There is something almost impressive about the ability of the Philadelphia Church of God to turn an inconvenient question into an organizational emergency. After decades of being told that members must prove all things, examine the evidence, and distinguish truth from error, one might assume that asking about an old prophecy would be welcomed. Apparently, that assumption gives the leadership far too much credit.
Consider the prediction attributed to Gerald Flurry that Donald Trump would somehow drive PCG members out of America, across the Atlantic, and into the Cave of Adullam. That is not exactly a minor detail in the church's prophetic imagination. It is the sort of prediction one might expect members to remember, especially when the political circumstances that supposedly make it relevant have been discussed so enthusiastically. Yet, according to the letter, when members are asked whether they intend to examine Flurry's writings on the subject, the answer is a rather emphatic no. Apparently, proving all things is still encouraged-as long as nobody actually proves anything inconvenient.
And there lies the little problem. A prophecy that once sounded impressive from the pulpit can become remarkably awkward when it refuses to cooperate with reality. What is a prophetic organization to do? Admit that a prediction may have been mistaken? Revisit the evidence? Invite members to examine the original writings and reach their own conclusions? Perish the thought! Much safer to let the subject sink quietly into the institutional swamp and hope nobody remembers where it went.
The irony is that Armstrongism has spent decades telling its followers that they are different from everyone else because they supposedly examine the Bible, reject deception, and prove the truth for themselves. Yet the letter describes an organization in which members appear increasingly reluctant to question what they are told. The old slogan about proving all things seems to have acquired a rather convenient footnote: unless the thing being examined was written by the man at the top.
That is not spiritual discernment. It is organizational loyalty dressed up in religious clothing. A person should not have to surrender common sense, historical memory, or personal integrity at the church door in order to remain accepted. Nor should asking a reasonable question be treated like an act of rebellion. When a religious organization teaches people to fear questions, it should not be surprised when independent thinking eventually becomes an endangered species.
The letter also describes a culture of fear and suspicion, in which members worry about what other members might reveal and whether some private failing could cost them their place in the group. That is a grim indictment of any religious environment. A Christian community should be a place where people can grow in honesty, humility, compassion, and faith-not a neighborhood surveillance operation where everyone watches everyone else while wondering who might report them to headquarters.
And what happens to the old distinctions between right and wrong, truth and falsehood, honesty and deception? They become blurred when institutional survival takes priority over personal integrity. Suddenly, the important question is no longer whether something is true, but whether acknowledging it might upset the leadership. The compass still exists, of course; it has simply been handed to someone who insists that north is wherever the ministry says it is this week.
The letter's claim that the people of integrity have already left may be too sweeping to apply to every person who remains. There may well be sincere people inside PCG who are trying to make sense of what they have been taught. But that makes the situation more troubling, not less. Good people can remain in unhealthy environments because they are attached to friends, family, familiar routines, or beliefs they once held with conviction. Their presence does not prove that the system is healthy, and their doubts should not be dismissed as disloyalty.
Perhaps the most revealing test of any religious organization is not how loudly it proclaims its commitment to truth, but what it does when its own claims are questioned. Can members examine the writings of their leaders without being intimidated? Can an old prediction be revisited without excuses and evasions? Can a minister admit that something was wrong? Can a member disagree and still be treated with dignity?
Those are not dangerous questions. They are basic questions of honesty.
So the swamp metaphor is fitting-not because every person still sitting in the pews deserves to be dismissed, but because an organization that refuses to drain its own stagnant waters should not be surprised when the atmosphere becomes increasingly unpleasant. A church cannot keep demanding unquestioning loyalty, burying awkward predictions, and treating independent thought as a threat while continuing to congratulate itself on being the sole custodian of truth.
Eventually, the question becomes unavoidable: is the organization helping people follow Christ, or teaching them to follow an institution? Because when loyalty to a human leadership becomes more important than truth, the swamp does not need outside enemies. It is perfectly capable of sustaining itself.
The Swamp Creatures That Remain in PCG:
November 20, 2026
I think part of what bothers me so much about members in the PCG group today is that they are completely blind now and just following whatever their ‘leaders’ are telling them, instead of researching and proving true from false in the “doctrine” they are being given today, and more importantly what they have been given the past 36 years. When you ask members point blank to their faces, “are you going to look into Gerald Flurry’s writings about President Trump kicking you out of America, across the Atlantic ocean, and into the Cave of Adullam?”, with nasty little 12-year-old attitudes, they respond, “no.” They know full-well Gerald Flurry is full of shit. You can imagine how hard and fast PCG leaders today want to bury that particular GRF prophecy. It’s hanging around like a bad smell.
But members just go along with the programming. In their minds, their group membership is not about proving true from false values (like we do in mathematics) so that we know true from false. It’s not about right or wrong according to God’s instructions for right and wrong behavior. It’s not about actually doing what’s right and living an honest life with God and Jesus Christ leading them. It’s about following church [PCG] “leaders” who lie to them, no matter if it costs them their character to follow along.
You can see it in them when you talk to them. You can see how unsure they are. They don’t know. You can see the look of uncertainty on their faces as they process information. Not only do they NOT know what Gerald Flurry teaches, but they can’t make sense of cardinal directions anymore. They don’t know east from west. Up from down. Right from left. In from out. Top from bottom. Black from white. Their distinctions are completely scrambled. Their membership in the group today is not about living the right distinctions anymore. Like it used to be when they started with God after baptism.
You know what they are? They are afraid. They are afraid of their own family members (inside the group) telling their secret sins and getting kicked out of the group. That’s what their home-life-strategies center around. After 36 years, that’s the character they’ve become. Can you just imagine being that!? The truth is, the real and proven characters of integrity, substance, sincerity, quality, and truth (true righteousness) have already left the PCG group. The ones who prove true from false, know right from wrong, and do what’s right are already gone. That’s the good news. That’s the silver lining. Only the swamp creatures remain in the pot that’s starting to boil in the kitchen. –[name withheld]













