dressed up as scholarly consensus.

Conclusion

Wade Cox's bold assertions amount to little more than an Armstrongist shell game. He points to real scholarly discussions of the divine council, real textual variants, and the occasional liberal historian's reconstruction of early Christianity, then pretends these add up to a consensus that the Bible is Unitarian, that Trinitarians have been systematically rewriting the text for centuries, and that his own version of a singular Eloah plus a subordinate host of elohim is what the texts actually teach. It isn't.

Most reputable theologians and biblical scholars do not agree with Cox, Thiel, or the rest of the Armstrongist crowd. Calvin was not a Unitarian. Harnack was not saying what Cox wants him to have said. Brunner was not a Unitarian. The divine council, where it is acknowledged, consists of created beings under the absolute sovereignty of Yahweh; it does not demote the unique, uncreated Son of the New Testament to the status of one more member of the host. Translations that render elohim as "angels" in certain contexts are ancient and contextually grounded, not the product of a centuries-long Trinitarian conspiracy. And the textual changes Cox highlights (such as Deuteronomy 32:8) are well-known to scholars and do not support his system.

Armstrongism has a long habit of announcing that "the scholars" or "reputable theologians" have finally come around to its views, only for those same scholars to remain blissfully unaware of the supposed conversion. Cox's treatment of the "Council of the Elohim" is simply the latest installment. The texts are open for examination. The scholarly literature is public. And neither supports the confident Unitarian-subordinationist reconstruction Cox is selling.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Good post. The Armstrong franchise is simply looking for credibility, any credibility. They are a dying movement and nothing will bring them back from the cliff edge, no matter what they say or who they quote or point too; that will give them validity of any kind. Cliff edge? Nah, they have fallen off. The way back is Jesus Christ, who gave Himself for us all. We contributed nothing to our salvation except the sin that made it necessary. We are saved by grace…..not by works or intellectual mishmash that passes as gospel. My two cents worth…..

Anonymous said...

"Bible scolarship" is an oxymoron.

Anonymous said...

There have always been certain Armstrongite teachers who deliberately put on pedantic airs, adding their own brand of knowledge they consider to be special to the package of HWAcaca, in the hopes that it will distinguish them from the crowd of others. Usually, the bits which they add strain credibility. Some is total fabrication, and is easily dispelled. At best it is pretentious. It appeals to their followers as Armstrongism always has. It puffs them up because they feel as if they have special knowledge of which nobody else is aware. As in the case of flat earthers or young creationists, it defies even the most valid attempts to correct it. It is a form of false teaching. In many cases, these people were corrected for their theories by the ministers in the WCG or ACOG splinter. But, they never cut it loose, and always feel a need to infect others with it. This would be the cultic guru. Legends in their own minds.

Anonymous said...

Who is Wade Cox? He is an barely known fringe element of COG movement.

There has always been men, from all various religious denominations, who develop obscure beliefs alot of the time it is usually old worn out or obscure winds of doctrine: as the denial of Adam as the first human, animals in church, will Satan die, the hebrew calendar, postponements and so on... Nothing new....ALL topics appeared in the COG in the 1990's.

Anonymous said...

Uh, the Australian Bob Thiel?

Anonymous said...

Infinity is something which is boundless, limitless, or endless. (see Wiki). Therefore Infinity cannot be divided by a rational limited number.

Anonymous said...

Wade is really schmart.

Anonymous said...

Nobody has ever been to infinity. It's just bullshit.

Anonymous said...

It is when you leave h out.

Scout said...

Excellent article. I do not know who Cox is or the details of what he believes. I see this as a midrash involving unitarianism in conflict with trinitarianism. The only thing I would mention is that Doubting Thomas referred to Jesus as “ho theos” (“the God” in Greek). This is an articular locution reserved for the Most High God. If this term were inaccurately applied to Jesus, Jesus would have immediately jumped on it and corrected Thomas. Jesus let it stand although he never referred to himself in this way. Jesus as God is principally established by what Jesus did on earth, such as forgiving sins, rather than the use of any titles.

It has never been clear to me why there is such a preoccupation with various sorts of Arianism in the Millerite denominations. I even know of people who have left Armstrongism and joined various Arianist denominations (more recently than Westby and his followers). What is it that the denial of Jesus’ divinity accomplishes? Is there something more to this than product differentiation?

nck said...

A God that needs an article like this to introduce itself is a ridiculous God.

Nck

Anonymous said...

So the author supports the dominant Catholic and Protestant view?

How has this doctrine helped them over the centuries?

Not very much.